Alle verhalen

Een radicaal feministe die nooit transitioneerde

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd105
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben nooit gedetransitioneerd; ik ben een gender-kritische meelezer die zichzelf expliciet 'zelf niet detrans' heeft genoemd bij reacties in detrans-ruimtes. Ik ben een radicaal feministe uiterst links, kritisch over medische transitie van jongeren, puberteitsremmers en vroege toegang tot hormonen van het andere geslacht, en ik verdedig gender-kritische gemeenschappen tegen het label alt-right of conservatief. Ik post over het algemeen niet in detrans-fora uit respect voor hen als detrans-only ruimtes, al heb ik die regel af en toe doorbroken om punten te verduidelijken. Ik heb geen persoonlijke ervaring met dysforie, transitie of detransitie beschreven.

Volledig verhaal

I have never detransitioned myself — I want to be clear about that up front. I am a gender critical lurker on detrans forums, and I have said so explicitly when I broke my own rule and commented. I read the posts and comments to understand and sympathise with detransitioners, but I generally avoid replying, and I acknowledged that participating was 'infringing on a space I shouldn't be in.' My involvement in these spaces is ideological rather than personal. I describe myself as gender critical and say I do not use the label 'terf,' which I consider a pejorative. I identify as a radical feminist and as politically far left — a socialist, though I say I haven't read enough theory to pick a specific ideology yet. I've spent what I call 'aeons' participating in gender critical and sister subreddits. On transition and minors, I hold strongly critical views. I argued that puberty blockers can cause a reduction in IQ of approximately 10 points, and that in trans men the pre-transition voice might never return, that blockers can cause sterility and weak bones, and other health issues. I was adamant that a 14-year-old cannot make life-long body-altering decisions, comparing it to driving, drinking, and full-time work. I argued cross-sex hormones are not like ordinary medications because their side effects are far more prevalent and body-altering, and that it's better to wait to be certain than to 'go headfirst and regret it later.' I noted the rate of teens seeking transition had increased 1500% in some countries and predicted we'd see more detransitioners soon. I also agreed that therapists are sometimes too quick to call for hormones, and that everyone can agree there should be more barriers for trans people to get hormones, especially as kids. In my country, I noted, you have to try therapy first before getting medication. I spent a lot of energy in 2020 defending gender critical spaces from accusations of being alt-right, conservative, or linked to incels. I argued radical feminism and conservatism are incompatible, that GC members are mostly centre-left or left-wing, and that GC theory predates the 'terf' label, with roots in radical feminist books from the 80s or 90s. I pushed back hard on the 'man-hating lesbian' stereotype, calling it misogynistic and lesbophobic, and noted many GC members are straight women. I defended GC's stance that sex-based oppression cannot be opted out of, and that trans women don't give up male privilege. I was frustrated by a commenter making claims about GC positions I'd never heard in all my time in those spaces, and I eventually told them to stop discussing 'terf points' on a detrans sub. I also clarified the relationship between GC and detrans communities: I said non-detrans GC members are heavily discouraged from participating in the detrans sub by both communities, that GC mods actively discouraged brigading, and that most GC members who visit detrans spaces only lurk. I acknowledged the hypocrisy of my own commenting while making these points. I expressed hope that a rumored July 1st banwave wouldn't affect the detrans subreddit. On other issues, I've argued against men's rights framing of custody, claiming men win over 70% of contested custody cases, and I've been dismissive and sharp in debate, at times resorting to insults like 'What, you can't read?' I also commented sarcastically about Mermaids, a UK organization supporting gender-diverse young people. On family acceptance of LGB identity, I took a hard line: if family can't accept someone dating or marrying same-sex partners, they're 'in full rights to cut you out of their life,' and that anyone who doesn't accept it at face value is 'absolutely unsalvageable.' I have not described any personal experience of dysphoria, transition, or detransition in these comments. My engagement is as an ideological observer and defender of gender critical viewpoints within and around detrans spaces.