Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up in what I now describe as a pretty rough childhood — my parents were detached and neglectful, and I was the black sheep of the family. I had a lot of self-hatred from a very early age. I developed physically early: I started developing at 8 years old and got my first period at 10. From about 4th through 5th grade (roughly ages 9–11) I wore hoodies at school every day to hide my chest — I'd wear them at home and in public too, and my parents hated it and would sometimes force me to take it off. I remember at recess a friend convinced me to take mine off because it was hot, and our other friends stood back and said "Woah, she got big titties" and another said "That's why she wears hoodies." That hurt me. I felt jealous of boys for being able to not have that attention, and also jealous of my girl peers for not going through puberty as early as I did. In 7th grade two guy friends poked fun at how small my chest was, which was strange because for years I'd been insecure about it being noticeable. I was always tomboyish — equally into "girl" and "boy" things, with a good mix of male and female friends — but I never felt so uncomfortable with my gender that I wanted to be male. I always liked being a girl as a child and a teen.
Sexuality was a major thread. I realized I was same-sex attracted at 14 but automatically refused to question whether I was a lesbian because I felt the *need* to be attracted to men. I identified as bisexual all throughout high school (ages roughly 14–18), only my closest friends knew, and I deeply rejected the thought of being an actual lesbian. I clung to the bi label because of internalized homophobia — I didn't want to face the possibility and also didn't think it was possible. A month or so before college, right before turning 18, it dawned on me that the chances of finding men attractive romantically or sexually were slim to none. I came out as gay when I entered college at 18 — though I avoided saying "lesbian" and would say "gay" instead, because the word had negative connotations for me. I spent a year "out" as a lesbian at 18.
I wasn't prepared for the passive lesbophobia I encountered at college — micro-aggressions and benign jokes about my sexuality I hadn't experienced in high school since I wasn't out then. Straight friends would bring up my sexuality more than I would, which made me feel constantly reminded I was different. I struggled to relate to other lesbians: I wasn't starkly femme nor butch, I didn't care for sports or many common lesbian interests, and the relationship-focused "u-haul" culture never resonated with me. I also had social anxiety and depression during college.
At 19, partly out of desperation and internalized homophobia, I "re-came-out" as queer, and then identified as nonbinary on top of that, basically up until 22–23. I was heavily ingrained in SJW tumblr ideology — I joined tumblr around 16 in 2010, knew about trans guys and "genderqueer" people from LGBT vloggers around 2011, and trans stuff exploded on tumblr around 2012. I took gender and queer studies courses in college (roughly 2012–2016) and was already indoctrinated from tumblr and trans/queer YouTubers. I believed queer theory's claims that gender was a social construct, that sexuality was a spectrum, that everyone was inherently bisexual, and that I could learn to be attracted to men if I unlearned certain things. I experimented with men more than with women to solidify my "queer" identity — a waste of time, as I eventually had to accept I wasn't attracted to men.
Identifying as nonbinary gave me a socially acceptable reason to explore androgyny. I transferred schools while deep in depression and social anxiety, and I began going by a gender-neutral, masc-leaning name (I went by Drew for two years in college) — I chose it partly because professors and others constantly mispronounced my birth name and I felt awkward correcting them repeatedly, and partly because I felt disconnected from my name. I cut my hair and began dressing more androgynously and felt more like myself — I guess that was the "gender euphoria" some people describe. I never formally came out as nb to most people; my gender identity was mostly part of my online life. I questioned whether I wanted to take testosterone and whether I was "transmasc," but I always knew deep down I had no desire to look male or be seen as one — I never envied male bodies besides not having periods, never wanted a penis. I admired trans guys for being open, confident, and able to dress masculinely.
