Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde, gender-non-conforme man die ongeveer 4,5 jaar als transvrouw leefde op oestrogeen en spironolacton (ongeveer van mijn 24e tot 28e, eindigend in juni 2020) zonder operaties, en die detransitioneerde nadat hij zich tot het christendom bekeerde. Ik geloof dat mijn genderdysforie een symptoom was van borderline persoonlijkheidsstoornis, onopgemerkt autisme en een gewelddadig, alcoholistisch thuismilieu, en dat het behandelen daarvan het bijna liet verdwijnen. Ik heb nog restborstweefsel, een onregelmatig gelaserde baard, enkele genitale veranderingen, vermoeidheid en PTSS-achtige symptomen en soms intense spijt, al ben ik veel stabieler, beschadig ik mezelf niet meer en is mijn suïcidaliteit afgenomen — al heb ik minstens twee keer geprobeerd een einde aan mijn leven te maken en kampte ik meer dan tien jaar met suïcidale gedachten. Nu ben ik volledig tegen transitie en zie ik transgenderisme als seksistisch en een sekte, en pleit ik in plaats daarvan voor gender-non-conformiteit. Op dit moment ben ik een gedetransitioneerde man die zich identificeert als GNC-man met een feminiene kant, biseksueel.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and grew up in the southern USA with two alcoholic parents — my dad was a high-functioning alcoholic who neglected my mother and himself, and my mom was a drunk who emotionally abused me for years. Up until about age 8 to 10 I envisioned my adult self as female, and I had gender confusion since childhood, but I grew out of it. I was always feminine for a guy: naturally high estrogen for a male, slim shoulders, prominent hips, soft facial features, a naturally high androgynous voice, and never much muscle. I am a pianist, singer, and artist.
I was diagnosed with borderline personality disorder about 5 years into living as a woman (so around 2016), and I also had undiagnosed autism until my late twenties. I had a restrictive eating disorder, self-harmed for several years, self-medicated with marijuana, and struggled with depression and avoidant personality traits. I also had a restrictive eating disorder and later, in recovery, an eating disorder again.
At around age 24 I identified as gender queer and saw a therapist who encouraged me to crossdress as a way to experiment with gender expression. That led me toward medical transition. I had gender dysphoria as a child and again as an adult, and my deciding reason for transitioning was that I did not want to grow into an old man — the idea of aging as a masculine man disgusted me, and aging as a feminine/androgynous man sounded better. Almost everyone around me was supportive; no one stood in my way. I began hormones and socially transitioned in my mid/early twenties (around 2016, age 24). I was on estrogen and spironolactone — injections, which I administered myself — for about 4.5 years. I also had laser hair removal on a full beard (twelve sessions total, bought through Groupon in bulk). I voice trained as a trans woman, which gave me a passable female voice but cost me my ability to sing. I kept my nails long, which meant I had to give up playing piano. I passed fairly well as a woman.
I lived as a woman for about 4.5 years, from roughly ages 24 to 28. I was only happy the first year; after that it went downhill. My mental health deteriorated. I became increasingly anxious and somewhat agoraphobic, constantly worried that people could tell I was actually biologically male. I was sexually assaulted a couple of times while living as a woman, including once being drugged for sex. I did not regret transitioning until around 4 years in, a bit before my religious conversion — at the time I was self-medicating with weed and not really in touch with what I was feeling.
Around the same time I began to regret it, I moved back home to my broken parents (my mom newly drinking in addition to my dad), lost my best friend of 3 or 4 years, and dropped out of college, all in the same year. I had almost desisted before that. I also lost most of my gender dysphoria upon conversion to Christianity — God was the one who convinced me to detransition. I detransitioned in June 2020, at age 28, going off my hormones basically cold turkey because I didn't want pushback from doctors: I gave myself a half dose of my injection and then just quit.
