Alle verhalen

Kunstacademie, 2015 en een decennium een label verdedigen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd2,5K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik werd als meisje geboren, was al androgyn en identificeerde me vanaf ongeveer 2015, op de kunstacademie, als trans non-binair, na jaren van kleine stapjes zoals nagellak, kapsels en een vrouwelijke spelling van mijn naam. Ik heb inmiddels gedesisteerd en identificeer me nu met mijn geslacht als genderonconforme vrouw, al heb ik nog vrouwelijke kleding in mijn kast en omschrijf ik mezelf als neurodivergent (ADHD). Ik heb spijt van het ongezonde, gepolitiseerde begrip van geslacht en gender dat ik had, en noem de jaren die ik besteedde aan het verdedigen van mijn trans identiteit ‘een verspilling van mijn tijd’, al zeg ik dat ik geen spijt heb van de non-binaire periode zelf. Ik beschrijf in dit transcript geen eigen medische ingrepen en meld geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging sinds mijn detransitie. Ik ben kritisch over moderne transideologie maar zeg dat transitie voor sommigen goed kan werken, en ik pleit voor lange periodes van ‘kleine stapjes’ in genderonconformiteit vóór enige medische transitie.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and I identified as trans nonbinary for a period, and I have since desisted and come to identify with my sex as a woman. My gender nonconformity and gender questioning went on for a long time — I've said that gender, whether gender politics, my transition, my detransition, or gender criticism, has been 'very occupying for almost fifteen years.' I went to an art college, where I was already androgynous, and I found myself identifying as trans nonbinary in response to the cultural moment in 2015. Half of my artist friends later became nonbinary or trans. I took what I now call 'baby steps' toward my gender experience years before that: trying out nail polish, hair styles, feminine cuts of clothing, and a feminine spelling of my real name. It was years of androgyny before I had ever thought of identifying as trans. I have said I felt pressured to be trans to begin with because no one understood gender nonconformity outside of a trans identity. I now describe myself as desisted rather than medically detransitioned. In this community I've explained the distinction: 'detrans: medical transition, desist: social transition.' I've said 'I desisted and still have gestures of feminine clothes in my wardrobe.' I don't currently identify as trans. I've said I 'just identify as "male" now' in one comment addressed to a male detransitioner — but elsewhere I've written about still having trouble calling myself a 'man' given my experiences, and I've told others 'You can be a she/her and be the same person you are now,' and I've said 'Life is much easier and clearer when you identify with your sex.' I've also said I'm 'still a bit androgynous and enjoy that part of myself without needing to conform to masculinity.' Given that I was born female and transitioned in a female-to-trans direction, I read my current identity as a desisted, gender-nonconforming woman. On causes, I've reflected that I fell in with 'a really anti-social feminist crowd that hated men, and it hurt my relationship with my sex badly.' I've also said I learned 'a very harsh critical version of what it means to be a "man"' and that it hurt me. I've described my own thinking as tending 'to intellectualize and obsess — in my hobbies, politics, philosophy, and unfortunately, gender.' I've identified as neurodivergent: 'because we're neurodivergent (I have ADHD too), you may have different interests and relate to culture differently than your peers of the same sex.' I've come to feel that my difficulty relating to most other men isn't a gender identity but that 'I'm neurodivergent and creative,' and that I relate 'super well to other artsy ADHDers.' I've also said I don't connect well to most other men and 'in a way, I feel as if I'm only passing as one.' I've described my time identifying as nonbinary positively in part: 'I was nonbinary and do not regret that time in my life. It was a beautiful and creative experience for me. Part of my journey. But I had an unhealthy politicized understanding of sex and gender that I do regret.' I've said that when I was trans I was 'constantly seeking out how society was oriented to victimize me,' that I 'saw oppression around every corner and obsessively intellectualized defensive justifications for my identity,' and that looking back 'it was all upsettingly avoidant narcissistic and deluded.' I've said that sustaining an artificial identity put me in a defensive state: 'I know I was more defensive and neurotic when trans,' and 'It caused a lot of distress to justify my trans identity to myself.' On what moved me toward desisting, I've described a relief: 'One massive relief to desisting has been growing out of the self-victimizing oppression conspiracies that are so encouraged in trans spaces.' I've said that when you detransition 'you come to find that what was "transphobic" was actually just genuine concern and critique of bad ideas all along.' I've said I've 'explored other theories, deconstructed "trans ideology," and tried to just put the subject down several times. I've even deleted my Reddit, but keep