Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde, biseksuele vrouw die zich als non-binair/transmasculien identificeerde en desisteerde na ongeveer zes jaar aan mijn gender te hebben getwijfeld, en concludeerde dat onderzoek naar affirmatieve zorg twijfelachtig was en dat gender zelf een nutteloze sociale constructie is. Mijn dysforie was ernstig en veroorzaakte studieschade, seksuele afkeer en herhaalde suïcidale gevoelens, en ik overwoog zelfdoding zowel voor als na het desisteren. Ik werd door de LHBT- en transgemeenschappen buitengesloten om mijn opvattingen, waardoor ik me hopeloos voelde, maar ik vond steun in een detrans partner en online detransgemeenschappen. Ik ging door vier nutteloze therapeuten heen en zocht een gendertherapeut die bereid was mijn opties daadwerkelijk te beoordelen in plaats van transitie op te dringen. Eind 2021 overwoog ik nog zelfdoding terwijl ik hoopte rust te vinden, en ik was van plan onderzoekspsychologie te volgen om detransitie te bestuderen.
Volledig verhaal
I have experienced gender dysphoria my entire life, mostly social at first and later physical. I began actively questioning my gender around 2015-2016, and by 2021 I had been questioning for about six years. I used to identify as non-binary and transmasculine, but I stopped identifying that way when I realized it was making things worse for me rather than better — I became more obsessed with and hateful toward my body and more upset about people addressing me by my birth sex.
I am a psychology undergrad, and I came to the conclusion that a lot of the research backing affirmative care models for trans people is questionable. Because of that, I desisted and hoped to treat my gender dysphoria with therapy and less invasive methods than physical transition. I also became skeptical of the whole concept of gender, coming to think of it as a useless social institution and a nuisance I didn't need to conform to. I worked on learning to love my body more, even if it wasn't the one I preferred, because it is still my body.
Despite that self-acceptance work, my social dysphoria remained severe. Every time someone referred to me by my birth sex, I felt depressed and sometimes suicidal, because I didn't want to be grouped into a category I didn't identify with. I described my dysphoria as having pronounced impacts on several areas of my life, including hindering my academic progress and rendering me completely repulsed by sex when I had once been very sexually active.
In September 2021 I was wrestling with whether to start testosterone. I said I would be going on T, that I would prefer to be gendered male over female, and that I didn't mind ending up looking too masculine. But I was not willing to risk my health by being on T for years — the most I would ever be on it would be about a year, starting on a low dose, just long enough to gain a more androgynous presentation, so I could stop if I wasn't comfortable continuing. I was mostly concerned about the philosophical questions: whether the person I would be on HRT, with a changed voice and somewhat changed emotions, would really be "me," and whether I would just be conforming to a concept that had brought me so much distress. I worried I might change my mind or reopen a goal I could never achieve.
I was completely ostracized by the LGBT community for my views. I was told by both close friends and strangers that my gender dysphoria must not be as bad as theirs, that it was "fake," and that I could never know what they had been through. I was told I was "never trans" and that my dysphoria wasn't as real as theirs, even though in many cases it was actually worse — I had contemplated suicide. I tended to avoid trans people in general because I had been invalidated and treated badly by several. I also described a college friend group that consistently invalidated me and wasn't there for me when things got rough; I cut ties with them.
I found support in detrans/desisted communities, including memes that let me find humor in what I had been through. My fiancée — later described as my partner, a bisexual and detrans person assigned male at birth — was, along with a few others, one of the only people who really listened to and respected my identity. I myself am bisexual, assigned female at birth, and detrans, and I prefer role-reversal type relationships. My partner and I call the societal messaging around gender "cultural gaslighting."
I went through four therapists. My parents kept me from therapy in high school. My first therapist was an intern at my college counseling center who was amazing but only worked with me about a semester before graduating. My second saw me for three sessions and told me not to worry about my issues because I was so young, then dropped me. My third said essentially the same thing over a longer period of time, which I called a huge waste of my money. My fourth, my current therapist as of October 2021, was amazing and gave me real skills, but she actively refused to counsel me on gender dysphoria because she felt she lacked the expertise and it wasn't ethical for her to do so, and she wanted me to see someone else in addition to her. I tried therapist shopping but due to COVID no one had room on their caseload. I felt I had reached the end of my rope and was starting to believe no one would ever help me.
I also found that adopting a philosophy rejecting gender as a whole helped my physical dysphoria more than my social dysphoria — it gave me a neutral stance on my body, seeing it simply as my body rather than a "feminine" body. I had never felt a close connection to my body in the first place.
As of late 2021 I was contemplating suicide and told another person in a similar position not to take their life, saying my hope was that we both could find some level of peace, and that I was much happier before I started questioning my gender. I wanted to become a research professor in psychology and further knowledge on detransition and alternative treatments for dysphoria, feeling an obligation to share what I knew, while also worrying that sharing it had made me miserable.