Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een man die niet is getransitioneerd maar mijn genderidentiteit heeft verkend, en ik omschrijf mezelf als heteroseksueel, hoogfunctionerend autistisch en zonder duidelijk label voor mijn identiteit (het dichtst in de buurt komt Prince). Ik gebruik sinds 2006 EFT-tappingtherapie en pleit voor therapie boven medische transitie om trauma en dysforie op te lossen. Ik ben zeer kritisch over de medische transitie-industrie en stel dat die winstgedreven is, dat passing onmogelijk is en dat HRT/operaties grotendeels onomkeerbaar zijn. Ik heb zelf geen hormonen of operaties gehad en heb geen persoonlijke spijt over transitie uitgesproken, maar ik heb anderen gewaarschuwd voor kleinere datingmogelijkheden en operatiecomplicaties. Mijn huidige identiteit is een heteroseksuele, aan zijn gender twijfelende man die niet-medische manieren zoekt om zichzelf uit te drukken.
Volledig verhaal
I am a male who has been working through questions about gender identity publicly on r/detrans during mid-2022. I have never claimed to have transitioned myself; instead I have described myself as still trying to figure out my gender identity, saying at one point that 'I still have no idea if there is even a name for my gender identity' and that the closest match I have found is 'the rockstar Ƭ̵̬̊ (Prince)'.
I have described myself as 100% straight sexually, and I have two entirely separate wardrobes: one belonging to 'the average chad' and one that 'clearly belongs to a very flamboyant gay man'. I said this split is one reason I have started to explore gender. I also said I enjoy being 'the guy that confuses the hell out of everyone'. I have noted that 'Girls jeans still look great on me though and no-one needs to know lol', and that I don't have child-bearing hips and will always have an adam's apple.
I have described myself as high-functioning autistic: 'I am high-functioning autistic myself. For me it just means I need things explaining when they don't make any sense.' I have used EFT/tapping therapy since 2006 and recommended EFT, EMDR, and TRE for trauma processing.
I have not described any hormones, surgeries, or puberty blockers for myself. I have, however, discussed medical transition extensively in advising others: I have argued that 'HRT is very hard or impossible to reverse', that 'Passing is impossible', and that surgically constructed vaginas can 'grow hair inside and collect faecal bacteria, leaving a bad smell' and that this 'seems to be a strong factor in trans regret stories'. I have also written critically about the medical establishment: 'Gender dysphoria is extremely profitable to surgeons and to the pharmaceutical industry' and 'Many well-meaning therapists have been trained by the pharmaceutical industry to tell someone that their problems will go away if they transition. It's simply not true.'
I have been critical of the concept of gender identity as socially constructed, arguing that 'The danger of defining Gender as "social" is that it's in reference to the world around you' and asking whether one is 'still a man or a woman if you are alone on a desert island'. I have argued that gender non-conforming people have always existed and that what is new is 'the transgender hormone and surgery industry are telling you what to do if you are that.' I have also stated bluntly to another poster, 'You are a female who was scammed by the transgender industry.'
I have advised others that therapy (EFT/EMDR/TRE) can resolve trauma underlying gender dysphoria: 'Fix the issues and the dysphoria will go away' and 'Recovering from trauma including sexual trauma is a well-trodden path. No-one regrets successful therapy later, like they regret transitioning, which is really a way of avoiding healing the trauma.' I have also warned that transition shrinks one's dating pool: 'the choice to do those things was the choice to cut your dating pool down to a tiny fragment of what it was.'
I have not described any personal regret about transition because I have not described undergoing one. I have not described a current relationship, family situation, or career. I have not described suicidal ideation or self-harm. My current status is that I am a male, straight, autistic, still exploring my gender identity without medical intervention, and skeptical of medical transition for others.