Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben als vrouw geboren en voelde me een groot deel van mijn leven ongemakkelijk in mezelf, waarbij ik voortdurend van persona wisselde, totdat het krijgen van een kind mijn aandacht naar buiten richtte en me hielp tot rust te komen. Ik heb echte tegenspoed meegemaakt, waaronder een jaar in mijn auto slapen, en ik werk nog aan zelfacceptatie. Ik ben scherp kritisch geworden over medische transitie, vooral voor kinderen, die ik zie als een ideologie van bovenaf die inspeelt op de beïnvloedbaarheid van jonge mensen en medische winst boven gezondheid stelt. Ik steun mensen die er in zichzelf rustig uitzien en moedig eerlijkheid en volledige informatie aan voor iedereen die over deze beslissingen nadenkt. Ik presenteer me als vrouw en voed mijn zoon op terwijl ik aan mezelf blijf werken.
Volledig verhaal
I have been open on here about a lot of my own life while talking with other people in this community, and looking back over what I've shared, a picture of where I've come from emerges.
I was born female, and for much of my life I felt genuinely uncomfortable with myself as a woman. In my own words, I "felt really uncomfortable with myself a lot in my life, as a female," feeling like I should sound or look or act or think certain ways. I changed my persona repeatedly, trying on new ways of expressing myself that I thought would be more likable. I don't give exact ages for when this started, but it clearly spanned a long stretch of my adult life.
At some point I had a child, and that became a turning point. I've said that the discomfort "lessened a lot after I had a child" because the focus was taken away from myself and onto my child, and that it helped me with a lot of things. I ended up homeschooling my son, which I described as a way to keep him focused on academics more than identity complexities, because I think it's better for self-esteem not to be so confused from so young. I was homeschooled myself growing up, and I've told others that homeschoolers can be very accomplished — starting college early with dual enrollment, graduating early or with double majors, or going to prestigious colleges — so I'm confident the opportunities are there if you go that route.
I've also been through real hardship. I slept in my car for a year at one point, and I've offered that advice to others who might end up in the same situation. I've dealt with people I've described as having "low levels of maturity and compassion," and I've worked on loving myself, self-care, and getting my life in the direction I want it to go, one step at a time while figuring out the bigger picture.
On the question of transition and medical intervention, I've become quite critical. I've written that "a lot of the pharmaceuticals and surgeries trans will subject themselves to, will actually be self-inflicted adverse health repercussions down the line," and I've said it's wild what people focus on instead of actual health. I believe we should prioritize a meaningfully educated population over medical industry profits, because it seems like we're protecting a right to profit more than a right to be educated enough not to make decisions that ruin one's own health. I've told people not to worry about "hurting" trans people by looking into surgery — they should see all sides and not be hidden from them. I do think people need to take responsibility for their choices, but I've also come to see this as a top-down ideology that has been intentionally pushed on children and mainstream culture, which I find disgusting and wrong, because humans are impressionable and children and young adults more so. When someone described a physical change, I attributed it bluntly: "That's a result of taking hormones." I've encouraged people considering regret to talk to others and say so out loud — "Tell them you regret it. They may not hear you, but they might" — and I've advised a parent to be honest with a daughter who was considering transition, saying she probably wants to please you and thinks it will make her cool, so tell her you don't want her to do it, that it's dangerous, not cool, and that you love her the way she is.
I've been supportive when I see people who look happy and at home in themselves, commenting "Gorgeous!!!" and "You are a wildly beautiful woman. It suits you so much" on photos of detransitioned or re-identified women. I use Walmart as a kind of reality check against social media fakeness — walking the aisles to remind myself that this is what real people look like, that I'm good enough, and that I'm like everyone else. I've said we're all perfectly imperfect and human, and that one day I'll find my person who loves me for all I've evolved into or failed to evolve into.
On family, I've recognized that my mom has issues and that it's really just her, not me — I'm glad she isn't worse, and some kids have it much worse, but it's good to recognize it and not take it personally. I've been through a period of over-analyzing and over-criticizing myself, and I'm still working on who I'm becoming, but it's gotten easier.
I don't give a precise current identity label for myself in these posts, but I present and am received as a woman, and I'm raising my son, working on myself, and holding a critical view of how transition is pushed on young people.