Alle verhalen

Een jongensachtig meisje dat nooit transitioneerde — en er nu kritiek op heeft

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd202
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben nooit trans geweest en wilde nooit transitioneren, maar als levenslang jongensachtig meisje met lichaamsbeeldproblemen ben ik een uitgesproken criticus van de transbeweging geworden, vooral wat jongeren, puberteitsremmers en het experimentele karakter van hormonen en operaties betreft. Ik geloof dat genderdysforie echt is maar een psychische ziekte die behandeld moet worden en niet aangemoedigd, en ik betoog dat ongemak vaak onterecht dysforie wordt genoemd. Ik steun dat detransitioners een stem hebben en probeer individuen aan te moedigen tot therapie en zelfacceptatie. Ik identificeer me nu als gendernonconforme vrouw die kritisch is over transitie zoals die nu wordt toegepast.

Volledig verhaal

I've never been trans myself, and I have no interest in transitioning — but I've thought a lot about this subject and I'm vocal about it online. I'd describe myself as very tomboyish, always have been. I never liked a girly thing in my life, I've always looked up to my dad and mimicked him from a young age, I picked boy characters in video games, hung around with boys, and was uncomfortable around girls. Even so, I have no interest in transitioning and don't feel the need to just because I like boyish things. I've always hated my body too, though I never wanted to be male; as I get older I'm starting to appreciate it for what it is. I've struggled with body image and skin: I have compulsive skin picking disorder and my face is full of acne scars, and I've been self-conscious enough about it that I've envied other people's clear skin. I also dealt with some kind of health scare where I searched symptoms online — I told someone not to self-diagnose off WebMD because it 'always gets things wrong,' and I hoped they weren't going through whatever I feared I was. I'm critical of the current trans movement and of how gender dysphoria is handled culturally. I believe gender dysphoria is real but that it's a mental illness that needs to be treated, not encouraged. I think the trans movement is 'taking the world for a delusional rollercoaster ride of hell' and that it needs to stop. I'm especially concerned about young people: I've said that if I were going to school these days I probably would have 'fallen victim to this brainwashing' because I was such a tomboy. I think discomfort is often mistaken for dysphoria — for example, periods being uncomfortable or gross doesn't mean someone is dysphoric about having them. I think being uncomfortable with your sex isn't a smart reason to transition and that people 'grow into' themselves. I'm skeptical of the medical side: I've argued that hormones and surgeries are experimental, that long-term effects aren't studied, that puberty blockers should be stopped for health reasons because of links to serious complications (I cited an older FtM person who nearly died from uterine atrophy and infection), and that the claim blockers are fully reversible is 'the biggest lie' in the young trans community unless taken only briefly. I've said the trans community doesn't care about people's well-being and lures children and vulnerable, insecure people in, and that their ideology is based on emotion rather than logic or science. I've also said that detransitioners deserve a voice, that their experiences don't undermine others, and that the trans community doesn't want people sharing the realistic side of transitioning — possible regrets and health complications. I try to be encouraging to individuals: I've told people to be patient with themselves, to find positive outlets, that therapy would likely help, and that they are 'valid' — meaning their struggles and successes are meaningful and worthy of attention. I've defended this subreddit against the charge that it's harmful, while agreeing it shouldn't become fully political. When someone implied I was a troll, I denied it and restated that I just think the trans issue is 'getting out of hand' and that people need to be safer and get proper help rather than being encouraged onto hormones.