Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I want to tell my story as honestly as I can, though most of what I've shared publicly has been in the form of advice and arguments rather than a single narrative. I am not trans — I have said so explicitly — but I have spent years engaging with detransition and gender-critical discussions, and my own experience shapes how I think about these questions.
I went through a period where I was on testosterone for a relatively short time — about three months — before stopping. When I talked about it, I framed it in terms of recovery: three months is worse than zero months, but not that bad in the larger scheme of things, and I believed I would make a complete recovery. I also noted that for every one day I had been off T, I had been on for 52 days, and that I needed to give my body more time rather than catastrophizing about my hair or other changes. I told others that the brain develops differently with different hormone levels but that this is difference, not damage, and that it was very unlikely to stunt intellectual ability.
I have dealt with OCD, and I have spoken about it directly. I compared gender transition to other compulsions, like hand-washing, arguing that acting on compulsions never truly relieves them and that transitioning would not fix OCD-related problems — it would just create more. I also referred to myself as a young woman affected by OCD and encouraged myself not to worry excessively about how my opinions affected others in online communities.
I have also referenced having experienced abuse in my past. In one comment I discussed how life experiences, including nonconsensual experiences, can contribute to sexual orientation, and I said it was okay if abuse influenced my sexual development. I tried to be compassionate with myself about this, telling myself there is no alternate, theoretical 'right' version of myself that is better than the one who exists and made it through.
On guilt, I was told (and I echoed back) that I was the only person preventing myself from putting things behind me and moving on, and that I hadn't done anything that would cause significant changes to my normal development. I have suggested therapy for guilt and lingering issues.
My views on transition have become increasingly critical over time. I questioned whether gender dysphoria could even be properly diagnosed, whether it exists as a stable category, and whether transition has been rigorously compared to other treatments or no intervention in large-scale long-term studies. I argued that if gender is a social construct, it would be cheaper, simpler, less risky, and less invasive to construct a new gender identity rather than a new body. I suggested alternatives like psychotherapy, counseling, and same-sex rather than cross-sex hormones. I was critical of the informed consent model and believed some people — especially children — should be denied certain interventions for their own good, while acknowledging I didn't know exactly who or how to determine that.
I have been skeptical of medical claims about transition's reversibility, mocking the idea with 'ReVeRSiBlE!!!' and stating that only a few people pass, sometimes. I noted that fat and muscle distribution change with hormones but bone structure does not. I argued that 'gender identity' is purely a social phenomenon, not a part of the body that doctors can repair, and that seeking surgery to change how others categorize you is a fool's errand because categories never truly existed in the first place.
I have also been critical of what I see as group dynamics in trans communities, arguing that it is human nature for groups to want to expand, and that portraying transition as trendy and cool is believable given adolescent culture's values. I warned against chasing 'euphoria,' especially based on unrealizable fantasies, calling it a sure path to ruin.
Despite my critical views, I have tried to be encouraging to others going through detransition. I told one person they were a stronger dude than they realized, that there is no shame in admitting mistakes, and that severity of mistakes has nothing to do with how good we are as people — it's luck and circumstance. I compared detransition to quitting a demanding career path like neurosurgery: making an effort, finding it didn't work, and trying something different is not failure. I expressed happiness when people came through distressing experiences with optimism and hope.
I don't regret the experience in a way that consumes me — I have tried to move forward constructively. I told others that in ten years, if everyone continued on their current paths, they would not envy the online trans community members who risk being stuck in perpetual adolescence, while those doing constructive things would build real lives. I believe I am miles ahead of many people in my situation and that everything I have done is at least partly reversible, if not fully, even the social changes.