Alle verhalen

Terugduwen tegen de gendercritische menigte in haar eigen steungroep

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd196
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een fysiek getransitioneerde, gedetransitioneerde of detransitionerende vrouw met een veranderd lichaam, uiterlijk en een niet-passend identiteitsbewijs, die testosteron heeft genomen en wier seksualiteit niet veranderde met de transitie. Ik kwam op advies van mijn therapeut in deze gemeenschap, maar vond haar gedomineerd door gendercritische bondgenoten en toeschouwers die detrans-mensen behandelen als waarschuwende spektakels in plaats van als mensen. Ik ben politiek progressief, vijandig tegenover anti-trans beleid en kritisch over puristische of one-size-fits-all-opvattingen over detransitie, in de overtuiging dat iedereen zelf moet beslissen hoe te leven met zijn lichaam. Ik heb teruggeduwd tegen kwaadwillige en pseudowetenschappelijke posters met geciteerd onderzoek en moderators aangesproken als de sub afdreef van het dienen van detransitioners.

Volledig verhaal

I came to this detrans community on the advice of my therapist, looking for support, but I found it unhealthy and made an account only after months of lurking because I was upset at how little the place seemed to serve the people it claimed to be for. I am female by birth and have physically transitioned — I have an altered body and appearance and mismatched ID — and I have been on testosterone. When someone posted a photo of a hand worried about testosterone's effects, I told them it just looked like a hand and that they needed to accept that they will keep aging regardless of past testosterone use. I have been on hormones long enough to have a long-term perspective: when asked whether transition changed my sexuality, I said, 'I know people for whom it did change and for whom it didn't. Mine didn't,' and I described hearing it explained as 'gay is gay,' where former lesbians become gay men as their body changes, with latent attractions appearing as dysphoria decreases. I have a network of long-term transitioned people in my life, more than most people here. I am sharply critical of the 'allies' and gender-critical posters who dominate the sub. I said the allies bother me more than anyone else, that they are 'given a lot of leeway to insult our experiences and bodies and treat us with pity instead of empathy,' and that the sub functions as 'a honeypot to collect the stories of vulnerable people for GC to self-satisfiedly wank to.' I repeatedly pushed back against posters who treat detrans people as 'a combination of a zoo and a warning sign,' saying we are 'people and not huddled lumps wrapped in caution tape waiting to be used as a warning tale.' I argued that what the sub is for 'should be decided by detransitioning people. Not you,' and I tagged moderators when I felt quacks or bad-faith posters were wasting everyone's time — including a poster I called 'a quack peddling his book' who claimed anticonvulsants make people lose interest in transition, to which I responded with published research (a Norwegian registry study on substance use disorders in epilepsy and a paper titled 'Caring for transgender patients with epilepsy') and told him, 'You're a moron. Shut up. Go away.' I am politically progressive and hostile to the Trump administration, telling a conservative poster, 'Everything your Great Dicktator is doing to trans people affects detrans and gender nonconforming people too,' and accusing them of supporting me 'being fired and evicted and denied medical care because I have an altered body and appearance and mismatched ID.' I rejected comparisons to conditions in Nigeria, saying 'Oh yes, Nigeria is worse so appreciate that I might *only* get fired or die of incompetent medical care.' I criticized radfems for allying with the religious right against porn since the 1980s, arguing the tactic left radfems more marginalized while the religious right made gains and porn became more prevalent — 'shooting off your nose to spite your face.' I also criticized Paul McHugh, saying 'McHugh's entire career has been a fight against gay rights.' I hold a nuanced, non-purist view of detransition. I am 'strongly against the sub enforcing the hard line that any body modification is wrong,' noting people may detransition in different ways — staying on hormones but detransitioning socially, stopping hormones but pursuing surgery like FFS or mastectomy, or pursuing reversal surgeries — because 'we are all trying to figure out how to live with ourselves and the reality is that is just not going to look the same for everyone.' I told someone that if testosterone 'allowed you to get to a place where you believe in yourself and your abilities, then maybe it wasn't wasted time,' and that 'life is too short to be strict about purity or naturalistic approaches.' I advised a self-loathing person that 'working on liking yourself as a person' was necessary for basic quality of life, since 'not transitioning is not going to bring any peace by itself.' I also cautioned that 'getting laid is as bad a reason to detransition as it is to transition in the first place.' I try to give practical, boundary-respecting advice: I suggested r/nonbinary for someone pursuing a partial detransition or exploring bigender identity, noting this sub is 'pretty intolerant of anything outside of full return to birth sex and gender'; I pointed a man toward r/MensLib for talking about emotions, saying 'detrans people are not here to talk you into or out of anything'; and I told someone seeking community among non-feminine straight women that 'you're never going to have much community.' I have been blunt with people showing severe dissociation or emptiness, telling one that 'what you are (not) feeling is not normal' and that dissociation is a protective mechanism meaning 'there's something wrong that needs looked at,' and I called another poster a 'demented monster' for praising someone's severe dissociation. I also predicted, pointedly, that a controlling parent's child would transition at college. Overall I have not described my own current identity beyond being a physically transitioned, detransitioning or detransitioned woman with an altered body, and I have not described surgeries, fertility, or a specific detransition date.