Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben als man geboren en identificeer me als gedetransitioneerd — ik streefde naar transitie en koos er daarna voor te accepteren wat ik de biologische realiteit van man zijn noem, terwijl ik zelfexpressie voorbij genderrollen blijf waarderen. In dit transcript geef ik geen expliciete data voor mijn dysforie, mijn coming-out, hormonen, operaties of detransitie, dus die tijdlijnvelden zijn leeg. Wat ik wel beschrijf, is een reeks commentaren van medio 2021 tot begin 2022 waarin ik me sterk uitspreek tegen transitie, de medicalisering en marketing van genderidentiteit bekritiseer en anderen aanmoedig tot zelfacceptatie en eerlijkheid. Ik schrijf het toe aan meer eten en rond begin 2021 beginnen met trainen dat ik me gezonder, zelfverzekerder en voldoeniger voel. Ik bespreek hier in mijn eigen woorden geen mentale diagnoses, therapie, vruchtbaarheid of specifieke medische complicaties.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and, from what I've written online, I came to identify as detransitioned — someone who pursued a transition and then chose to return to accepting what I describe as "the biological reality" of being male. I've described myself physically as a "twink," slim and low on the BMI scale, and I've said I've been told I have feminine characteristics both behaviorally and physiologically, though I don't regard those as limiting me socially now that I'm in better shape.
I never worked out in my life until about six months before June 2021, when I started eating more and training. I've credited that with making me feel healthier, more confident, and more fulfilled — "more than just the less feminine body," though I've admitted I like the balance I'm nearing. I've recommended gym work to others, including the argument that it's worth putting in the work before bones finish hardening in the mid-20s.
I don't have any explicit dates in my own posts for when I first felt dysphoria, when I started identifying as trans, whether I took hormones or had any surgeries, or exactly when I detransitioned. What I do have is a body of commentary, from mid-2021 into early 2022, in which I argue strongly against transition and against the medical and cultural framing of gender identity. I've written that "detransitioning is coming to accept the biological reality, however still being comfortable to be self-expressive and free willed beyond gender roles," and that "the sooner we accept the person we were born as, the sooner we find ourselves in a happier state of mind."
I've been critical of the medicalization of gender identity, writing that "clinical and psychological 'care' including hormones make a lot of money" and that there's "a lot of money being dumped into marketing this stuff." I've distinguished gender non-conformity from non-binary identity, saying one is not conforming to gender roles while the other is "ignoring biological science." I've also written that "there's psuedo science being made up in an effort to reaffirm the lies being told to unstable and sexually confused youth," and that transitioning "has proven to be dangerous due to the affects it has on both the mental health and physical health." I've characterized the current cultural moment as possibly "just another generational fad that will certainly die out."
On sexuality and relationships, I've written about the difficulty of maintaining a relationship when sexual interests aren't met and when you can't be "full disclosure about what's going on and how you think and feel." In one comment I advised someone whose partner was watching trans porn despite knowing it caused them trauma or PTSD "from trying to pursue transgenderism" — which suggests I view that kind of pornography and the surrounding culture as potentially harmful to people who've been through a transition-related experience. I've said I don't really like religion but understand the intent behind ensuring a nuclear family setup, and I've expressed the view that humans are "animals that naturally want to breed" and that there are "simply" two genders, with rare exceptions for what I called "hermaphrodites in very rare genetic breeding failures."
I don't describe mental health diagnoses, therapy, medication, family dynamics, or specific traumatic events in my own words in this transcript. I do reference "trauma of the experience" in relation to people who've been targeted by what I see as a cultural trend, and I've mentioned personal experience with relationships where honesty was difficult. I don't discuss fertility, surgical complications, or specific medical interventions I underwent.
My overall stance is critical of transition as a general practice, supportive of detransition as a return to accepting one's biological sex, and encouraging of self-acceptance combined with freedom of expression beyond gender roles. I've advocated for honesty with oneself and with others, and I've been supportive in tone toward others considering or going through detransition, while also being sharply critical of the medical, political, and cultural forces I believe promote transition.