Alle verhalen

Transitie kon zijn biologie niet veranderen — dus stopte hij met proberen

Man · Gedetransitioneerd507
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben man geboren, identificeerde als trans en detransitioneerde nadat ik concludeerde dat transitie mijn aangeboren biologie nooit kon veranderen. Ik identificeer me nu als gedetransitioneerde man die openlijk anti-trans is, gender volledig wil afschaffen en massale detransitie bij anderen wil inspireren. Ik zie mijn eigen resterende dissociatie van mijn geslacht als iets om te doorstaan in plaats van medisch aan te pakken, en ik adviseer anderen te stoppen met hormonen en hun lichaam met rust te laten. Ik beschrijf in dit transcript geen specifieke psychische diagnoses, medische complicaties of suïcidale gedachten. Mijn verzet tegen transitie is ideologisch en vastberaden, en ik bied actief aan anderen te helpen detransitioneren.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male and identified as trans for a period before detransitioning. Looking back, I came to understand that transition was never going to be enough because it wouldn't change my innate biology — that realization is what moved me toward detransition. I also recognize in myself a persistent dissociation from my sex that I don't think can be fully resolved; my approach now is to ignore and distract from it by doing things I enjoy and simply putting up with it, since we can't change our sex and have to move forward with who and what we are by nature. I don't have a detailed public timeline of my own transition in these posts — no dates for first dysphoria, coming out, hormones, or surgeries — so I'll leave those blank rather than guess. What I do talk about openly is my thinking about why people transition in general, and I apply it to myself: I think a large proportion of transition comes from wanting to escape an assigned social position — males wanting to escape being seen as the oppressor, females wanting to escape being oppressed — while gender roles continue to be enforced, so trying to be something you aren't doesn't solve the underlying problem. I'm now openly critical of transition and of gender as a concept. I've said plainly that I'm what many would call transphobic, but more accurately anti-trans: I want to uproot the concept of gender itself from people's minds and society, bring about the complete end of trans identification by inspiring mass detransition, help people understand the truth of themselves and their dissociation from their sex, abolish gender roles and stereotypes, achieve what I call 'sex egality,' and leave all of it as a dark past we learn from together. I've offered directly to help others detransition — telling one person, 'I'd like to help you detransition in any way that I can, I just don't want you to hurt yourself.' I also believe that anyone not 'too far gone in their delusions and sunk-cost-fallacy' will detransition. I frame trans identity as something caused by encountering the trans community and being convinced by them that not conforming to stereotypes means you're something you're not — 'grooming and coercion,' in my words — with people continuing transition through 'self-loathing disguised as self-love, Stockholm syndrome and the sunk-cost fallacy.' I view gender itself as 'a lie born from Sexism,' a reinvention of sociocultural sex stereotypes, and I say there are no 'Trans people,' only people who internalise and externalise those abstract concepts. I'm skeptical of broader identity-label culture too, comparing some of it to 'astrology for people who think they're more intelligent than they actually are,' and I think people with ordinary struggles get sorted into boxes like 'trans' or 'autistic' simply for being different. On practical matters, I've advised people to stop taking testosterone and let their bodies be naturally estrogen dominant, arguing the desire to keep changing yourself will stop and your mind will settle. I've suggested alternatives like presenting as a butch woman with a deep voice, or using no pronouns and just a name. I've also said that destroying your own reproductive system out of hatred for your body is worse than just putting up with your body, since you can't change what you're born with. I don't describe a specific therapy experience, mental health diagnosis, or medical complication for myself in these posts. I do have strong views on adversity: I believe sexualisation by others is what harms people and makes them think badly of their bodies and question themselves — 'there's nothing wrong with your body, it's the sexualisation from others.' I've told others they're beautiful and have 'just gone through a lot of shit' that led them to think otherwise. I don't discuss my own sexuality, family, or career in this transcript. On social and political attitudes, I reject 'live and let live,' saying I call people by what they are because we are our bodies, and I believe in honesty and doing the right thing even if people hate me for it. I think people need to band together to change society so life doesn't 'suck as much.' I'm frustrated that I can't find people in person who aren't 'entrapped within gender ideology,' and I relate most to unfeminine young women as a young man who is neither masculine nor feminine and is weary of men. I see the discourse as binary — 'you are either 100% pro-trans in their eyes or you are anti-trans' — and I've described r/detrans as a support group for struggling and traumatised people to help each other and learn not to hate themselves. I don't describe any formal advocacy or activism beyond these online statements.