Alle verhalen

De honeymoon was voorbij — de stem en de baard bleven

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd71
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die als man leefde en op mijn 30e met testosteron begon. Ik had een ‘honeymoonperiode’ voordat ik besloot te detransitioneren. Ik heb een top surgery gehad, waar ik geen spijt van heb, maar ik leef nu met een lage stem en een baard die ik als blijvend accepteer. Mijn mentale gezondheid verslechterde na de detransitie door isolatie en gebrek aan steun, al heb ik contact gelegd met andere detransitioners, onder meer in het noordwesten van de VS (Pacific Northwest). Ik geloof dat transitie onderliggende problemen zoals trauma, dissociatie of autisme-gerelateerde moeilijkheden niet oplost, en ik presenteer me nu gewoon als vrouw, zonder me verplicht te voelen mijn detransitie aan anderen uit te leggen.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female, and I identified as trans and lived as a man for years. I don't remember exactly when my dysphoria started, but I do know I was 30 when I began testosterone. Before that, I had suffered from anorexia nervosa for years — long before I ever transitioned — and I've since watched with frustration as some psychologists and trans activists claim that an eating disorder like mine can be caused by gender dysphoria. I was fairly masculine growing up and, looking back, I should probably have just stayed gender-nonconforming rather than transitioning. When I started T, I experienced the "honeymoon period" that so many detransitioners describe — that initial rush of feeling like things were finally getting better. I also recognize the pattern of thinking "if I just change one more thing I'll be happy," which I now see as one of the biggest issues tied to detransition. I had top surgery and I do not regret it. But over time I came to accept something painful: you can never actually be the opposite sex, and you will always be "trans" in some sense. That realization was central to my decision to detransition. After I stopped identifying as FTM, my mental health got worse for a while. I isolated myself, lost motivation, and my anxiety intensified. I relate strongly to other detransitioners who describe that same spiral. I think part of it is that detransitioners get even more hostility from society than trans people do — there's no affirmation, no support, no legitimization, and if you already have a shaky sense of identity, that feeling of abandonment is crushing. I also came to believe that transition doesn't actually solve the underlying problems: it won't make dysphoria disappear completely, it won't fix dissociation, it won't erase a history of bullying or abuse, and it won't remove the pressure to conform to gender roles. I've seen too many trans people who never dealt with their real issues and used transition as an escape from themselves, and who are miserable today. Coming out to my family as a detransitioner was one of the hardest parts. I feel a lot of shame and embarrassment about it — in some ways it was harder than coming out as trans. My approach was to explain that I had transitioned because I was trying to find "treatment" for myself, that it didn't work completely, and that I was now moving on to another kind of treatment. I've also thought a lot about community. For me, a bigger issue than the medical stuff has been community: if I'd had a group of lesbians I felt accepted by and close to, I would have been reluctant to leave that world. Instead, the feeling of "oh well, not losing something I never had" was very real. I'm in the Pacific Northwest and I've reached out to other detransitioners to connect. A lot of our stories overlap — the masculinity, the honeymoon period on T, the lack of regret about top surgery. Physically, I'm dealing with changes I'll have to live with: I have a "man's voice" and a beard, and I've accepted that those are permanent. In some ways that experience feels similar to what trans women go through, but there's a key difference in how I'm approaching it. I'm not actively trying to feminize myself the way a trans woman might; instead of rejecting the reality of my body, I'm trying to re-embrace it. On the question of how I present myself to the world now, I don't think I need to mention detransition at all — it's nobody's business. If people ask, I just say "nope, I'm a woman" and they can learn to deal with it. That's what butch women have had to do for ages. I've also thought a lot about the overlap between body dysmorphia, autism, and gender dysphoria. I've met many trans-identified autistic people whose transness, in my view, is absolutely a symptom of the autism — the difficulty following social roles, the hypersensitivity to body sensations, the obsessive behavior, the tendency to take things too seriously. Even when such people feel better bucking social expectations around dress and mannerisms, I've never seen an autistic trans person who seemed to benefit from medical transition. I also think BDD is distinct from gender dysphoria: BDD involves obsessive behaviors like "checking" and intense focus on specific body parts, and a sense that something is wrong with the body that needs correction, rather than simply feeling in the wrong body. There are zero studies directly comparing gender dysphoria to BDD, so it's hard to say definitively how similar they are. Overall, I've worked toward accepting myself as I am. Detransition for me has meant reconciling with my body, my voice, and my history, and finding a way forward without shame.