Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up in Ontario, Canada. Looking back, I can trace the roots of my transition to childhood trauma: a boyfriend of my mother's exposed himself and touched me for years, and my mother often brought me around older men who were inappropriate toward me. I felt sexualized and abused as a child and young teen, and I have said plainly that I transitioned because I was so uncomfortable being seen as a woman after being sexualized and abused so much. I also spent a lot of time on Tumblr, and I often blame that site for my transition — I believe that without its influence and access to so many people telling me these things, I would never have even thought about it, and I would probably have found a healthier coping mechanism than taking hormones to change my body rather than heal my mind.
I started socially transitioning at 14 and presented as male for about six to eight years. I started testosterone at 17 and was on HRT for roughly four to six and a half years (I have given slightly different figures at different times — '4 years' in 2020, '6 years' and 'almost 7' in later posts). I was never diagnosed with gender dysphoria and never attended therapy for it; all I had to do in Ontario was call and ask to see a specialist in another town, and about a month after my appointment, where the doctor went over symptoms and side effects, I started hormones. I have written that this was very dangerous: 'if I was made to wait until I was 20 or went to therapy to talk out these feelings, I would have never transitioned.' A lot of personal reasons, insecurities, and uncomfortableness led me to believe I would be happier as someone completely different.
By 18, about a year after starting HRT, I had begun writing journal entries about how hopeless and trapped I felt. I remember feeling incredibly embarrassed that I had made all this effort to change and then wanted to change back. T ruined my self-image and made me feel insecure in every social setting; I hated how I looked, sounded, and was perceived, and dating as a trans man was a nightmare that made me lonelier than I already was. I identified as a gay man but no cis gay guys were interested, so I only dated trans men or AFAB people long-distance, and I did not enjoy it.
I began detransitioning around 2020, stopping testosterone about a year before my June 2020 post (I have said I was off T for 10 months then, and later that I have been off for 3 years as of late 2022). Socially detransitioning was the scariest thing I have ever had to do and I felt deeply embarrassed, but I have never been prouder of myself since. My family switched back to my birth name and pronouns so easily that it felt like it never happened, which hurt because it made me feel they had never taken my identity seriously. Close friends were accepting, but childhood friends who had ignored me the whole time I was 'a boy' suddenly reconnected and added me on Facebook now that I was a girl again — I called that shady.
Physically, detransition brought real changes and real problems. I gained weight very quickly after stopping T — my breasts went up three cup sizes and my hips got big, and I am covered in stretch marks, 'like my body was starved for estrogen.' I lost breast tissue on T, and the rapid regain left my breasts saggy and sometimes not noticeable, which adds to being misgendered. I experienced heavy male-pattern baldness on T and had a five-o'clock shadow 24/7; I have had 12 professional laser sessions over a year plus maintenance every six months, which removed my neck/jawline/chin hair and greatly reduced my upper lip. Body hair is permanent but lighter. I also dealt with clitoral shrinkage on T. For about a year after stopping T I was exhausted constantly no matter how much I slept or ate, needing daily naps. I started birth control pills about a few months into detransition to level out my hormones, control acne and mood swings, and feminize; I have now been on some form of hormones since I was 17 and have been on birth control for about three years as of late 2022, describing those years as 'an emotional hell' and wanting to know my normal. I tried stopping birth control for about two weeks and lost clumps of hair in the shower from the estrogen dip, so I went back on. I also had a painful invasive dental surgery and am in braces costing $8,500.
The hardest ongoing issue is my voice. It dropped very deep on T and I also had a flamboyant, gay-coded manner of speaking from my time identifying as gay. Now, even though I pass well, dress and present feminine and goth with long dark hair, people constantly mistake me for a trans woman or call me 'sir' the moment I speak — on the phone, with a mask on, on Zoom, in VRChat and game voice chat, and from telemarketers I have gotten into arguments with. Friends admit they noticed my voice when they met me, which embarrasses me. My boyfriend reassures me but I suspect he is biased. I cannot afford voice feminization surgery and am intimidated by voice training because people in my life do not know I used to be trans. I have said being gendered the way I fought for years to be, when I no longer want it, is devastating, and that being perceived as a trans woman when I am not makes me feel hopeless. I still sometimes look in the mirror and see the boy I used to be, and I compare myself to women on Instagram and TikTok and do not feel 'woman' enough, even though I am biologically female.
Sexually and romantically, detransition forced me to face that I am simply not attracted to women and am not as queer as I thought. I had avoided accepting that I was straight. After detransitioning I dated as a feminine-presenting non-binary person for a while, used Tinder to filter for people cool with my situation, and eventually found my current boyfriend, who listens to me vent about my dysphoria and is respectful and non-judgmental. My sex and romantic life is much better now dating the sex and gender I actually like.
On causes, I believe childhood sexual trauma and Tumblr influence were the primary drivers; I have also said anything can trigger it but especially unnerving, traumatizing events early in life. I do not regret my time as a trans person entirely — I feel I learned a lot and that transitioning helped me become more comfortable in my skin at the time — but I do regret transitioning overall, while no longer feeling embarrassed about it because I love who I am now. I wish I had been made to wait or attend therapy. I have organized and run a DeTrans Support Discord server for detrans, desisting, and questioning people, and I frequently counsel others to disconnect from trans-related content online, to ask themselves whether they see themselves as a happy old man or woman, and to detransition for themselves rather than for other people. I am critical of how easily hormones are handed out, of transitioning becoming a trend among young people influenced online, and of being told I was 'never trans' — I insist my experiences as a trans person were real and should count. I am not transphobic but would rather choke than be considered part of the trans community now. Overall I am much happier, more confident in my body, and a better person to myself and others than I was before.