Alle verhalen

Van testosteron af, en online met iedereen in discussie

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd19
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die als man leefde, van testosteron af ging en nu betoogt dat transitie onomkeerbare schade veroorzaakt en dat detransitie vooral moeilijk is voor mensen met een vrouwelijk lichaam. Ik heb een biologisch-essentialistische kijk („Wat is een vrouw?”, „volwassen vrouwelijk mens”), bekritiseer zowel transactivisten als rechtse figuren zoals Matt Walsh, en verdedig transseksualiteit als een echte medische aandoening terwijl ik uithaal naar wat ik zie als trenders. In dit transcript heb ik geen specifieke leeftijden, transitiedata of operaties genoemd. Ik blijf online strijdlustig en krijg vaak negatieve scores voor mijn standpunten.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and transitioned to live as a man. By 2022 I was already detransitioning and spending a lot of time on detrans forums arguing with people about what transition can and cannot undo. I told people bluntly that 'you will never ever be deemed attractively feminine as a male' and that 'you will never be able to return to your former self. You can try to find happiness in your life, still' — I framed irreversible changes as 'a fact of life' that dysphoria sufferers had to accept rather than run from. I argued from lived experience that passing as male does not let you escape how society reads you: 'A crying man versus a crying woman doesn't have the same effect. Men are scary, women are sweet. You can NEVER escape that while passing as a male. Trust me on this one.' I insisted detransition is far harder in one direction than the other — 'It's different for ex trans dudes. It's far worse' and later 'It's different for detrans females' and 'Detransition is VERY different for MTFTMs versus FTMTFs.' I also described the reverse case: 'Feminine males are dehumanised. Masculine females are tolerated. Going back to manhood invokes loneliness and the male social pyramid. Zero support for males too.' I was skeptical of 'male brain/female brain' claims, asking people whether they had neuroscience degrees, what makes a brain male or female, and whether they believed in MRI scanners and hormone percentages. I mocked the idea: 'Brains are male and female... does that mean they can reproduce independent of the body they are in?' I argued sex is 'primarily down to sex organs carried by the individual who is labelled as one.' I was strongly critical of Matt Walsh and right-wing figures, saying they don't care about women's rights but about defeating liberals, and that privileged people can afford to be theoretical about gender while the rest of the world deals with mass rape, FGM, and domestic violence. I defended trans people's access to treatment, arguing 'transsexualism' is 'a physical mismatch of the brain from one sex to another' and a medical condition, and that professional help doesn't exist for it. I corrected my own terminology at one point: 'Gender =/= sexuality; I'd like to correct what I've previously spoken about: I mean transsexualism. Transsexual dysphoria is a medical condition.' I said if you didn't understand the pain of genital/body-development disconnect 'then you were NEVER trans in the first place, but a confused individual appropriating the transsexual condition.' I sparred repeatedly with a user called portaux, doubting they genuinely cared about detransitioners and demanding proof of claimed DMs. I also argued with religious critics, quoting Deuteronomy 22:5 against a self-described Christian and calling conversion therapy a dead end given its suicide rate. I pushed back on suicide-related rhetoric, saying 'I genuinely know of people who struggle with gender dysphoria who silently attempt it because it hurts them so much.' In early 2023 I repeatedly posted 'What is a woman?' and 'What is a female?' in threads, insisting 'Basic biology 101' and 'Facts are facts,' and telling someone 'No, you're an adult female.' I criticized trans people who 'put zero effort into transitioning and think it is just self identifying.' I asked another detransitioner why they were still taking patches: 'Shouldn't your body be making them now you are off T?' — implying I had been on testosterone myself and stopped. In March 2023 I told someone 'There's enough damage to put you in the grey zone. Men and sapphic women can tell. You must accept this biological reality and come to terms with it.' I was often combative, calling opponents trolls, 'chronically online,' or mentally ill, and my comments frequently drew negative scores.