Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerde, nooit getransitioneerde vrouw die genderdysforie ervaart maar ervoor heeft gekozen transitie te weerstaan, omdat ik mijn dysforie zie als zelfhaat en niet als een signaal dat mijn lichaam fout is. Ik heb nooit testosteron genomen, een operatie gehad of stemtraining gedaan, ondanks een van nature tenor zangstem en een voorkeur voor mannelijke kleding die mannelijkheid ooit aantrekkelijk deed lijken. Ik ben actief in online detrans- en gendercritische ruimtes, kritisch over transitie als standaardbehandeling terwijl ik erken dat dysforie echt is, en ik verdedig vrouwenruimtes en de realiteit van de ervaringen van anderen. Ik beschrijf in dit materiaal geen specifieke diagnoses, therapie, trauma of relaties. Mijn huidige identiteit is die van een gedesisteerde vrouw die nog steeds dysforie voelt maar vastbesloten is transitie te weerstaan.
Volledig verhaal
I never actually transitioned, but I've spent a long time resisting the pull toward it, and I want to explain where I've ended up and why.
As far back as I can remember I've felt discomfort with being female, and I still do. In June 2020 I wrote that I related to the posts about dysphoria in this community and that I felt it too, but added that "it makes me sick and I know that it's stupid." That captures a lot of how I experience it: the dysphoria is real, but I've come to see it as something destructive rather than something to act on. In August 2020 I put it bluntly in a comment that got a lot of agreement: "Dysphoria *is* self-hatred." That framing matters to me because it reframes the whole thing — the feeling isn't evidence that my body is wrong, it's evidence that I've learned to hate myself.
I've never taken testosterone, never had any medical intervention, and never done voice training. I said so explicitly in January 2021 when someone asked about a deep voice: "I've never took testosterone or done voice training, but my singing voice is just like that anyway." My natural singing voice is a tenor, which is traditionally a male range, and that used to feel strange and confusing to me — I noted in June 2020 that it seemed like "it would be so much better being male and looking as a male." I also have wide feet, so I mainly wear boys' shoes because women's shoes are too tight. More broadly, I've always worn whichever clothes and shoes I want regardless of gender, because I value comfort over looking pretty. Those things — the voice, the feet, the clothing — fed the sense that I was somehow already leaning male, and I think they made transition feel more plausible and appealing than it should have.
I've never identified as detransitioned because I never transitioned. In June 2020 I said directly: "I have never transitioned, so I haven't detransitioned, but I'm trying to resist it." So I think of myself as someone who has desisted, or who is actively resisting — someone who experiences gender dysphoria but has chosen not to act on it. I've also asked in this community what the difference between "detransitioner" and "desister" actually is, because the glossary post seemed to use them in a different context than I expected.
My thinking about transition has hardened considerably over time. I'm critical of how transition is promoted as the default answer to dysphoria, and I've pushed back against people who claim all trans people are fetishists — I argued in June 2020 that such claims "completely ignore people who transition because of dysphoria (even if transition isn't really the right way to treat it)." That parenthetical is important: I acknowledge the dysphoria is genuine while still doubting that medical transition is the right treatment. I've also pushed back against blanket hostility toward men, noting the double standard of condemning generalizations about women while making them about men.
I'm active in this community and in broader gender-critical discussions online. I've asked pointed questions like "How do you know that you're not male?" to people asserting a trans identity, questioned whether re-transitioners should be included in this subreddit, defended women's spaces, and pointed people toward r/SSAWomen for bi and lesbian women. I've argued against the idea that a woman can't look androgynous and still be a woman, and I've defended the reality of other people's experiences when they're dismissed — in December 2022 I responded to someone minimizing a phenomenon by saying "just because it hasn't happened to you, it doesn't mean that it hasn't happened to other people."
On sexuality, I don't think I've stated anything explicit in these posts beyond engaging with lesbian and bi women's spaces. On mental health, I haven't described specific diagnoses, but the language of self-hatred and feeling "sick" about my own dysphoria suggests significant distress. I don't describe therapy, trauma, family dynamics, or relationships in this transcript.
Where I am now: I still experience dysphoria, but I've decided it's self-hatred rather than a signal to transition, and I'm resisting medical and social transition. I'm critical of transition as an approach, both for myself and increasingly skeptical of it as a general solution, while still acknowledging that dysphoria is real and painful for people.