Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben als vrouw geboren en identificeerde me jarenlang als transmasculien, maar ben nooit medisch getransitioneerd. Nu identificeer ik me als vrouw, al voel ik me niet op mijn gemak bij het label ‘cis’. Mijn dysforie werd gevoed door endometriose, PMDD, PCOS, vleesboomgezwellen, gewichtstoename, een beperkende moeder die zich feminien presenteerde, een vader met problematische opvattingen over vrouwen, mogelijk ADHD/autisme, en online retoriek die zei dat dysforie alleen met transitie te genezen was. Ik knapte op dankzij antidepressiva (Lexapro), tijd, het herstellen van mijn relatie met mijn moeder en het besef dat transitie mijn geslacht niet echt zou veranderen. Ik ben nu bijna 40, politiek extreem links, en laat me online luid horen met mijn standpunt dat transitie niet het enige antwoord op genderdysforie is, terwijl ik nog steeds geloof dat het sommigen helpt. Ik heb nog steeds te maken met chronische gezondheidsproblemen die bij vrouw-zijn horen en met enkele aanhoudende wensen dat ik als man geboren was, al zijn die met de leeftijd minder geworden.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I never took the medical route of transition, though I came very close to wanting to. For years I identified as transmasc and believed I wanted to live as a man. My dysphoria centered on wishing I had been born male, hating my breasts (which I described as being 'in the way' and slowing me down), dreading pregnancy and breast and ovarian cancer, and feeling awful during periods. I asked my ob/gyn about a double mastectomy and she refused, saying no doctor with integrity would do an unnecessary risky surgery like that.
What drove my feelings was a mix of things I've only fully pieced together recently. I had endometriosis, PMDD, PCOS and fibroids, which led to IBS, depression and anxiety. I was overweight at one point and gaining weight actually triggered more dysphoria — I felt I was losing my feminine features and thought 'maybe I'm just really manly.' My mother was raised in the 50s-60s and constantly pushed me to be more feminine — waxing my eyebrows, blonde highlights, earrings, makeup, flowery dresses — and rejected the clothes I picked out, which felt restrictive and like she didn't appreciate my uniqueness. My father was 'problematic in the way he looked at women,' which affected how I felt about my body. I also suspect I'm neurodivergent — ADHD and mildly autistic — which made me feel lonely and unable to keep up with peers. I'm bisexual and was confused about how my sexuality related to my gender.
I read online that 'if you think your life would have been better as the other gender then you are trans' and 'if you have dysphoria the only cure is to transition,' and I heard 'no cis woman wants to be a man, so you must be trans' over and over. I was very depressed and read happy transition stories thinking I'd feel better. Instead I started antidepressants — Lexapro — which helped but very slowly, taking about a year to see a turnaround, and my mood is now much more balanced. I also take a progesterone-only birth control continuously so I don't have a period, and I take a daily pill with androgenic effects that caused significant hair loss, which I slowed with a caffeinated shampoo and leave-in treatment, though my hairline still looks receded.
Over time I realized transitioning wouldn't actually make me male — most people would still see me as female, and no matter what I did I would be female — so I decided to stop obsessing over it and focus on bettering my life. Repairing my relationship with my mother (before she died) helped, as did getting older; I used to picture myself as an old man but now I live more in the moment. I've never felt 'like a man' because I don't know what that's like. I was hospitalized for something neurological/vascular and had low B12 during a period of increased dysphoria. I've dealt with self-hatred and shame about my body, and I relate to others' struggles with appearance and self-esteem.
I'm now nearly 40 and approaching that age with much less concern about labels. I'm less comfortable with 'cis' than 'woman' because 'cis' was thrust upon me; I tried 'non-binary woman' but that felt weird too, so I mostly just care about my health and survival. I'm still far left/socialist politically and insist my position isn't right-wing. I'm critical of the idea that dysphoria can only be treated by transition, at least for some cases, and I've become vocal about that online — criticizing gender ideology terminology, the sports debate, the medicalization of gender-nonconforming youth, and what I see as doctors sweeping detransitioners under the rug. I've recommended Dr. Azi Hakeem's non-pressuring approach and encouraged people to stop engaging with trans content online. I don't oppose transition for others — I believe some people are genuinely happier transitioning — but I think the current framework is wrong for many, and I hope people learn you don't have to be trans to be yourself.