Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich vanaf mijn tienerjaren in sommige kringen als man identificeerde maar nooit toegang kreeg tot hormonen of operaties door gebrek aan geld, toegang en steun. Mijn ernstige levenslange dysforie, die rond mijn 5e begon, vervaagde nadat ik op mijn 20e mijn kleine geboortestad verliet voor de universiteit in San Francisco, en was in mijn dertiger jaren helemaal verdwenen. Ik beschouw die periode als een fase waar ik uit gegroeid ben, en ik ben dankbaar dat ik te arm was voor de boven- en onderoperaties waar ik zeker spijt van zou hebben gekregen. Nu werk ik aan het deprogrammeren van geïnternaliseerd vrouwenhaat, het geloof dat vrouw zijn me minder waard maakt, en ik raad anderen aan onomkeerbare ingrepen uit te stellen bij twijfel. Ik heb geen gemelde suïcidale gedachten, zelfbeschadiging of zelfmoordpogingen.
Volledig verhaal
I developed dysphoria further back than I can remember; at 5 years old I distinctly remember feeling sad that I wasn't a boy. That feeling endured and worsened and became the fixation of my existence throughout childhood and into my teens, at which point I began identifying as male in some circles. I never medically transitioned, due to lack of access, funds, and support, but I had a plan to make it happen.
I was born in the mid-80s, which I mention because the internet and Tumblr were not a factor in the onset of my dysphoria — I had no community of nonbinary or gender-nonconforming people around me, and my dysphoria appears to have developed spontaneously. I do think a biological predisposition may be involved for people like me who had dysphoria as long as they can remember. But I also think a very young child can make observations about human society that lead them to dissociate from their birth gender. Relatives would give me dresses, Barbies, and princess things and push me toward being a stereotypical girl, which was at odds with my nature. Even as a very young child it probably made sense to me that I was "supposed to be a boy" — that is literally how I thought about it in my own young head — because I didn't like the options presented to me as a girl. I internalized that narrative until, about 15 years later, I realized that being a girl doesn't have to be pink and frilly and domesticated.
Some of my most distinct uncomfortable childhood memories were when a teacher would divide the class into two groups, boys in one and girls in the other. I wanted so badly to be with the boys and felt so out of place with the girls. Gender stereotypes were definitely a factor for me, even though my own household didn't push me to conform to particular female stereotypes — but schools, sports teams, other people (kids and adults), and the media all did.
At 20 I left my tiny hometown for college in San Francisco. The scene change and culture shock were profound and knocked me out of the rhythm my life had adhered to. Just being away from home, the image I had of myself as a small-town high-school loner born in the wrong body began to fade. New experiences and aspirations redirected my energy from trying to become a man to simply trying to make my existence the most gratifying one possible: becoming a better artist, getting into a field I loved, traveling, getting healthy in mind, body, and spirit. Eventually my gender identity wasn't a priority for me at all.
My lifelong dysphoria began to fade around 18–19. Around 18 is where I started wondering why I could only imagine accepting myself if I transitioned to male; eventually the idea that I'd have to first transition in order to love myself stopped making sense. By my mid-20s I was dysphoria free, and it is completely gone in my 30s. I feel at home in my biological body today, and it's almost counterintuitive that it only happened once I stopped obsessing over my gender. I consider my experience of severe dysphoria absolutely, 100% a phase — it lasted a very long time, but shortly after I reached adulthood and had some new life experiences, the phase was over.
I consider myself extremely lucky for having been broke during that period of my life, because I would have spent my money on top surgery and bottom surgery, and I'm certain I would have regretted it.
I now struggle with internalized misogyny: I feel like the idea that being female makes me less worthy is lodged deep within my subconscious, and I asked others in the community what methods helped them change that internal narrative. I'm grateful my adolescence just missed the Tumblr explosion — I don't know if I would have been allowed to grow out of my dysphoria had I found a community affirming it and pushing me toward medical solutions. At the same time, I think there's value in the more nuanced discussion about gender that internet communities have produced; maybe younger me would have felt valid as a gender-nonconforming girl sooner if there had been role models or conversation treating the GNC girl as a normal, worthy individual.
I have advised others who are doubting surgery not to proceed, to take doubts to therapy and explore why dysphoria symptoms seemed to disappear right before surgery, and to safely delay any scheduled surgeries or treatments while examining the doubt. I also tell younger people that they will change in ways they can't imagine in their 20s, and to keep that in mind before making permanent changes to the body. I believe there's too much pressure on people to "figure out who you are" as if it's a single, tangible thing — you are ever-changing, evolving, stumbling and triumphing.