Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw, een androgyne, genderonconforme vrouw die zich eerst als non-binair en daarna als transjongen identificeerde nadat ik me rond 2012-2013 onderdompelde in transcontent op Tumblr terwijl ik getraumatiseerd, gedissocieerd en vol zelfhaat was. Ik nam ruim 3 jaar testosteron (Nebido) en onderging een dubbele mastectomie, en stopte ongeveer vier jaar voor 2020 nadat een door een psychedelicum veroorzaakte ego-dood me deed beseffen dat mijn trans-identiteit een ongezond copingmechanisme was geweest, geworteld in trauma, dissociatie, geïnternaliseerde misogynie en sociale besmetting. Sinds mijn detransitie heb ik somatische therapie en gesprekstherapie gedaan, ben ik opnieuw verbonden met mijn lichaam en mijn vrouwelijkheid en heb ik de banden met de transgemeenschap verbroken, al ervaar ik nog verdriet en woede over mijn veranderde lichaam en blijf ik worstelen met psychische problemen. In 2020 overwoog ik serieus om weer een lage dosis testosteron te nemen als anabool middel en stemmingsstabilisator, terwijl ik de risico’s van verslaving, hersenmist en verdere lichamelijke veranderingen onderkende, en ik besloot niet impulsief te handelen en het verlangen eerst in therapie te onderzoeken. Ik blijf kritisch over de toxiciteit van de transgemeenschap en over transitie als oplossing voor onverwerkt trauma, terwijl ik volhoud dat mijn transitie echt was en mijn leven materieel heeft gevormd.
Volledig verhaal
I am an androgynous female with a (de)trans experience. Growing up in the mid-2000s, I was a gender nonconforming girl: from about 13 to 16 I wore baggy clothes, wanted to bind my breasts and wear boys' underwear, and wished to be more muscular and androgynous, but I never thought I had "gender dysphoria" or that I should be a guy — I knew I was female and I was into other females. I hated my body but didn't stress about my gender identity, because trans and gender identity content was essentially non-existent then; transitioning was a marginal phenomenon before roughly 2012-2015.
It was not until 2012-2013 that I began to obsess about my gender identity, as I saw more trans-related content online and a few of my friends started transitioning; then I became absolutely sure I was trans too. I spent a lot of time on Tumblr during the period when gender identity content began filling the site. At the time I was an unstable, traumatized, self-hating young woman going through huge life changes, deep in dissociation and denial, disconnected from my body, memories and feelings. I first identified as nonbinary, then as a trans guy. I changed my name almost immediately, started hormones, and had a double mastectomy a few years later — in a very short period I transformed into someone else, which I later described as "a suicide without the actual killing of this organism." I identify this as a stereotypical case of "rapid onset gender dysphoria," though I don't believe ROGD is caused by social contagion alone — there are always complex underlying issues lumped under the vague concept of "gender dysphoria."
I was on testosterone for over 3 years, using Nebido; my last shot was in September or October, and I had my first post-T period at the end of March the following year. I decided not to continue HRT and did not need to taper — testosterone levels gradually decline after the last shot. I experienced no health issues after quitting; possibly I sweated more than normal, but otherwise both my physical and mental health changed only for the better. I have now been off testosterone for about four years as of my September 2020 post.
What kicked off my detransitioning and healing processes were psychedelics — I still enjoy eating shrooms occasionally. After several years on testosterone I had an ego death / spiritual awakening, came out of my extreme dissociation, and realized the things I had been running from (my femaleness included) had not gone anywhere. I realized my trans identity had been an unhealthy coping mechanism and that I had always been, and will always be, a female. I abandoned the superficial identity I had crafted and began basing my identity on integrating all parts of my experience. Over the four years off T I have been reconnecting with my body and the feelings it holds, dealing with my trauma both somatically and in therapy, and reconnecting with my femaleness and the wounded feminine in me. I'm still not "healed" but in the process of healing; I still struggle with mental health issues but feel very much in contact with myself and no longer ashamed of any part of myself. My relationship with my body is completely different: now I actually feel I AM my body, and I exercise, dance and swim, existing more sensually.
