Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and started identifying as a boy in my mid-teens. I socially transitioned and lived as a trans man for about four years, but because I was under 18 the entire time, I never took testosterone or had any surgery. I came out publicly and told people around me that I wanted to be referred to as a boy.
Looking back, I don't think I was ever really trans in the way others claimed. I behaved in a stereotypical and, for a female, pretty misogynistic way — I was "acting like a real man" — and I now think that was driven by insecurity rather than by any feminist beliefs. In fact, I'm conservative and anti-modern feminism. I believe femininity is fine for those it suits, but I'm a butch lesbian and it never felt right to me. I think a lot of trans-identified females, myself included, were essentially "brainwashed into thinking our masculinity made us trans men."
I desisted around the start of 2023, at 18. Coming back was easier than I expected: I had done nothing irreversible, so it was just a matter of telling people I wanted to be called a girl again. A few people asked why, but most didn't care beyond a question or two. The hardest part was coming to terms with it myself. I cut off nearly all the people who had known me as trans, and the shame and embarrassment of having been a trans kid has mostly faded — I'm forgetting I ever was trans.
Now I'm just me. I haven't tried to be feminine, but I let myself be interested in whatever I'm naturally into. I still present butch and have a masculine-type face, so in public people often read me as a boy — I get mistaken for a child when I buy alcohol and have to explain I'm 18, not 12, which wears me down. I'm not ready to wear women's clothing because I don't like it, though I've considered makeup and feminine clothes just to stop being misread; it feels like it wouldn't be true to me. My hair is still growing out from the short cut I had, and I hate waiting for it. I also notice that people find my interests and music taste weird, but don't care if they think I'm a dude — I'm "weird" for a girl.
I have no medical regrets because I never had hormones or surgery, though I did consider it. I've thought about testosterone's permanent effects — bottom growth, voice changes, hair loss — and I'm glad I never went down that path. I do carry some psychological scars from living a lie for four years; breaking down over the thought of faking being a man "made me feel like a complete f***ing idiot," and accepting that I'm stuck as a "weird female" was painful.
I'm active in detransitioner spaces and give advice to younger people questioning transition. I tell them to find the root cause of their dysphoria — trauma, bullying, homosexuality, online communities — and to give it time, since medical transition is irreversible and there's no rush. I'm critical of how detransitioners are used politically on both sides: I argue that some activists dismiss us as "never trans" because our stories threaten the case for childhood medical transition, and I also push back against conservative audiences who only embrace straight, gender-conforming detransitioners while being uncomfortable with masculine or lesbian women. I'm skeptical of figures like Buck Angel, whom I view as a fetishist, and of Norah Vincent's experiment, which I don't find convincing. I don't seek out people whose company I probably wouldn't enjoy.
I have not experienced suicidal ideation or self-harm since detransitioning. My mental health has improved as I've accepted myself, though I still deal with the social friction of being a visibly gender-nonconforming woman.