Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die vooral wilde transitioneren om de puberteit terug te draaien en geen man te worden, en ik ben gedesisteerd mede doordat ik besefte dat ik nooit als vrouw zou doorgaan. Ik ben nooit met HRT begonnen, mijn ouders zijn blij dat ik gedetransitioneerd ben, terwijl mijn transgemeenschap wil dat ik doorga. Ik zie mijn transitiewens nu als verbonden met nostalgie, angst voor onafhankelijkheid en (bij anderen zoals ik) door porno aangewakkerde AGP, en ik raad anderen actief af te transitioneren. Ik blijf kritisch op de moderne LHBT-gemeenschap, trans-activisme en transmedicalisme, en ik verwerp labels als 'cisgender' en 'non-binair'.
Volledig verhaal
I am male, and what drove me toward transition was not really a wish to be a woman but a wish to undo puberty. I wanted to suppress my testosterone and take estrogen mainly because I wanted to go back to before puberty began. I didn't like how puberty made me angsty, stressed, horny, and looking more like a man physically — I just wanted to be a sweet little boy and not mature into a man. I coped at first by living in denial that I was even undergoing puberty and maturing; for a while I refused to let anyone remind me of my age or call me a teenager. After that I coped by constantly looking at pictures of myself when I was younger and heavily indulging in nostalgia to try to relive those days. Finally I discovered trans stuff on the internet and wanted to use transitioning to avoid maturing into a man by becoming a woman instead. I also had anxiety about having to be independent, which I didn't want.
I never started HRT. Realizing that I would, most likely, never pass compared to a cis woman, even after HRT and all the surgeries, is part of what made me desist. I described my trans life as one lived on autopilot: 'I just lived every day of my trans life on autopilot, doing the bare minimum and thinking about little except trans stuff.' I was also unrealistic about what I was doing, what my life was like, and what I expected would happen.
My parents are definitely happy I am detransitioning, but everyone I know in the trans community wants me to continue transitioning. I see this as a common pattern: trans people feel that detransitions reflect badly on them, so they either tell you that you weren't really trans or that you're confused and should continue transitioning. I have given up on civil discourse with most trans people, though there are a couple I enjoy talking to; I find many of them paranoid and dogmatic, and I believe they project strength because deep down they are uncertain and insecure about their identities.
I have strong views about causes of transition in others. I believe porn addiction and autogynephilia (AGP) drive a lot of male transition, and I have advised others struggling with sissy or trans porn urges to work on their addiction through a 12-step program rather than Nofap, warning that transitioning at that stage is an escalation of the addiction. I also believe teenage AGP or AAP can be induced by social surroundings and culture rather than porn. I am critical of transmedicalism as 'pure cope' rooted in conformity, and I hold the modern LGBT community and modern LGBT activism in low regard — I have been banned from LGBT spaces for saying that porn is bad and that there are good things to be found in Christians and Christianity. I believe testosterone is a Schedule-III controlled steroid with low physical and high psychological dependence, and I have suggested 12-step addiction support groups to others coming off it, warning them to be careful about sponsors who might call them 'trans in denial.'
I don't think people should detransition because of politics or transphobia — repression with transphobia isn't healthy and could lead to retransitioning. I also have disdain for the trans flag now that I know what it represents, and I relate that reaction to trauma rather than transphobia. I am wary of the sexualized online trans community, noting that it scarily contains a lot of minors, and I'm glad I wasn't active online during my age-regression phase, since adults have made a fetish out of Peter Pan syndrome and age regression. I don't like labels like 'cisgender,' because if I did I would be considered non-binary and I want nothing to do with that.