Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and identified as trans from age 13 to 20, living and presenting as a man (FTM) during those years. I detransitioned three years before May 2022, so around 2019, after having been on testosterone but before getting the top surgery I had wanted for years. I describe myself as a detrans female.
My dysphoria around my chest began at puberty and by 2022 I had wanted my breasts removed for about ten years. Even after detransitioning, I still wished I could have a flat chest. I wrote that I no longer felt transition was a viable option for me 'health-wise or in terms of achieving satisfactory results,' but the desire itself did not go away. I am strongly opposed to cosmetic surgery because I believe it is 'psychologically and physically damaging,' and I did not want to put my body through surgical pain. At the same time, having breasts was really distressing to me and I often felt suicidal because I did not see a way out of feeling that way or how I could cope living with those body parts for the rest of my life. I envied people who underwent top surgery and got good results.
I still wanted to be male but no longer saw it as possible. Ideally I wanted a masculine chest; the next best thing, in terms of how I looked, would have been top surgery without socially transitioning to male. I said I was not comfortable being a woman but did not feel I had any other option. I hated the bodily feeling of having breasts, describing it as 'very disgusting to me,' and suggested it might be an ASD sensory thing. I noted I had never been sexualised because of them, so I did not think that was the cause, though I had had no sexual experience and wondered whether it might become an issue in a sexual situation. I envied the freedom of men who do not have breasts and, more generally, wished to look like a man, with this being one of the key differences that distressed me.
I also reflected that I had seen trans women express similar disgust over their flat chests and longing for breasts, which led me to think this must be a general disliking of the self that has become attached to an individual's biological sex rather than something rooted in logic or reason. I acknowledged that being aware of this did not do much to remove the dislike or the desire for cosmetic surgery. I was scared that surgery might leave me feeling even worse than I already did, and I said I really did not trust other people with my body. When someone suggested viewing my breasts positively, I said that made me feel worse because it felt like my body was not for me but for someone else, and it emphasised their specifically female function. I agreed that surgery was not the right option for me, which was why I felt so torn — I still desired it but thought it was realistically terrifying and traumatising.
On the reasons behind my transition, I described being 13 and scared of being a girl who liked girls, and feeling thoroughly unattractive to the boy I liked. I then discovered fanfiction and became, in my words, 'completely autistically obsessed with a gay ship,' spending all my time reading, drawing, and daydreaming about the characters. The fantasy of being a gay guy took over because I felt that as a boy I could be more attractive to the bisexual boy I liked, whereas as a girl I felt inferior. By 16 I had totally repressed my attraction to women because I was so obsessed with being a gay boy. I now accept that I am a bi woman and that the fanfictions are just female fantasies with nothing to do with real-life gay male sexuality. I still read them and sometimes they still make me unhappy, but I have grown up and know I cannot transition myself into a handsome 'gay guy.' I am still working on accepting the idea of being attractive to men as a woman — I am scared of real-life male sexuality and generally do not know how to act around guys — though I have fully embraced liking women.
I also identified broader cultural and social factors. I said it is 'partly a cultural obsession with gender that makes it fashionable to be trans in certain contexts and circles (TikTok, insta, high school GSAs).' My college is, in my words, 'very very gender-y,' and during term time I literally felt like I wanted to re-transition to fit in with the gnc/trans people I felt an affinity towards. I was careful to say no one was directly pressuring me — it was a longing to feel accepted and like I fit in, and trans happened to be the Thing in that social context that would foster that feeling. I noted this was subconscious and only realised by examining it. I combined this social context with obsessive thinking, body image issues, sexuality confusion, and autism as factors that can make the longing to be gnc or transition very strong. I compared transition's social contagion potential among teens to eating disorders and self-harm. I also observed that pronouns and gender labels can be a new way of expressing discomfort with gender roles, noting female friends who are feminine but go by she/they or they/them on Instagram.
In August 2022, about three years after detransitioning, I posted about trying to grow into myself as a feminine woman. I said I was feeling a little lost and was trying to see how I felt presenting more traditionally feminine, hoping maybe it would help ease my dysphoria. I had been very gender-nonconforming for most of the few years since detransitioning and had not changed my presentation much. When I thought of myself as feminine, the only reference point was how I wanted to dress when I was 12, so I felt clueless picking out a wardrobe and worried I looked weird because I did not know what I was doing. I had never worn makeup and only shaved my legs a few times, and I did not really want to start either, but worried it would make me seem strange, deficient, or ugly when all I wanted was to fit in. I was also concerned no man would be interested in me if I did not wear makeup or shave my hairy legs from testosterone. I framed this as an experiment to see if being feminine helped reduce my obsession with wanting to be a man, not as forcing myself into anything.
When advising someone else considering detransition, I drew on my own experience. I said I was deeply unhappy living as trans because I realised I would never really see myself as a man no matter how much I medically transitioned, and that the feeling of 'living a lie' was very strong — presenting as male in real life and then coming home unable to ignore the material reality of my female body. The longer that went on, the harder it was to ignore, and soon none of the trans thing made sense to me and I could not keep pretending I was 'really a man.' I also could not live as a proudly transgender person because I wanted to be biologically male, a cis man; being a trans man was not enough because it would always mean being biologically female. I said I still struggle with dysphoria sometimes, but it is definitely better now that I am no longer trying to convince myself and others that I am something I am not, and I found freedom in not having to constantly monitor how male I looked. I advised that one's mental health and sense of self must be better with a sense of wholeness between body and mind, which I did not see as possible while transitioned. My ultimate reason for detransitioning while having doubts was that it was 'better to stop the train Now and then get back on it later if i change my mind, rather than keep going and then regret in the future.' I also said I would always advise that not being on cross-sex hormones or undergoing surgeries is better because it is physically healthier; I did not feel safe being on T without knowing how it would affect my health 50 years down the line.