Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die naar transitie werd geduwd door seksisme en doordat ik als mollig jongensachtig meisje in het Zuiden als 'mislukte vrouw' werd behandeld, en als jonge persoon door Planned Parenthood op testosteron werd gezet. Ik detransitioneerde, liet mijn haar groeien om weer als vrouw gezien te worden, had een borstlift en leef nu in het noorden, waar ik me presenteer als mijn geslacht. Ik geloof dat mijn transitie werd gedreven door geïnternaliseerde misogynie en een verlangen te ontsnappen aan het zijn van een geseksualiseerde vrouw, en ik neem gedeeltelijk verantwoordelijkheid dat ik de blijvende effecten van HRT vooraf niet onderzocht, terwijl ik ook mijn ouders de schuld geef dat ze het mogelijk maakten. Ik ben nu uitgesproken kritisch over transitie, vooral voor minderjarigen, en vergelijk het met het amputeren van gezonde ledematen, en ik verwerp de gangbare detransitiegemeenschap als door trans mensen gerund. Ik heb sociale angst gehad en beveel DGT met radicale acceptatie aan; ik vind mezelf nu mooi en heb relaties met vrouwen.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up in the South, where I was a chunky kid and a tomboy with short hair. Growing up I experienced intense misogyny both inside and outside my home, and I was treated as a 'failed woman' because I didn't fit the mold of a pretty, delicate, feminine girl. That treatment is what pushed me toward transition — I came to believe I must actually be a man, or at least a 'third thing' like nonbinary, in order to be accepted. I was pushed toward HRT by Planned Parenthood, and I went on testosterone.
After detransitioning, I've come to see my transition as rooted in internalized misogyny and sexism — an attempt to escape being a woman, and especially an attempt to escape being a sexualized or desirable woman and all the baggage that comes with that. I also lost weight at some point and, in my own words, 'realized I was beautiful and wanted to be a woman again.' I now believe that being a woman isn't a feeling — I'm just a woman with a dominant personality, and I wish my younger self had been exposed to better role models and more worldviews rather than being funneled toward hormones.
Detransitioning socially was something I did gradually — I changed my email signature, told only my trusted supervisor at work, started dressing femininely, and let everyone else just figure it out. One of the hardest parts of detransition for me has been the social signaling around appearance. I've had short hair my whole life, and I've watched as pixie cuts went from being simply 'a girl's haircut' to a universal signal that a female is trans or nonbinary. When I presented in a gender-nonconforming way, people stopped gendering me correctly and assumed I was trans or nonbinary — which I did not want. The only way I 'pass' as cisgender again is by growing my hair out long enough to be read as a woman. I bought a nice wig from UNICE to tide myself over while my natural hair (which I describe as beautiful curly ginger) grows out. I also had laser hair removal and dealt with skin irritation afterward.
I have had a breast lift and I'm very happy with the result — I've said I 'can't wait to get a lift myself' in one comment while discussing someone else's, and in another I praised a natural-looking result with tattoos covering scars. I've also discussed bottom growth from testosterone as a 'non-refundable purchase' — a permanent change that isn't reversed when you stop T.
On the question of responsibility, I take a nuanced view. I do think detransitioners need to take at least partial accountability for not doing their own research before starting HRT — I compare it to taking Accutane, where the doctor gives you a rundown and you do a cost-benefit analysis yourself. But I'm also deeply critical of my parents, who I feel still pat themselves on the back for 'allowing me to explore myself' when in reality I was making medical decisions none of us understood the long-term consequences of. I was a minor at the time, which I argue makes it parental neglect.
I've become very outspoken about my views on transition, particularly for minors. I don't believe 'trans' exists as an identity — I view it as pure ideology and very harmful. I compare transition to amputating the healthy limb of someone with body integrity dysphoria, and argue that just as a doctor would be arrested for amputating a healthy limb to satisfy that compulsion, doctors shouldn't be removing the healthy breasts of teenage girls. I believe we shouldn't affirm psychosis or altered perceptions of reality — we should help people reconnect with reality, the way we wouldn't tell someone with anorexia that they're fat. I'm critical of what I see as 'trans hug boxing' and I've been attacked online for my views — people dig through my comment history, find that I've posted in detrans communities, and try to use it against me in unrelated conversations.
I'm skeptical of the mainstream detransition community — I've said that 'actual detrans is run by trans people' and that you're not allowed to criticize the trans movement or express negative experiences about having been trans there. I also believe detransition rates are underreported because follow-up research is outdated, and that there's a large population of FTMTF detransitioners with 'mutilated breasts' who were convinced by TikTok and Tumblr they were trans at young, vulnerable ages.
My current position on trans issues for adults is that adults can do as they please in their personal lives, but with firm lines: I won't be forced to think of someone as something they're not ('no thought crimes'), children should be left out of it, trans women shouldn't compete in women's sports where money or scholarships are on the line, I reject denial of biological sex as real and rooted in science, and if a male is in a female bathroom or changing room I leave immediately.
On mental health, I've dealt with social anxiety — I took buspirone in college for it — and I've recommended DBT therapy with a focus on radical acceptance to others, saying it will 'change your life.' I've also recommended that other women struggling with internalized misogyny start by making female friends and recognizing them as full, multifaceted human beings, and that they find women who embody the kind of woman they want to be.
Today I live up north in a city, present as my sex, and I consider myself beautiful — though I note that being visibly a woman comes with its own harassment: men yell, honk, whistle, slap my ass, or grab at my arm when I go running. I've told others that being a woman is hard but that we have more options and opportunities than any generation before, and that fearmongering about how hard it is to be female is defeatist. I'm in a relationship with women — I've referred to having had girlfriends with similar chests to mine.