Alle verhalen

Een pleitbezorger die zelf nooit transitioneerde

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd903
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gendernonconforme vrouw van middelbare leeftijd en moeder van twee die nooit is getransitioneerd, maar een prominente pleitbezorger werd in de detransitiegemeenschap nadat mijn eigen OCD-gerelateerde worsteling en tienerhaat tegen mijn borsten met de tijd overgingen. Ik heb zelf nooit genderdysforie gehad; ik voel me 'een persoon zonder gender' die mannelijk gezelschap verkiest, en ik dank mijn herstel aan CGT/DGT en volwassenheid. Sinds 2019 heb ik informed-consent-documenten over testosteronrisico's georganiseerd, een petitie aan de Surgeon General gepromoot, gepusht voor publicatie van detransitie-casusbeschrijvingen, mensen met advocaten in contact gebracht en mensen aangespoord hun behandelaars aan te klagen. Ik ben sterk kritisch over gender-affirmerende therapie, puberteitsremmers en medische transitie bij jongeren, en zie ROGD als gedreven door autisme, ADHD, OCD, porno en sociale besmetting. Ik blijf een bondgenoot van de detransitiegemeenschap en geen gedetransitioneerd persoon, en ik identificeer me nu als vrouw van middelbare leeftijd en moeder.

Volledig verhaal

I am a middle-aged woman and a mother of two kids. I never felt that I belonged with other girls — I always felt they were a different species — and I never felt that I had a "gender" long before there was any public talk of such things. I prefer male company, feel competitive with men, like their sense of humor; they feel like my "peers." I also have a problem with my vocal cords that I was born with, which caused years of trauma I hid and never dealt with properly; I had voice therapy as a teen that taught me to speak an octave higher, but it felt fake so I did not stick with it. As a teen I was binding my breasts because I hated them. My mom noticed and mocked me harshly, then went out and bought me a bra — not a minimizer or sports bra, but the opposite — and I remember the dread and self-loathing of having to wear it. Over time the issue faded; now I don't care one way or the other about my breasts — they are like my hands, my feet, my nose — and they are saggy since I breast-fed both of my kids. I describe myself as gender-conforming now because I know what looks good on my body, but I say that if I had been born a guy I would have done just fine. I also note that before having kids I liked only geometric patterns, was very logical and not emotional, and could never wear a bikini; as I got older I started appreciating more feminine patterns and even got myself a bikini. I have had an OCD-related mental health issue that was crippling for years and is now barely an issue, which I cite as evidence that the brain eventually rewires itself. I have never had gender dysphoria myself. I identify as a Democrat, though I say I am "not sure for how much longer." I have talked with Abigail Shrier in the past and describe her as fair and respectful of LGBT people. I am active in advocating against youth medical transition: I helped organize a project compiling testosterone effects into an informed-consent document for physicians, helped coordinate a letter to insurance companies from clinicians and detransitioners, promoted a petition to the Surgeon General, encouraged detransitioners to publish case reports (referencing Dr. Ken Zucker's call for them), and reached out to a UK attorney willing to help UK detransitioners pursue legal action. I have offered to connect people with Abigail Shrier and her agent, and I have repeatedly urged people to consider suing their doctors and therapists. I was banned from r/asktransgender within minutes after offering gentle, cautious advice to a straight girl who identified as FTM. My views are strongly critical of gender-affirming therapy and youth transition. I argue that gender dysphoria is real but that transition is a last-resort, highly imperfect treatment for a rare, severe, lifelong condition, and that today's cases are largely ROGD driven by autism, ADHD, OCD, stress, porn, and social contagion. I recommend CBT/DBT for body dysmorphia and obsessive thinking, and I advise waiting until at least 25-30 before any permanent decisions. I have never detransitioned myself — I never transitioned — but I am deeply involved in the detransition community as an ally, parent-advocate, and organizer.