I sometimes feel grief over changing my body so drastically while not really being in contact with it, and anger at how much misogyny made me hate my female body. I sometimes miss how I looked before transitioning, but that's gone forever. If I could go back in time I would not have had my breasts removed or used testosterone as long as I did — though I do like some changes T gave me: bottom growth, a slightly lower voice, more muscles. My biggest mistakes in my trans process were rushing into it while mentally unstable, going on a full dose of T too soon, having a double mastectomy (it would have been best to have no surgeries, or only a breast reduction), and trying to pass as a man rather than embracing being a gender nonconforming woman experimenting with testosterone.
Since about May 2020 (the four months before my September 2020 post) I have been thinking about starting testosterone again — not to look like a man, but because I miss the physical energy, the ease of gaining muscle, the better appetite (I have always been naturally underweight, and the only time I was not underweight was on T), and the mood-stabilizing effect, since my moods and feelings are normally so intense it's draining. I'm quite sure my estrogen cycles affect my moods more than normal. I explicitly frame this as using testosterone as an anabolic steroid rather than as HRT — I know for sure I don't want to replace my natural sex hormone production with synthetic drugs, but would like to boost or "balance" my natural system with small doses of T. I am not going to make impulsive decisions; I want to examine these thoughts in therapy and in conversation with others first, and I don't believe I'm in the right place in my life to experiment with T right now given lots of stressful stuff, wanting to be in a calmer place and in therapy longer to be certain the desire isn't my trauma acting out.
I also recognize that wanting low-dose T for mental stability and healthy weight is "the extremely lazy way" to achieve those things, and that meditation, diet and eating schedules would be better — but after several years of "natural lifestyle" and herbal remedies I'm questioning whether a little "unnatural" support is so bad. I worry about addiction: the energy rush and high libido from T were extremely addictive for me, and as a very sexual person I developed an awful porn addiction on T and my sexuality changed in ways I didn't like. I also experienced brain fog on T, though I'm unsure how much came from the drug versus the dissociation and denial I was in; it took me years to get out of that fog. When I started T I usually woke up to panic or a foggy uncomfortable feeling — doubts and worries that never reached the surface but were bubbling underneath; I was scared to face them so I pretended they didn't exist.
I was heavily entangled in trans politics and trans communities, leaving no space to get to know myself outside that social influence. I believe the queer/trans community enables toxic, narcissistic and controlling behavior in some individuals, with aggressive "every day is a trans day of vengeance" and "die cis scum" talk where no one dares disagree. I don't want anything to do with the trans community anymore unless it becomes less toxic and cult-like. I am completely ok with my femaleness, but I enjoy the freedom of being able to pass as a guy when needed — "my outside doesn't necessarily reflect who I truly am on the inside, but it's quite practical to have this disguise." I'm not fond of identity and prefer to speak of embodied experiences rather than identities; I reject the phrase "I wasn't actually trans," saying it stopped being just an idea and became material reality when I started testosterone and had a double mastectomy, something I can never undo, and that it shaped almost every aspect of my life. Some of my reasons for being trans — trauma, dissociation, internalized misogyny, social contagion — are things most of the trans community ignores.
I was hurt badly by people in the queer community whom I loved and respected; they stopped associating with me and shared posts on social media telling everyone else to stop associating with me as well. This was the only space on the internet where I felt I could safely share that trauma, and being attacked there left me feeling like "total transphobic scum," feeling like total shit, not wanting to write on the sub anymore, and "so fucking tired of walking on eggshells." I have read Levine and van der Kolk on trauma and was seeking a book explaining the somatic nature of structural dissociation. I now live away from cities — a recluse life that has mostly made my life much better but lonelier, with animals, plants and fungi for company, further limited by covid lockdowns.
I have been critical of other people's transition decisions too: I told someone with intense bottom dysphoria that it "screams" unresolved trauma and asked what made them certain they wouldn't regret bottom surgery given they already regretted starting T and getting a hysterectomy (I later apologized for psychoanalyzing and a condescending tone). I also told someone with OCD-driven gender doubts that they were battling OCD, comparing it to my own dreams of being a gnome or traveling in space. I believe people should be able to use whatever words best describe their own experience when talking about themselves, while avoiding generalizations. I respect trans people's identities and will use preferred pronouns if I know someone is trans, but I don't think someone is narcissistic for not doing so.