Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I am biologically female, and I identified as a trans man from 2010 to 2013, living as a trans man for about three years from ages 15 to 18. I socially transitioned but never went on testosterone or had any medical transition. I desisted around 2013, before this subreddit even existed, and I am now a desister who identifies as a lesbian.
As a pre-teen and especially as a teen, I had what I considered all the usual symptoms of gender dysphoria. I showered in the dark because I hated seeing my body, I hated being female, I really wanted to be a guy, and I would break down and cry because my periods reminded me of being female. Because of that, I went on a birth control that specifically stopped my periods, which helped, and my mom was willing to let me do that instead of hormone therapy. I'm grateful for that, because I'm sure I would have come to regret the results of testosterone.
When I was 15, in 2010, I saw a doctor at a clinic (I've mentioned Planned Parenthood) that spent maybe 45 minutes to an hour talking to me before they were asking my mom why she wouldn't allow me to start testosterone. My mom thought they were crazy, got angry at the clinic, and never took me back, even though at the time I was pissed about it. I've said repeatedly that I'm genuinely so grateful for that, because I know the HRT changes would bother me now if I had gone through with it. We might have a shit relationship, but I'm grateful for that one thing.
When I was in therapy as a teen, it was very unhelpful. My suicidal ideation and depression were either brushed off or said to be a product of my environment, specifically not being supported as transgender by my parents. At the time I was also dealing with an eating disorder and self-harm. I sometimes still think about self-harm, though it's not as prevalent, but the depression is still there. My mom swore up and down when I was around 17-18 that I had bipolar disorder because I acted like my dad, who apparently is bipolar and takes medication. Apparently he tried to kill himself once, but I don't know how true that is because whenever I've mentioned my own depression to him, he just shrugs it off and says nothing.
I've been afraid to go to therapy because I think there's probably something wrong with my brain that I don't want to acknowledge or medicate. I kept finding explanations for my depression: first that my home life was crap, then that I was trans, then that college sucked. Now I have an awesome, stable, full-time job and can afford things, and my mental health issues haven't gone away. Sometimes I feel okay, but then my mood will swing harshly downward out of nowhere.
Coming out as a lesbian instead of continuing to identify as a transgender guy was embarrassing. I had to do quite a bit of explaining to people who were confused. I had been SO sure, and it was humiliating. Returning to my birth name was extremely awkward at first; my mom suggested using my middle name if my first name was too uncomfortable, but I've never connected with my middle name, so I just used my first name despite the discomfort. After a few months I got used to it again.
When I look back, it feels like I was an entirely different person. Sometimes I forget it even happened until I see old pictures. Luckily I never went on T, so there are no physical effects of this phase.
Being seen as female still bothers me in some ways. I like feminine clothing and makeup, but having men look at me in public makes me want to shave my hair off again and dress more masculine so they won't. I've had disturbing experiences: my uncle commenting on my "cute little ass" at Christmas Eve, men staring at me in public, a man on the train masturbating while staring at me, and a guy pulling his car up to say "hey baby" while I was walking alone from my office. I'm 5'2" and extremely petite, which makes me feel weak, and I can't overpower a man twice my size. I hate that I don't feel safe in public. I also hate that when I tell guys I'm a lesbian and not interested, they take it as a challenge. I felt way more protected as a guy, or even just binding so people wouldn't look at my chest. Sometimes I think I'm over these feelings, then something happens and it comes rushing back.
I've also noticed that after living as a guy and binding for multiple years, the idea of binding again is uncomfortable for me, so when I cosplay male characters I genderbend them to female. I'm heavily involved in anime and cosplay fandom, and I've noticed an uptick in trans and nonbinary people in that community, particularly among young female crossplayers who later come out as trans, many of whom are really into m/m or yaoi content. Nearly all of my friends from high school and many from college now identify as trans men or non-binary, including ones who made fun of me for thinking I was trans at the time, which I find weird since I was the only one who identified as trans back then.
I don't consider myself Gender Critical, though I fell down that rabbit hole at one point, and I do think being transgender is valid. But I'm skeptical of the "male brain in a female body" talking points, since almost nobody saying them has had brain scans. I also think gender dysphoria is a mental illness, or possibly a symptom rather than its own disorder, and my opinion on that hasn't changed since I thought I was trans, when it was still called gender identity disorder in the DSM. I don't think that's a negative or stigmatizing statement.
I find the idea that only trans people think about their gender identity to be counterproductive and actively harmful. I thought a LOT about my gender identity for years and socially transitioned, wanting to medically transition, and then realized I am not trans. The notion that if you question yourself you MUST be trans is harmful.
Coming back out and explaining my detransition to people was embarrassing, and I've had online experiences where my detrans experience gets used or devalued, ranging from trans people feeling I'm invalidating their identity, to radical feminists and social conservatives using my experience as proof that trans people don't exist, to being told I "didn't really have gender dysphoria." That last one annoys me most, because kids can have gender dysphoria and grow up to realize they're gay without it being said they didn't really have it.