Alle verhalen

Een jaar oestrogeen, geen sperma ingevroren

Man · GedetransitioneerdTransitie 18 → Detransitie 20755
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man (MtFtM) die als trans identificeerde, als vrouw leefde en in totaal ongeveer anderhalf jaar oestrogeen gebruikte voordat ik detransitioneerde. Ik noem mezelf nu een homoseksuele man, ga met mijn androgyne tweede naam door het leven, en ik heb nog wat genderdysforie en autogynefilie, maar ben grotendeels in vrede. Mijn transitie werd gedreven door geïnternaliseerde homofobie, autogynefilie en het geloof dat de wens een vrouw te zijn me er een maakte; ik had daarvoor geen echte dysforie. Mijn detransitie kwam door rationalistische lectuur, Jesse Singals artikel in The Atlantic en het verhaal van mijn transvriend dat dysforie niet verdwijnt met transitie. Ik ben op en af met hormonen geweest (ongeveer 1,5 jaar aan, 4 maanden uit, 3 maanden aan, 4 maanden uit) en ben nog onzeker over mijn lange-termijnpad, en ik heb soms opnieuw getransitioneerd uit angst voor verdere masculinisering. Ik heb geen sperma ingevroren en mijn vruchtbaarheid was bij de laatste controle niet teruggekeerd, wat me verdrietig maakt. Ik heb spijt dat ik geen sperma heb laten invriezen en dat ik mezelf niet eerder als homo accepteerde, maar ik heb over het geheel genomen geen spijt van de transitie. Ik ben kritisch over zowel kritiekloze trans-bevestiging als de gender-kritische vijandigheid tegenover trans mensen in detrans-ruimtes, en ik pleit ervoor dat de stemmen van detransitioners centraal staan in deze gemeenschap.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male and I've experienced homosexual attraction for about as long as heterosexual attraction, though my attraction to men has always been more intense. Many of my childhood crushes were on guys, and I always wanted them to top me and wanted to submit to them. But because I was also physically attracted to women, I felt I was supposed to be straight, have a family, and conform to gender norms. My attempts at dating girls in middle school and high school were disastrous — I was awkward and intensely uncomfortable initiating romantic contact. Around that time, roughly age 12, I developed autogynephilia: I became sexually attracted to the idea of becoming a woman and having sex with men, which gave me an outlet to fantasize about submitting to men without feeling like a deviant. As a man I felt unlovable; as a woman those pressures seemed not to exist. In college I dated a girl for about three months — she was three inches taller than me and so masculine she was often mistaken for a man. I didn't enjoy sex with her because I don't actually find vaginas attractive; I couldn't finish without imagining myself as female, being fucked by a man. She broke up with me after discovering she was a lesbian. That experience made me realize I was actually a gay bottom, but instead of accepting that, I concluded my autogynephilia meant I was transgender. I found trans subreddits, learned about "the button," and the meme that wanting to be a girl made you a girl. I reasoned that if I didn't transition I'd just get more masculine, and I really didn't want to go bald or get body hair — I wanted to be soft and delicate. I had no dysphoria at all and wasn't even sure I'd press the button, but my underdeveloped frontal lobe made a snap decision. I found a rubber-stamp therapist, got my letter, and started HRT about a month later, in September 2017, right before my 19th birthday and at the start of my sophomore year of college. In a comment I later wrote that I "transitioned at 18," and elsewhere that I got on hormones at 19 — the hormone start date is the firmer fact. In my haste I failed to bank sperm. In December 2017 I came off hormones for about a month to try to bank sperm, but my dysphoria was too bad and I gave up; when I tried again three months in, my sperm count was zero. HRT initially felt bad — foggy, low energy and libido, and crucially no real euphoria, unlike how trans people describe it. My breasts began developing and I did not like them at all: they were itchy, looked weird, and meant I couldn't go shirtless. I rationalized this as the discomfort cis girls feel. I built a fortress of reasons why transition was right. I was on HRT for a year and eight months in total (elsewhere I say a year and a half, or "a bit under 2 years"), legally changed my name to an obviously feminine one, and lived full-time as a woman for about six months. Presenting as female made me incredibly uncomfortable — I constantly worried people read me as male, felt fake faking a feminine voice, mannerisms and clothes, hated tucking, and hated suppressing masculine sounds during sex or intense video games. I passed fairly well, getting gendered female about 90–95% of the time even without makeup and dressing somewhat androgynously, but it was exhausting vigilance over my voice, tuck and mannerisms, and I was perpetually afraid of entering women's restrooms. I missed my male clothes, easygoing nature and humor. Around five months into transition I discovered the Internet rationality movement through a Slate Star Codex article, then LessWrong, the Sequences, Sam Harris, Kahneman. Eliezer Yudkowsky's "Crisis of Faith" post lay in wait until my fortress was ready to be dismantled. The turning point came from Jesse Singal's Atlantic article about child transition, quoting a desisting girl: "it didn't make me feel any better. I was still miserable, and I still hated myself." I reeled: I had never thought transition was supposed to make me happier; I thought it was something I had to do because Transgender People Must Transition. I wasn't happier transitioned — as a guy I would have said I was a happy person; as a girl, not a chance. I thought "I should detransition" and my boyfriend talked me out of it, but the urge came back. Dressing in male clothes and using my male voice with my boyfriend, I felt liberated and real — exactly how actual trans people describe starting transition, and not at all how I felt starting it. I also later realized a strange mushroom-like experience was a big part of why I fell into transition: it was actually 4-AcO-DMT, and lying in bed I had a vivid mental image of a beautiful woman who told me I'd never be happy unless I became a woman, citing that I couldn't orgasm with my girlfriend without imagining myself female. I was shaken and it catalyzed my realization I couldn't keep living as a straight man. I wish I'd taken transition's limits more seriously and accepted myself as a gay man instead. In April 2019 I stopped hormones to live as male for a summer internship in New York — an extremely high-stress finance internship a thousand miles from family and boyfriend — without telling anyone at college. I was off until August 2019, when I got back on because I got too scared to detransition for school and thought it was less destructive long-term to be on hormones while figuring things out. I went back off around November 2019, and came out to everyone at the start of the school year, mid-January 2020. TL;DR: roughly a year and a half on hormones, four months off, three months on, four months off. I wrote my "Why I'm detransitioning" post in April 2019 at age 20, two weeks onto testosterone I made myself. I was out as detrans to family, best friend and boyfriend. I identified as a gay man and described myself as biromantic homosexual — sexually attracted to men, somewhat romantically to women. My boyfriend is trans: he's 5'9