Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gendercritische vrouw van in de 50, aan de rand van detransitie, die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd maar van jongs af aan genderdysforie had totdat die rond mijn 20e verdween. Ik ben vrouw, getrouwd, moeder van één kind, in de overgang, gebruik oestrogeenvervanging en kreeg in 2019 de diagnose ADHD, met angst, een verleden van boulimia en aanhoudende nood over mijn lichaamsbeeld. Ik had suïcidale gedachten die met de overgang en lichaamshaat samenhingen, en ik omschrijf mezelf als ‘dysforisch tot ik ongeveer 20 was’ voordat ik uitgroeide tot een ‘jongensgek biseksueel meisje’. Ik ben zeer actief in gendercritisch en detrans-activisme, spoor aan tot rechtszaken tegen artsen en politiek lobbyen, en waarschuw anderen voor transitie, pornografie en online transgemeenschappen. Ik zeg uitdrukkelijk dat ik ‘niet trans of detrans’ ben, maar spreek vanuit eigen ervaring met dysforie die met de tijd verdween.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I never transitioned myself, but gender dysphoria has been part of my life since I was young. I often describe myself as having been a 'butch girl in the 80s' — I identified with androgynous women like Annie Lennox and k.d. lang, and I preferred hanging out with guys since childhood. I say plainly that I've 'never been trans and I'm afab and I don't identify as a woman. I'm female. I'm an adult. That makes me a woman. It's not a feeling. It's a biological fact.'
My dysphoria didn't resolve through transition — it faded on its own. I've told people here: 'The most likely outcome for you, statistically speaking, is that you will mature out of your dysphoria. I was dysphoric until I was about 20. Then it slowly went away when I became more experienced and confident with my sexuality and my body and who I was. For me that was a boy crazy bi-girl who liked lacy undies and cowboy boots.' I'm grateful the poisonous protocols weren't widely known when I went through it: 'Thank goodness when I went through gender dysphoria these poisonous protocols weren't widely known.'
I'm in my 50s now. I describe myself as a menopausal woman, and I take synthetic estrogen as hormone replacement — I've had real difficulty getting it filled, calling pharmacies across town and often not being able to get a full prescription because of shortages. I've said: 'I'm a menopausal woman with multiple symptoms relating to hormone depletion including almost daily suicidal ideation.' I had my uterus removed — 'it was great for a while but now my internal organs are falling out my vagina' — and I warn others about prolapse risk. I developed swallowing issues with menopause. My ADHD got dramatically worse with menopause, and I was diagnosed with ADHD this year (2019) after learning about RSD (rejection sensitivity dysphoria). I also experience anxiety, which I say is 'probably what's causing your dysphoria too' in my own case, and I've had panic attacks through menopause. I've struggled with my weight — I describe myself as 'grossly fat and flabby' with a bloated face, and I say looking in the mirror causes me 'acute distress' that affects my social life, sex life, marriage, professional life and general health, causing depression and suicidal ideation. I wanted weight-loss drugs and surgery but couldn't get them because they're bad for you.
I was bulimic as a teen. I've compared gender dysphoria to that experience: 'Accepting that is just as hard for you as accepting my weight was as a bulimic teen.' I mention that many GC women experience sex dysphoria and body dysphoria, and that 'many of us starved or purged, abused drugs or self-harmed.' I was anorgasmic my whole life and am now basically asexual. I stopped at one child because I hated being pregnant, and I'm not sure I ever liked sex. I'm married. I'm an atheist, though I respect religion's comfort for others, and I've described myself as an ex-Christian who avoids believers, including believers 'of trans ideology.' I was a butch girl in the 80s and I loved androgynous people; I say I'm 'completely closeted as gendercritical IRL' but friendly with trans people individually. I have trans colleagues in my line of work (working with young people) who post hundreds of topless selfies on Instagram, which I describe as obsession, not happiness.
I've never been a detransitioner, and I say so directly: 'Though technically I'm not trans or detrans. I did have gender dysphoria as a young person. Still do to an extent.' I believe 'GD is caused by suicidality, not the other way around.' I'm very active in gender critical spaces and consider r/gendercritical my community ('You need r/gendercritical, sis. Come on over'). I've done extensive advocacy: encouraging people to contact lawyers about malpractice suits, write to politicians (I've named Canadian federal health minister Patty Hajdu and NDP health critic Don Davies), report doctors to medical boards, and speak to journalists. I've argued that detrans spaces should not allow non-detransitioned trans people to post, and I've pushed back against what I see as a 'coordinated incursion' into r/detrans. I've recommended resources like the Boyce of Reason podcast with William Malone MD, 4thwavenow, The Pique Resilience Project, and r/nofap and r/pornfree. I've told people considering surgery to cancel it, and I've told parents to take away phones and WiFi. I've been told I'm harsh and condescending; my response: 'Thanks, I guess.' I've said 'I'm in this to save lives and hearts.'