Alle verhalen

Een tomboy in een steunend huis, zonder wens een jongen te zijn

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd632
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde of gendercritische butch lesbische vrouw die als kind een tomboy was zonder vroege wens een jongen te worden, opgegroeid in een steunend gezin. Ik heb sterk kritische opvattingen over transitie, vooral voor gendernonconformistische vrouwen en lesbiennes, die ik zie als geworteld in regressieve genderstereotypen en, voor translesbiennes, in autogynefilie. Ik heb de detransities van anderen gesteund en ben kritisch op transmensen in lesbische en homoseksuele ruimtes. Ik heb in dit transcript niet beschreven dat ik zelf hormonen of operaties heb ondergaan.

Volledig verhaal

I was a tomboy growing up — my girl friends in elementary school would ask why I never wore a dress and always wore basketball shorts, and I never had a real answer because I didn't see a problem with it. It was just me. There was no thought in my mind about "becoming a boy"; that was a thought that never occurred to me. I was lucky to grow up in a very supportive family who never said anything about it and just let me be. I am a lesbian, and I speak mostly from that vantage point — I've said I can really only speak on the FTM heterosexual females and tomboys since I'm a lesbian. I identify as a butch woman. I've described myself as a butch woman who finds the thought of having facial hair, a deeper voice, or dating a woman with those traits to be deeply wrong for me. I've also, at one point, told someone "You sound like a teenage boy to me," which suggests I have some familiarity with masculine presentation or being read that way, though I have not described any medical transition of my own in this transcript. My views on transition, particularly for gender-nonconforming women, are strongly critical. I believe there is "absolutely nothing wrong with gatekeeping lesbianism" and that "we are homosexual." I've argued that the trans community's foundation is based on regressive gender stereotypes — that masculine = male and feminine = female — and that gender nonconforming girls are the biggest victims of this ideology. I've said "the transing of tomboys (majority who turn out to be L&B) became inevitable when being a girl or a boy was made based on a 'feeling'." I've also expressed concern that some lesbians grow up in religious or homophobic households where being gay is treated as a sin, so being a "man" attracted to women feels better to them. I've been critical of trans lesbians specifically, stating flatly "Trans lesbians do not exist. Lesbians are homosexual females," and characterizing trans women who identify as lesbians as autogynephiles who encroach on women's spaces. I've referenced Ray Blanchard's transsexualism typology and the concept of autogynephilia in discussions with others. I've also expressed concern about gay trans men hitting on gay male friends on Grindr or in gay bars, describing it as "some fetish for them." I've discussed the history of butch lesbians, noting that butches in the 70s/80s were given testosterone by men outside lesbian bars in San Francisco to masculinize them — something I saw in a documentary — and I called this "butch erasure." I've said I can usually tell immediately (99% of the time) when someone is trans. I've expressed sadness about certain situations involving gender-nonconforming women and transition, and I've been supportive of people detransitioning, telling one person "Good on you for recognizing and leaving. Best of luck with your detransition" and another that "It's never too late" and "Your features will soften up over time." I've also told someone to "stop watching porn it's rotting your brain." On sexuality more broadly, I've acknowledged that some women don't realize they're lesbian until after having a husband and children, and that circumstances vary, while also noting that if someone considered themselves lesbian but slept with men they might be bisexual. I've advised someone that they can present however they'd like regardless of sex and shouldn't care too much about what people think. I have not described undergoing hormones, surgeries, or a formal detransition process myself in this transcript, though I have been active in detransition-supportive conversations and hold views common in gender-critical lesbian communities.