Alle verhalen

Nooit getransitioneerd, maar jarenlang meisjes gewaarschuwd tegen testosteron

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd118
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een vrouw die op mannen valt en nooit is getransitioneerd, maar ik heb veel tijd besteed aan het adviseren van jonge vrouwen om geen testosteron en geen borstoperatie te nemen. Ik geloof dat de meeste jonge vrouwen die zich nu als trans identificeren een ontsnapping zoeken aan het niet passen, terwijl ik accepteer dat sommige transvrouwen en transmannen echt zijn. Ik waarschuw uitgebreid voor de onomkeerbare effecten van testosteron (orgaanatrofie, vroege overgang, kaalheid, levenslange medicatie) en dring aan op therapie vóór enige operatie. Ik heb geen persoonlijke medische transitie, detransitie of psychische crisis van mezelf beschreven; mijn verhaal is dat van een waarnemer en commentator. Ik maak onderscheid tussen echte transvrouwen en autogynefiele mannen en zie het beschermen van zowel vrouwen als transvrouwen als een grote uitdaging.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and I have never identified as trans myself, but I have spent a lot of time in detransition and gender-critical spaces talking to young women who are on the verge of or in the process of transitioning. My own sexuality is straightforward: I like men. What turns me on is the idea that they have been socialised differently, that they have a body different from mine — a flat hairy chest, broad shoulders, bigger hands than mine, more physical strength, the capacity to have a hard on. A transman does not have this, and while I wish them well, it is not for me. In April 2020 I got into a long exchange with a young woman who was about to start testosterone. I told her plainly that pumping her body with hormones that are not meant for it is not a good idea, that there is nothing 'casual' about it, and that she was damaging her body with some changes being irreversible. I pointed out she had a healthy body, even if it was not perfect, and that she had mentioned a medical condition related to anorexia. I argued she could live her life as she pleased — dress 'like a man', do whatever activities she wanted, get the job she wanted, date the guys and girls she wanted — without injecting artificial hormones. I warned her that injecting testosterone would cause her to go through menopause several decades earlier and may result in her organs shrinking (atrophy), that she might go bald, an irreversible side effect rarely spoken about on social media, and that she would have to take medication for the rest of her life and might need surgeries to remove shrinking organs. I stressed that female organs atrophy with testosterone — the vagina and uterus — unlike male organs, and that removing them is a heavy surgical procedure creating a void in the body with lifelong consequences and permanent hormone dependence. I told her to ask herself how it would look in ten years, to talk it over repeatedly with family and friends, and, if she could, to travel abroad for a few weeks or months because it often helps people change the way they see life. I also said: 'Many girls change their mind after a year or two and say that they were never told what would happen.' I acknowledged in the end that the decision was hers to make. I gave similar advice elsewhere: that a parent's role is to protect a child who is harming herself, that 'Your parents love you. They will not be angry at you. They will probably be incredibly happy and relieved if you tell them you will no longer inject your body with hormones,' and that family and friends are probably relieved when someone stops injecting high doses of hormones. I told one person, 'You look smart, beautiful and healthy,' and another, 'You are beautiful in both pics.' I also discussed hair loss in detail with someone whose hair changed after starting testosterone. I explained that hair reacts to hormones and that this is a bad sign, since the next step is hair falling out — people who go bald have hair that reacts to hormones, people who keep their hair have hair that does not. I said that if she stopped taking testosterone things should come back to normal. I elaborated that sensitivity is often genetic but not always, and gave the example of pregnant women whose hair grows faster under increased estrogen and falls after birth when estrogen drops. On other threads I argued against chest surgery. When someone was considering removing breast implants, I said that once she had them removed and had a flat chest again she would most likely start being depressed again and want surgery for other implants, and I urged her to see a therapist: 'Having surgery without talking to a therapist is not the answer, as you have seen from your own past experiences.' I pushed back on bodily autonomy arguments by asking whether you would cut someone's arm because he says he wants you to, and said the role of a doctor is to modify unhealthy bodies to make them healthy again, not to cut off healthy parts the patient may come to miss or regret. I also told someone that 'Treated like a boy' does not mean anything — boys and girls can be treated the same, and if they are not, you are dealing with sexist people; the answer to sexism is not hormones but denouncing and fighting gender stereotypes, because a girl can do everything a boy does. I was sceptical of some posts. I told one person who claimed to have transitioned to look like Jerry Seinfeld and detransitioned because of a comment he made that it sounded like a troll, and I called out another commenter as a troll after checking their history. I was blunt elsewhere: 'You injected your body with massive doses of artificial hormones so you would spend less time in jail once convicted of a crime? Do you work for a cartel? And have you tried to sell your story to Netflix?' I also made a pointed remark about millions of girls killed at birth, genitally mutilated, forcibly married, beaten, trafficked or killed in the name of 'honour' disagreeing with someone's view. I have thought a lot about why so many young women now believe they are trans. My view is that a lot of young teenagers who are not popular or who do not fit within our current consumerist, Hollywood-loving culture look for an escape, and that being transgender is fashionable and seen as one — suddenly you are no longer the weird girl who is not thin and sexy, or the weird girl who likes other girls, you are that cool girl who really is a trans boy. I noted teenagers think anything is possible. I was careful to say this is not to say there are no genuine transmen; I am sure there are, but I am also sure the vast majority of girls who currently think they are trans are not. My views on transwomen are more nuanced. I said there is a long tradition of transgender women in South and Eastern Asia, especially India and Pakistan, where they are considered a '3d sex' and become artists, particularly wedding dancers, though many now resort to prostitution due to poverty — a reality existing for centuries despite discrimination and violence as conservatism increased. I told someone they did not have to feel like a man or a woman. In a longer reflection I said transwomen have always existed for centuries, even in repressive societies, so I believe it is a real thing, but I noted they often emerged in societies where being gay was frowned upon or punishable, so some might have been gay men who could not live as gay men — while still affirming that there are also some 100 per cent genuine transwomen. In Western countries I think we need to differentiate genuine transwomen from men who suffer from autogynephilia and dress as women for sexual enjoyment. My summary was: 'transwomen are 100 per cent real, but not all those who claim to be transwomen are genuine transwomen,' and I called it one of the big challenges today — how to distinguish real transwomen from male perverts pretending, which matters both to protect women and transwomen. I also told someone, 'Guys who love you and who are worth loving will not mind,' and that you do not have to come out as a butch woman — 'This is who you are.'