Alle verhalen

Een jaar 'hij' zijn, en beseffen dat het probleem zelfhaat was

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd79
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw: ik ben nooit medisch getransitioneerd, al heb ik ongeveer een jaar sociaal geëxperimenteerd met als jongen behandeld worden voordat ik besefte dat het me het gevoel gaf voorgelogen te worden in plaats van bevestigd. Ik heb autisme en al lang milde dysforie, maar concludeerde dat transitie me alleen zou doen obsederen over doorgaan en nooit cis zijn, en dat mijn echte probleem zelfhaat is, geen gender. Mijn dysforie verergerde toen mijn online en offline gemeenschappen verschoof van overwegend vrouwen naar vooral transmasc/non-binair, wat geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat activeerde en het gevoel achtergelaten te worden in het 'mindere gender'. Ik verliet die ruimtes en leef nu rustig, ga om met premenstruele stemmingsinstorting en gebruik dagboekschrijven, cyclus bijhouden en grondingstechnieken. Ik ben niet tegen transitie voor anderen, maar geloof dat geestelijke gezondheid en andere kwesties eerst moeten worden aangepakt, en ik ben blij dat ik nooit met hormonen ben begonnen.

Volledig verhaal

I am a woman with autism who never medically transitioned, though I came close to considering it and spent about a year socially experimenting with being treated as a guy online and among friends. My dysphoria was mild for most of my life; as a teenager I spent time wishing I had been born male or hoping to look androgynous enough to pass for one, but my mother would have objected and being trans wasn't something I even knew was an option — the only representation I saw was jokes about trans women on TV. It wasn't until I was an adult, out of school, that I learned about trans issues, and my immediate thought was 'if I was a teenager today I would be trans.' I mostly ignored that thought because I was working hard on learning to love my gender. What reopened the wound was a shift in my social circles over roughly the past decade. I had deliberately built communities of other women to combat my dysphoria, but those spaces — the digital art community, the fanfiction community, the RP community, even feminist writers I admired — gradually became places where women were a minority, not because more men joined, but because people came out as transmasc or nonbinary. My offline circle, made up of terminally online/fandom friends, shifted the same way. Every time a woman I knew said 'actually I'm nonbinary' or 'I'm transmasc' I felt upset and betrayed, like I was being left behind as the only person stuck in the inferior gender, which confirmed my fear that being a woman was something everyone would escape from if they could. I also had complicated negative feelings about everyone around me suddenly being autistic — self-diagnosed or late-diagnosed — when I had spent my whole life being 'The Autistic One' in those same circles, people who had thought my autism made me weird. I revisited whether I was trans and spent about a year trying to be 'A Dude' within those communities, but not outside them. It didn't work: because everyone already knew me, their use of he/him and 'bro' felt like they were humoring me by lying, and I felt lied to rather than validated. Going by he/him online with strangers felt great, but I realized I had no interest in rebuilding my entire life just to feel validated as a man, and I knew that obsessing over passing and never being a cis man would overwhelm everything else in my life, since I'm prone to rumination. I also noticed I had less dysphoria when the characters I wrote had a more even gender split rather than slash-dominated fic. Forcing myself to confront all of this made me realize I was reacting to my communities' values and internalized misogyny, and that I needed to leave those spaces rather than transition. I've become something of a hermit because every interest-based community I try has the same dynamics. I'm not anti-transition for others — I explicitly say some people navigate being trans healthily — but I concluded it would be a net negative for me specifically, partly because of practical realities: my terrible executive function means appointments derail my whole day, I already struggle to remember my medications (I messed up my birth control schedule and period tracker by forgetting pills), and I knew I would fixate on passing. If I could press a button and become a cis man I would be tempted, but surgery and hormones for something that only resembles what I actually want isn't worth it, and it wouldn't solve my underlying problem, which is that I hate myself. I am married to a husband; when I tearfully told him I didn't know who I was and needed to find my authentic self, he told me 'You know yourself, you just don't like yourself. You should stop trying to find yourself and start trying to like yourself more,' which I grudgingly conceded was right. I have a lifelong interest in autism research and have shared studies on gender identity, sexual orientation, and brain sex differences in autism. I experience premenstrual magnification of anxiety and ADHD traits, with one week out of every month of severe self-loathing and despair; birth control made no difference and had side effects, so I manage it non-medically. I've developed coping strategies I share with others: tracking my cycle to anticipate bad days, value card sorting, listing traits I wish I had and traits I admire in others, maintaining a prioritized skills-to-learn list to redirect myself from rumination, and grounding exercises that force attention onto the external physical world when my brain fixates on gender.