coming back here.' I've described the current ideology as having been 'an abuse to the public' and said of my earlier defense of it: 'I don't know how I spent so much of my life defending this or justifying my false identity. It was such a waste of my time.' I don't describe specific medical interventions of my own in this transcript — no hormone or surgery details are given for me — so I have no stated medical complications or fertility concerns of my own. I have discussed testosterone reference ranges in general terms when advising others. On sexuality and sexual theories of transition, I've been exploring AGP/AAP frameworks: 'I'm just learning about AGP/AAP lately and figuring out where I sit,' and I've asked others 'Ever hear of autoandrophilia (AAP)?' and 'Are you AGP/AAP?' I've said 'I wonder how many other ex-transmen in the sub relate?' I've described AAP as 'an inward heterosexuality' — 'Basically, you're straight but you enjoy being the man in your straight sex. "Becoming what you love."' I've also said I've 'come to realize, despite all the talk about gender, this has all just been good ol' fashion transexualism all along' in some cases. I've said homosexuality 'is not a lifestyle, it's just same sex attraction.' I've mentioned my own use of pornography: 'I only use it every other time now, and I feel more connected to my sexuality,' and I've cautioned someone about hentai. On adversity, I've described falling in with an anti-social feminist crowd that hated men, and I've described the distress of justifying a trans identity. I don't describe family rejection or abuse in this transcript. On social life, I've said I live in a fairly conservative area where people 'just see me as "artsy" (and maybe sometimes assume I'm gay),' and that I wear a few androgynous fashion gestures — certain cuts of clothes, earrings, perfume — but wear clothes appropriate for my body type for the most part. I've described having trans friends and finding it hard to watch them: 'I can respect their decisions, but one of them just cannot stop peppering in propaganda in our convos. It's super awkward. I find myself biting my tongue a lot. They seem so unwell...' I've said 'almost all non-trans people privately wanted us to detransition and snap out of this the entire time.' I've described having had accounts harassed: 'I once had several messages calling me slurs and hate because I said most transwomen don't pass well and that passing was an unhealthy goal. On a previous account, I had all my posts shared and downvoted. I've had to delete one or two accounts because of it.' I've also described trying to talk a close friend out of starting HRT — a friend identifying as nonbinary after a brutal breakup with a radical nonbinary anarchist who shamed them for being a man. I worried a gender therapist would 'seal the deal,' said 'I don't think anyone else in their life is willing to stop them,' and described being scared to confront them directly because they're borderline and 'already cut off their elderly father for not having the hippest anarchist queer politics.' I've said I'm 'at a point where it's either they come back to reality or I have to move on.' On regret, I regret the 'unhealthy politicized understanding of sex and gender' I held, and I've called the years spent defending and justifying a trans identity 'such a waste of my time.' I've said I don't regret the nonbinary period itself. I've said 'I still have trouble calling myself a "man" given my experiences. But I'm working on it. And this new direction feels more honest.' On my attitudes toward transition for others, I've said: 'People can transition if they want to, but 90% of the modern trans movement is neo-religious garble. You don't have to appease the cult once you left it, but you can still respect people are doing what they feel is best for them individually.' I've also said 'Truth is, I do believe transition works well for some. I don't appreciate the prominence of the disagreeable postmodern ideological aspects in our culture, nor the coercion and censorship. But I don't want to see anyone hurt either.' I've advocated for 'baby steps' before medical transition: trying androgyny, loosening gender norms, therapy on one's relationship to one's sex, and reading about AAP first — 'In my opinion, I'm ok with transition but it should be a last resort in a series of baby steps of finding comfort in yourself.' I've said 'Try not to see trans as something you are, but rather, something you do.' I've said I don't believe in 'true trans': 'Everyone's just doing what they think will help.' I've also said 'I don't think being trans is merely a "delusion," although some contemporary ideologues and modern explanations are indeed delusional.' I've described detrans people as 'a powerful dialectic against gender identity essentialism' and said 'We represent a dialectical shift. Our stories are emblematic of a necessary shift in ideology.' I've said I'm no longer upset by the accusation of 'transphobia' and that it has become 'a meaningless thought terminating cliche.' I've agreed with Helen Joyce that gender ideology has become a 'postmodern neo-religion.' I've pulled out of the electoral system and no longer consume political media. I've said I've tried to get 'masculine' and 'feminine' out of my vocabulary.