Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die het grootste deel van mijn jonge volwassen leven openlijk lesbisch leefde en nu een normaal leven met gezin en kinderen wil. Ik ben zelf nooit medisch getransitioneerd, maar ik postte uitgebreid over een goede mannelijke vriend die naar vrouw transitioneerde, stealth doorging en daarna detransitioneerde toen hij besefte dat hij qua gedrag een man was, en vervolgens ernstige lichaamsdysmorfie en haaruitval kreeg waardoor hij huisgebonden raakte. Ik geef diep om hem en zocht succesverhalen zodat hij weer in de samenleving kon functioneren. Ik werk in financiële dienstverlening, consulting en daarna tech, en lees in mijn vrije tijd Latijn en Grieks. Ik heb gendercritische opvattingen en geloof dat wat IRL telt is hoe anderen je als man of vrouw zien en niet het online debat.
Volledig verhaal
I want to tell my story, though a lot of what I know about this process I first learned through a close male friend of mine who went through something similar, and through the questions I asked him and others.
I lived most of my young adult life as openly lesbian. I was never someone who wanted to make a big deal out of it — I found gay pride events, with their emphasis on showing off how weird being gay could get, alienating. Not all gays and lesbians want that kind of pride. I just wanted to live a normal life with a family and children. To me, being gay or lesbian is neither something to be proud of nor something to be ashamed of; it is as relevant as my blood type, outside the domain of romantic and intimate relationships. If every gay or lesbian around me or in the media had been the loud and proud type, hitting on everyone of the same sex or talking about their wild sexual experiences to complete strangers, I certainly would have pretended to have a boyfriend instead.
I also saw how masculine women get punished in the workplace, especially in fields where traditional masculine and feminine roles are reinforced. I was "encouraged" to wear makeup, skirts, and so on as a junior person out of school. They didn't care whether I was into men or women, but I needed to make the company look good. I worked in financial services, consulting, and then tech — the pursuit of money was my top priority for a long time, and academia was not satisfactory in that regard. In my free time, which I have a lot of, I read Latin, Greek, and other classical material; I happen to be a part-time Latinist.
The closest I came to understanding transition deeply was through a male friend. He hated his male body as a teenager and transitioned to female a few years ago. Although he passed really well physically and managed to be stealth, he felt a lot of anxiety and was constantly afraid of being clocked, so he could not have any meaningful social interactions. He met a trans woman who changed his view of what "real trans women" should be like — that person naturally had female mannerisms and had to suppress them to act as a man, and her transition was seamless, with people immediately seeing her as a cis woman. My friend, by contrast, had to learn female mannerisms — how to walk, stand, smile — and would automatically revert to male mannerisms when he became less conscious of his presentation. He felt he was acting. That was what convinced him he was not a "real trans woman."
Having realized he was behaviorally male, he detransitioned about a year ago. It went well for a few months, but soon after he experienced severe hair loss as he was no longer on HRT. Now he hates his body so much that he refuses to see or talk to any person in real life. He knows he should see a therapist, but a few weeks later he said he could not talk to one because he's too ugly and didn't want anyone else to see him. I posted asking for success stories from people like him — by success I meant being able to function normally in society, and I said I didn't really care whether he took hormones or lived as a man or a woman as long as he could fully participate in society. I also asked other detransitioned people whether they felt fake for the same reason he did — having to act on their mannerisms — or whether it was something deeper, like a feeling of not belonging to women deep down despite being perceived as a woman without conscious effort, and whether they had trouble passing as a normal male despite naturally feminine mannerisms.
I have also thought a lot about how the world perceives people. I've told someone directly that it doesn't matter whether you are trans or detrans — what matters IRL is whether people see you as male or female. I don't know whether T changed their bone structure or whatnot; if it did, they will unfortunately need to go through what many trans women have to go through. I think it might be easier to accept what other people think of you rather than try to "correct" them — you simply cannot correct another person's perception of you — and hopefully time will eventually do its work and people's perception will change. I've also said that normies don't care about "biological sex," at least as long as they are not trying to sleep with you, and that all the GC-versus-trans discussion is kind of online nonsense. I've noted that the modern trans movement is basically about being loud and proud, which forces trans folks who just want to live a normal life — family, career, children — to be stealth, and that unlike LGB, trans has never been normalized in public image.
On other matters, I've shared my view that IQ distribution among women is much narrower than among men — men are more likely to be geniuses but also more likely to be morons — while noting notable women at the top of intellectual achievement like Marie Curie, Emmy Noether, and Hypatia of Alexandria. I've also remarked that I am extremely male brained.