Recovery from hormones was slow. For a long time I was sleeping 12 to 14 hours a day and was exhausted all the time; I had to drink coffee all day to get anything done, and I was physically weak. My testosterone came back to normal levels but my estrogen remained abnormally high for a long time. After about 8 months off hormones my genitals functioned fairly normally, though with less semen; after a year my sperm production had returned. My testes got bigger on hormones and stayed bigger. My penis had not returned to its pre-hormone size even after a year. I developed breast tissue — only an A cup, with puffy nipples — that I still had years later; I wear loose sweaters and think of the tissue as a side effect of a medication. My face stayed full and my facial hair, after laser, grew back only patchy. My strength slowly returned. I never had any surgeries, though I came close to getting an orchiectomy.
Detransition was hard socially. I lost my best friend after starting detransition, and the queer community wanted nothing to do with me. I live alone, am disabled, and have received social security income for about 7 years — I could not have survived without it. I can't work and at times could barely drive. I go to therapy twice a week and attend a CBT group, which helps. I later moved out of my parents' home, which helped a great deal.
After detransition I went back to my birth name — I never did a legal name change — because keeping it felt like reconciling with myself, like finally giving him a happy ending. For over a year I tried the 'normal guy look' but it didn't feel right. Eventually I embraced being a gender-nonconforming man: I paint my nails, keep them long, wear dangly earrings, heeled shoes, jewelry, pastels, and shop in both the men's and women's sections. I have bright blue hair. I live in a liberal city in the southern USA. I still get ma'ammed on the phone sometimes, and someone who had known me as a trans woman asked if I was transgender now, which I found funny. Misgendering barely bothers me now because my identity as a man is firm and based in reality.
Mentally I am much more stable. I no longer self-harm, my suicidality has decreased, and I no longer self-medicate with marijuana. I believe my gender dysphoria was a symptom of my BPD's identity disturbance, compounded by undiagnosed autism, trauma, and living with two alcoholic parents; treating those things made the dysphoria almost disappear. I still have occasional dysphoria and moments of intense regret over my body, and I think I have at least mild PTSD from the hormonal changes and from living that way — pseudo-flashbacks about it. I also have residual trauma: I now obsess over whether my preferences are male or female, something I never cared about before, and it has taken me a while to be able to listen to Avril Lavigne again.
I am bisexual, and I became attracted to women for the first time near the end of my time living as a woman; now I am even more attracted to them and can see myself with a wife and kids someday. I describe my sexuality as bi but gay-leaning, or 'sort of gay... in a weird place with my sexuality tbh.' I have been about 2 years free from porn. My libido is high and erections are normal enough, though I take finasteride, which affects them. Orgasms are worse than before hormones. I am about 2 years free from hormones as of 2022.
I have a sibling who is trans; we were trans together for a time. My mom is pro-trans. I do not go to church because I struggle socially, but I have a relationship with God — I am not religious in the practice sense, but I pray and try to do good. I have a primary care physician I've known for years who knows my full journey.
I have attempted suicide at least twice and have dealt with suicidal thoughts for over a decade, though I now have hope. I have also been a victim of sexual assault, including being drugged.
I now think transition is never the right option for anyone and that medical gender transition should be illegalized entirely. I view having gender dysphoria as a feeling you don't choose, but identifying as trans as a choice. I believe transgenderism is sexist, that it is a cult, and that it is a sin; I also believe homosexuality is a sin, and I hold conservative Christian views while describing myself as a Christian feminist. I advocate for gender nonconformity instead of transition, and I have been vocal about this online, including posting in detransition communities and arguing with people in trans subreddits (where I was banned and told to burn in hell). I have shared my story widely and wish I could take legal action just to get my story out there. I believe no one is 'really trans' — that's a lie used to gaslight detransitioners.
Currently I am a detransitioned man, gender-nonconforming, at peace much of the time but still working through regret, trauma, and occasional dysphoria. I am recording my first album at age 29. I feel more integrated and healthy now, and I would not go back to living as a trans woman for anything.