Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die me als depressieve tiener als trans identificeerde en bijna volledig sociaal transitioneerde, maar nooit met hormonen of operaties begon nadat een therapeut me richting medische transitie duwde en ik in plaats daarvan pauzeerde om erover na te denken. Toen ik ouder was en op een betere plek zat, besefte ik dat ik niet trans was — de wens om te transitioneren verdween terwijl ik depressie, laag zelfbeeld en problemen met mijn lichaamsbeeld aanpakte, en ik wendde me tot het christendom om mijn gevoelens over mijn lichaam te verwerken. Ik identificeer me nu als vrouw, pleit tegen transitie voor mensen met onopgeloste onderliggende problemen en ben kritisch op therapeuten en online gemeenschappen die mensen richting transitie duwen.
Volledig verhaal
I was a teenager dealing with depression and generally hating life when I first heard about transgenderism and came to believe I was trans. I didn't like my body, the way a lot of girls at that age don't, and I had a history of being bullied and not feeling like I fit in. When I first mentioned the idea of being trans to my therapist, she immediately started giving me information on where to go to get hormones and said she'd write any letter needed — she kept pushing me to do it even as I was pushing it off. Not once did she try to figure out whether I was actually trans; she just pushed me to start transitioning.
What actually started me questioning things was hearing about the side effects of medical transition that people tend to ignore. It made me question whether it was worth it. I started putting off starting anything and, for the first time, actually thought the whole thing through — thinking about more than just how I felt in the moment. I realized transition wasn't going to fix me and would likely make things worse. I decided to block out all the people encouraging me to be trans and instead focused on my mental state and how to work through my illness without making decisions I would never be able to undo. During that time I also turned to Christianity, which helped me work through my feelings toward myself and my body.
I had almost entirely socially transitioned, though I never started physically transitioning. I felt intense euphoria every time I felt I looked like a man, but it never lasted — as soon as that moment passed, I was back to the same depressed teen who hated her body. I never quite felt happy with myself the way I do now. Looking back, I don't think I was really interested in actually transitioning; I think I wanted the way it eased my dislike for my body, plus the social aspect. I enjoyed having a community, and I enjoyed being considered unique and brave for transitioning. At some point I actually looked inward and tried to find out if I genuinely wanted to transition or just wanted the perks.
Once I was older and in a better place, I realized I wasn't trans — it was a mental problem I needed to work through. I had depression and low self-esteem, and as soon as I moved past those issues, the desire to transition started to disappear. After I made some serious changes in my life, I became happier in general and the "dysphoric" feelings vanished. I also came to see that when I first started believing I was trans, I justified the new identity by finding everything in my past that supported it — confirmation bias affecting my view of myself.
I never had hormones, surgeries, or puberty blockers, so there were no irreversible medical changes to undo. My detransition was essentially a matter of never starting physical transition and socially coming back to living as female. I now identify as a woman and I'm not trans. I have strong critical views about transition, particularly for young people: I advocate against transitioning because I don't feel it solves underlying issues, I'm critical of therapists who push transition without exploring why someone has these feelings, and I'm critical of what I see as a culture that pushes people toward being trans and treats anything short of complete support for transition as hatred of trans people. I also believe bottom surgery patients become "patients for life," which creates financial incentive, and that doctors may operate out of fear of backlash for refusing. I regularly advise others to step away from social media and pushy communities, to cut down or stop porn (which I believe can strengthen fetishes), to tackle underlying issues like self-esteem and bullying history in therapy before considering transition, and to remember that it's much harder to detransition than to transition later in life. I describe my own experience as a "temporary transgender journey" and a phase that sometimes just takes an outside force to realize.