Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een permanent gedetransitioneerde man die twee keer transitioneerde (elke keer ongeveer anderhalf jaar op HRT) voordat ik tijdens de pandemie abrupt stopte. Ik transitioneerde uit wanhoop — autisme, sociale angst, depressie, zelfhaat, isolatie, pornogebruik en wat AGP deden trans zijn lijken als de enige uitweg uit een ellendig leven. Ik besefte dat het enige echte voordeel vrienden hebben was, niet de hormonen zelf, waar ik me vreselijk door voelde. Ik ben nu lichamelijk en geestelijk gezond, gebruik meditatie om opdringerige gedachten te beheersen en blijf kritisch over genderideologie, en sta voorzichtig open voor het idee dat sommige mensen met extreme dysforie baat kunnen hebben bij transitie.
Volledig verhaal
I grew up as a male and started feeling that I was trans after reading webcomics with trans stories in them — reading those stories made me strangely emotional, and after that I was constantly thinking about the idea, and the more I thought about it the more I hated my body the way it was. I convinced myself I must be transgender. Looking back, I think I sort of convinced myself I was trans because I thought it was a better alternative to being who I was at the time.
At the root of it was a deeply unhappy life: I was completely socially inept, had no friends for years, felt hopeless about my future, hated both my body and who I was as a person, and felt as if I would never be able to date anyone. I have autism, and I felt pretty deeply uncomfortable with myself because of it — struggling to socialize made the idea of transition more appealing. I also think autistic overfixation played a role: I got mentally stuck on transition as the one solution to all my problems. I also suspect I had undiagnosed ADHD that I could have been medicated for. On top of that I had social anxiety, depression, and had been on SSRIs (citalopram), which I believe may have contributed to my dysphoria in some way. I also had some AGP, though not to a very intense degree, and I was using pornography — I suspect I would have been fine if I had just quit pornography.
I transitioned twice. The first time, I desisted for about a year before transitioning again. During that first desistance I was not able to confront the problems that caused me to transition in the first place — some combination of social anxiety, depression, and discomfort with being an autistic man. I was miserable, with a deep hatred for myself, and whenever these issues came up I'd think about transitioning again; I had this coping mechanism of fleeing to the idea of transition whenever I felt hopeless, until it was something I was constantly thinking about. So I transitioned again, and that was an absolute disaster, but I kept going for over a year because I thought it was the only option I had left — I didn't really think I had a life to go back to.
I was on HRT for about a year and a half the second time, and about the same the first time. One day I just stopped taking the pills, cold turkey — it was terrible for about a week and then I started to feel a lot better. I detransitioned during the pandemic. I didn't have much of a social life pre-transition, and after transition I had a pretty decent social life, which made it easy to think the transition itself was what helped me; when I had time to myself I realized I was actually a lot worse than before. The pandemic isolation also gave me time to think about why I transitioned to begin with and to remember that it was more or less out of desperation.
The key question that contributed to my detransition was 'What am I actually getting out of this?' — what I was getting wasn't anything I couldn't have had without taking hormones. I was dressing in a way I enjoyed and felt comfortable socially; I just took a weird and difficult route to accomplish something that could have been easy. I also realized that the only happiness I was getting from transition was because I actually had friends for once, and that the hormone aspect was actually making me feel awful. At a certain point the good feelings wore off and I started to crash — I didn't want to wear dresses or makeup, I just wanted to stay on my computer and wear sweatpants every day.
I regret that I waited until gynecomastia surgery to actually start taking the steps I needed to move on with my life — it was just more wasted time. I had gynecomastia from the hormones, and I noted that depending on breast growth a binder might not even be needed and it shouldn't stop a person from living their life.
It took me a while after detransitioning to really get things together, but I feel I've taken a much healthier attitude towards life now. I've been feeling very healthy both mentally and physically these days. Meditation has done a lot of good for my mental health — I get intrusive thoughts a lot less and have more focus, and it helps me reel myself back in from occasional thoughts of gender envy rather than dwelling on them. I also credit hobbies and anything that keeps me from stewing in my own thoughts.
I'm permanently detransitioned now. I'm still on the fence about whether there's such a thing as a 'real' trans person, but it seems like some people benefit from it enough that I can't be totally against transition for everyone — though I think it should be avoided if at all possible when a person can live a satisfactory life otherwise, since from what I've seen transition rarely leads to positive outcomes and usually only in very clear-cut cases. I think HRT only really benefits people with extreme dysphoria, and that it tends to have positive effects initially and then result in long-term mental health issues. I'm critical of nonbinary identity, of gender ideology being taught to kids, and of the idea that people have an innate internal gender identity. I believe biological sex is tied to gametes and that the biological definitions of man and woman are the most important ones to preserve. I'm willing to have my story politicized if it prevents others from making the same mistakes. I've also noted that many trans and detrans people are very neurotic and unable to get a thought out of their heads once it's there.