Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw met geslachtsdysforie in mijn kindertijd, PCOS met oestrogeenwaarden in het mannelijke bereik en jarenlang spironolacton, die 655 dagen testosteron nam (2021-2023) en op 3 oktober 2023 stopte. Ik heb niet direct spijt van de transitie, maar stopte omdat hormonen maar de helft van mijn dysforie oplosten, ernstige acne, gezichtsbeharing en angst voor kaalheid brachten, en omdat ik moe was van de obsessie met mijn uiterlijk en doorgaan. Sinds oktober 2023 ben ik van T af, weer op de NuvaRing en spironolacton, en later kreeg ik afwijkende schildklier- en bloedwaarden die mijn arts mogelijk aan T toeschreef. Ik heb nog dysforie maar heb transitie uitgesloten, en ik begrijp mijn gevoelens nu als geworteld in geïnternaliseerd vrouwenhaat en homofobie verbonden met lesbisch zijn; ik voel me op mijn 23e-24e veel beter dan tussen mijn 13e en 22e. Ik adviseer anderen dat transitie een reëel risico is, dat detransitiecijfers in onderzoek onbetrouwbaar zijn en dat volwassenen mogen kiezen te transitioneren maar niet moeten claimen dat ze zeker weten dat ze niet zullen detransitioneren.
Volledig verhaal
I have had sex dysphoria since childhood and was a gender-nonconforming kid. As soon as I hit puberty I had hormone problems: naturally high androgens, very low estrogen, brutal genetic acne, and irregular, painful periods that often disappeared for months at a time. I was diagnosed with PCOS, and my estrogen levels have been in the male range (around 20 pg/mL) for my whole life. I started estrogen birth control at 13 and tried it on and off until 19, but it made me mentally and physically miserable — it elevates my anxiety and makes me nauseous. I was treated with spironolactone for years, which cured the acne, but I spent some years with no sex hormones at all because I couldn't tolerate synthetic estrogen. The only estrogen method that worked decently for me was the NuvaRing.
I struggled with dysphoria into my late teens and early 20s. I tried other "treatments" — therapy, the gym — for seven years before going on hormones, and I had wanted to transition for five years before that. I did trans/queer studies at school and wanted to serve the trans community in my profession. I looked at detransition stories before going on hormones and felt I was different from what I saw; I thought I was a typical "case" of childhood gender dysphoria and a perfect candidate. I believed with 100% certainty I would transition for life.
Starting testosterone was not about identity for me. I never believed I could become a man, and I don't really "identify" as anything. All I knew was that I wanted the effects of testosterone. I stopped spiro and started T two years before September 2023 — eventually logging 655 consecutive days without missing a dose. The regimen: the first six months on a very low dose of AndroGel, about a year on a "normal" dose of AndroGel, then three months on low-dose injections that were far more effective than the gel and scared me. I also used finasteride at points.
I don't regret my transition as such. I love my deep voice, thick eyebrows, body hair, the fact that my period stopped, the reduction of hip fat, my broader shoulders, and the bottom growth. I stopped restricting my food intake because I became more comfortable with where I carry fat. But T also brought back acne worse than ever — past aesthetically unpleasant into debilitatingly painful — plus darkening, fast-growing facial hair I shave every few days (which worsens the acne), and a terror of balding; I have nightmares about it and constantly check my hairline. My face became too masculine and my neck too thick; my original goal had been androgyny and I went past it. I also still disliked my chest, which is very small, and expected to get top surgery eventually. I felt I was going through puberty while trying to live as an adult, applying to graduate programs and looking like a teenager.
I decided to stop. On October 3, 2023 (day 655), I skipped the shot I was due for. I felt immense relief and immense anxiety: "Will I be able to look female again?" About a week after stopping, I got called "miss" at the grocery store for the first time in about a year. I was concerned about having no sex hormones at all after coming off T, given my male-range estrogen and PCOS.
By January 2024 I had been off T almost four months and back on birth control about three months — I went back on the NuvaRing, plus spironolactone, which I need for PCOS and had taken for four years before T without issue. I noticed significant change, including skin texture improvements I never expected. By May 2024 I was about seven months off T. Routine labs then showed a very high TSH plus elevated cholesterol, triglycerides, platelets, and mono- and lymphocytes — all normal while on T. My family has a history of Hashimoto's; my T3, T4, and thyroid antibodies came back normal, and my doctor thought the problems might be brought on by T. I had not gained weight — I had lost weight — and had only small signs of hypothyroidism, though my neck hurt where the thyroid is.
What moved me toward detransition was realizing hormones wouldn't solve everything. I had hoped T was the cure; it wasn't. I also grew tired of focusing on appearance and how people perceived me. I wrote: "Focusing on looks is what got me into this. I didnt like myself before T, didn't like myself on T, so it's not rational to assume that going off T will be the miracle cure." I wanted to prioritize how I feel. I recognized that my solution to discomfort before T — overperforming masculinity — wasn't the answer, so overperforming femininity wouldn't be either. I stopped hormones to be my authentic self: accepting that I'm female with masculine traits, without needing to perform femininity. I don't intend to socially undo anything; I never cared whether someone assessed me as a man or woman, and I was never comfortable in super-feminine clothes — part of why I thought I was trans.
I do regret a lot of my transition and feel uncomfortable about how much I have masculinized, though I also accept that masculinization is now part of me and out of my control. I was mortified at the prospect of any voice feminization and terrified of my period returning, which repulses me, and of my hips widening further. I worried about explaining stopping to my mom, my partner, and my friends — family, friends, school, doctors, and employers had all been supportive — and about sunk cost. My dysphoria has not gone away; I still have it to this day, but I have ruled out transition as a solution. Living as a woman now is harder because I am androgenized. I described feeling not like a man but "like a freak" while on T, and said taking T did not reduce my dysphoria and may have increased it — a fraudulent feeling that convinced me I was a woman.
I now believe a lot of what I felt came from internalized misogyny and internalized homophobia, and that many feelings about failing to be feminine came from being a lesbian, since society treats heterosexuality as part of doing womanhood correctly. I realized being a woman is a neutral part of me that doesn't constrain my personality, clothing, or aesthetics, and that the societal view of womanhood is fundamentally wrong and constrictive. I struggled badly with dysphoria from 13 to 22, and it took attention away from finding myself in ways unrelated to gender or sexuality; it has started to get much better now at 23-24.
I have posted advice for others considering transition. I acknowledge that detransition stories sometimes share themes like internalized homophobia, autism, or body dysmorphia, but that there is no single detrans story. As a graduate statistics student, I say the current studies are flawed and the detransition rates cited are probably inaccurate, and that studies don't distinguish detransition from regret. I believe it's an adult's right to modify their body, and that transition does work for some people — but that anyone transitioning should accept it as a risk rather than claim they've proven they won't detransition. I have offered to DM with people who want a balanced perspective. I also counseled a minor not to take my word as prophecy, while telling them I wish I could prevent them from feeling what I feel.