Alle verhalen

Drie jaar testosteron, en haar zangstem was de prijs

Vrouw · GedetransitioneerdEerste dysforie 6 → Transitie 20 → Detransitie 232,8K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw: ik twijfelde vanaf ongeveer mijn 6e aan mijn sekse, kwam op mijn 15e uit als trans, begon op mijn 20e met testosteron, gebruikte het 3 jaar en detransitioneerde op mijn 23e. Mijn dysforie wortelde in geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat, lesbofobie, trauma van een narcistische, gewelddadige moeder en angst voor vrouwelijkheid in mijn lichaam, en vervaagde toen mijn brein rijpte en ik met feminisme in aanraking kwam. Ik heb over het geheel genomen geen spijt van mijn transitie — ik zeg dat het mijn leven misschien gered heeft — maar wel van blijvende veranderingen zoals het verlies van mijn zangstem, en ik zou het niet nog eens doen als ik terug kon. Na het stoppen met T kreeg ik een zware emotionele inzinking, met suïcidale gedachten, die in de maanden daarna sterk verbeterde, naast aanhoudende lichamelijke effecten zoals acne op de kaaklijn, vaginale droogte en een lichte terugkeer van de menstruatie. Ik identificeer me nu als een gelukkige gendernonconforme lesbienne, ben actief in detrans-gemeenschappen en pleit voor voorzichtigheid, therapie en een leeftijdsgrens vóór transitie voor anderen.

Volledig verhaal

I am a detransitioned woman from Norway who was born female. I first questioned my sex as early as age 6, before I had any knowledge of transgenderism. I learned about transgenderism at 15 (elsewhere stated as 16) and came out as trans then, identifying as a straight trans man. I debated the decision for about 5 years before starting testosterone at age 20, and I was on T for 3 years (ages 20-23), stopping around July/August 2020. I never had top surgery, bottom surgery, or any other surgical intervention. I detransitioned at 23. Before transition I was a gender nonconforming, highly analytical lesbian who could not relate to other women. My dysphoria had many roots: internalised misogyny from a very young age (I wanted to be accomplished and not adhere to feminine gender norms and naively thought being a man was my only ticket), internalised lesbophobia, revulsion at being aware my body could become pregnant, fear of being the physically weaker sex, fear of being overpowered or pursued by men, and gender nonconformity. I also grew up in a matriarchal household with a mother who was a narcissist, controlling, abusive, and misandrist, peddling the idea that women are superior and men are pigs — this pushed me down a misogynist rabbit hole. I also had to combat abuse/trauma growing up, though I say my dysphoria had less to do with that and more to do with societal factors. I was suicidal at times because I could never become biologically male, and I attempted suicide. I did not use Tumblr, had no trans friends, and never considered myself part of the LGBT or queer community; I was influenced mainly by the idea of a 'magical gender brain' which let me believe I was really a straight man inside. After transitioning I joined transmed and anti-SJW circles and was judgmental of people I saw as less trans. During my 3 years on T I passed as male. I experienced vaginal atrophy, loss of my singing voice (I was unable to cry on T), and mental changes from the hormones. Around the 3-year mark my dysphoria and insecurities about being female quietly dwindled to nothing — the realisation came suddenly, 'as if someone had just flicked a switch in my brain.' I attribute this partly to brain maturation (the brain finishes developing around 25) and partly to exposing myself to feminism and gender abolitionism, which helped me undo harmful beliefs about women. My health was declining (vaginal atrophy) and I was panicky about possibly needing a hysterectomy. I posted on r/detrans describing my situation, and a commenter suggested my brain had matured enough that the brain/body misalignment had ceased, which resonated deeply. I stopped T cold turkey on Nebido injections with no problems. After detransitioning I experienced an emotional rollercoaster: the first few post-HRT periods brought suicidal thoughts, impulsivity, and frequent crying (after being unable to cry on T), but this improved significantly over time to manageable mood swings. At around 8-9 months off T my period had returned (light, 2 days, no cramping), but I had stubborn jawline acne that was worse than on T, persistent vaginal dryness, a more constricted urethra, chronic silent (laryngopharyngeal) reflux, and a plummeted libido. My voice is androgynous rather than masculine but I still pass; I train it occasionally. I go by feminine pronouns in real life because they're accurate, and male pronouns online. I kept a gender-neutral version of my birth name because I'm GNC and comfortable with it. I do not regret transitioning overall — I say it may well have saved my life and gave me perspective I couldn't have gleaned otherwise, and living as a man for 3 years opened my eyes and got me into feminism. However, I find some permanent physical changes regrettable, especially losing my singing voice, and I say that if I could go back in time I wouldn't have transitioned, because the cons outweigh the pros. I no longer experience real sex dysphoria, only an occasional sense that being female is inconvenient. I am now a happy GNC lesbian, and I relate better to lesbians than to heterosexual women. I slept with two men before transition, which was deeply uncomfortable, and concluded heterosexuality wasn't for me — though while identifying as a man I got to be straight for a few years. I am very active in detrans communities, offering DM support and advice. I hold critical views of transition, especially for people under 25, and I advocate therapy, time-gating, and addressing trauma, internalised sexism, and homophobia before considering HRT. I believe gender is entirely a social construct, that transgenderism is not innate, that being trans is a choice while having dysphoria is not, and that gender dysphoria is a mental illness — a rational response to a sexist and homophobic environment. I am supportive of trans people as individuals and use preferred pronouns as courtesy, but I am critical of trans activism, the medicalisation of dysphoria, and the treatment of detransitioners, butch lesbians, and gender nonconforming people. I consider myself left-wing/feminist and reject attempts to recruit detransitioners to the political right.