Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben als man geboren, transitioneerde om als vrouw te leven van ongeveer mijn 17e tot mijn 24e (grofweg 6-7 jaar hormonen) en detransitioneerde ongeveer 3-4 jaar geleden; ik leef nu als gedetransitioneerde man en identificeer me als egalitair. Ik schrijf mijn transitie deels toe aan het gevoel dat ik de typische mannelijke ontwikkeling (stem, lengte, baard) had gemist, opgroeien in een omgeving vol boodschappen dat mannen slecht zijn, en wrok over gendergebonden verwachtingen van mannen. Ik detransitioneerde pragmatisch — het was goedkoper, hormonen brachten gezondheidsrisico's met zich mee en de stress van passeren en intimidatie was het niet waard — en hoewel ik me niet meer druk maak over passeren, blijf ik pessimistisch over de uitkomsten voor gedetransitioneerde mannen en vermijd ik daten helemaal. Ik ben nog steeds biseksueel en ik vind dat mensen vrij moeten zijn om te transitioneren als ze dat willen, terwijl ik ook tegengas geef aan het idee dat mannelijkheid zelf vernederend is.
Volledig verhaal
I am M2F2M — I was born male, transitioned to live as a woman, and have since detransitioned back to living as a man. I started hormones at 17, went off briefly at 17, started again at 18, and stayed on them until around 24, so roughly 6-7 years on hormones total. I have been off hormones for about 3-4 years now.
Several things influenced my decision to transition. Growing up, my natural voice was higher-pitched and more feminine, and I used to deliberately lower it every time I spoke because I was embarrassed about it. I'm the shortest guy in my family — everyone else is around 6 foot and I'm 5'6" or 5'7". I can't grow a full beard, I don't feel I have stereotypical male mannerisms, and I felt like "the testosterone train just kind of flew past me" growing up. I also hated genital-related aspects of my body then and still do now. On top of that, I grew up being told repeatedly how bad men are, that all bad things are men's fault, that women are more mature as a blanket assumption, and that men should be denied opportunities in favor of women. I literally never heard anyone disparage women as a group in person growing up. That kind of messaging — sexism against men — is a big part of what made me not like being a guy, and I think it's under-discussed as a contributor to male-to-female transition. I also resented the expectation that men should be protective toward women as a gendered obligation, especially when those same people wouldn't physically protect me back; I don't think any of those traits (protectiveness, psychological support) should be gendered at all.
I did believe I had dysphoria at the time. I also experienced fear about passing and being harassed as a trans woman, even though I was passable.
As for detransition, my reasoning was fairly pragmatic: being a guy in the USA sucks, being a trans female sucks, but it costs me less to just naturally be a guy. Since it all felt pointless anyways, I figured I might as well eliminate the hassles that come with being a trans female and go back to my natural gender. The hormones probably bring some health issues too. By that point my attitude was basically "fuck it, idgaf about most things anymore and this is cheaper," and I no longer had to worry about things like "am I passable today so I don't get harassed?" My dream is to make enough money working from home/indoors that I don't have to go out, at which point other people's perception of me would be almost moot.
I found it easier living as a woman in some ways — I could take advantage of affirmative action policies and other extra help women get, get away with more, and dating was easier. As a guy I won't go near dating with a ten-foot pole. I'm still bisexual after detransition.
I'm fairly pessimistic about detransition outcomes in general — when someone asked if there's hope for a healthy, semi-normal life after detransitioning, I said realistically how many successful or well-adjusted detrans men have you ever heard of, suggested focusing on career as the best bet, and told them stage 5 of grief is acceptance so the quicker you get there the better. I also suggested seeing a doctor to check hormone levels for peace of mind.
I identify as egalitarian rather than feminist. I've found that bringing up men's gender-based issues or sexism against men as a contributor to transition is unwelcome in spaces where many people identify as feminists — after too many times of people getting mad at a suggestion of working on both women's and men's issues, I mostly just lurk. I still think people should be free to transition if they want, and I've pushed back on framing masculinity itself as something that downgrades a person, noting that stopping that view would help M2F2M people like me.