What kept me from medically transitioning was twofold: I genuinely liked my body despite insecurities and had no body dysphoria, and my sexuality grounded me. I knew that to be satisfied with a woman romantically or sexually I had to be seen and interacted with AS a woman — being perceived as male or nonbinary by women I wanted to be with felt foreign. I also had social dysphoria: I disliked being read as female by men because of the sexual and gendered expectations placed on me, and I disliked receiving male attention because I'm very much a lesbian. In college I received the most male attention and sexualization and didn't know how to deal with it; identifying as nonbinary was partly a way to reject their attention, to view myself as outside of "woman" so they wouldn't see me as available. I also felt like I couldn't be a tomboyish lesbian without being substantially masc — I didn't feel feminine enough to be femme or masculine enough to be butch.
Desisting was a slow process. Around 22 I began noticing hostility in trans/nb online spaces about being misgendered that didn't make sense to me — if you're female, haven't been on T long, and wear a dress, of course a stranger will see you as female. I challenged a classmate in a queer theory course on trans feminism who wanted to medically transition to "look nonbinary," saying people would just see a masculine woman or feminine man. I realized there is no nonbinary transition and that no one can pass as nonbinary. After graduating college I stopped going by the gender-neutral name, always went by female pronouns, and slowly dropped the identity. I also began studying ancient spirituality, Taoism, and watching Jordan B Peterson, which helped put things in perspective — identifying out of something doesn't make me something I'm not. I "peaked" gradually over the years after desisting around 2016, questioning the ideology after I stopped being invested in it.
I never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries, no puberty blockers — so I technically desisted rather than detransitioned. I reidentified as a lesbian and stopped calling myself queer, though it took until about 22–23 to fully accept the word. I came to terms with my inherent lesbian nature and realized acceptance of myself as a woman and lesbian was incompatible with queer theory, so I chose the path of least resistance.
Mental health: I had a pretty bad depression during college, off-the-charts anxiety, and social anxiety — I was practically a recluse, only hanging out with friends two or three times a year for years. I was recovering a lot of childhood trauma during the same period I identified as nb. I've described identifying as nb as an escape during bad depression and unresolved trauma, and I lost interest in the identity as my mental health improved and I had to focus on adult responsibilities like finding a job and paying bills. I've dealt with social anxiety triggers that are social in nature and only recently (a few months before that comment) sought professional help for it, improving but not fully there.
Adversity: childhood neglect, being the family black sheep, early puberty and body shaming about my chest, internalized lesbophobia, a depressive and socially anxious college period. I also described a close encounter at a party at 18 where a girl a few years older, while I was very intoxicated and couldn't speak, insisted we go into a bedroom and I had to shake my head no until a friend intervened — I mentally blocked that out for months and only around 19 began to see myself as more genderqueer/nonbinary, though I never transitioned. I also mentioned an ex (my first girlfriend) who came out as ftm after we broke up, was manipulative about my sexuality, and died by suicide in October (about a year before that comment in late 2020), just months after getting top surgery; he had experienced neglect and sexual abuse as a child.
Sexuality after desisting: I'm a lesbian, exclusively attracted to women, and I feel most female when intimate with other women. I've said being with women AS a woman mattered more to me than how men saw me. I've noted I can relate to and am attracted to trans-identified females while recognizing it wouldn't benefit me to identify as trans.
Regret: I don't express medical regret since I never medically transitioned. I do express that queer theory and gender ideology "messed up" my sense of self — that believing gender was meaningless and sexuality a spectrum ruined my sense of self, that I hated being exclusively attracted to females and tried to acquire attraction to men out of principle, and that I felt like I wasn't really a woman. I've said I'm grateful I never let my mental health convince me transitioning would work for me, and that if I'd been younger or more impressionable I would have been caught up even deeper. I've expressed some lingering sadness or FOMO when seeing transmasc people and wondering "how would I look?" but recognize it as fleeting and not something I truly want. I also sometimes miss the radiance and positivity of the queer/nb community.
Current status and attitudes: I'm a desisted/detransitioned woman — specifically a black, gender non-conforming, androgynous lesbian in my mid-twenties (I was 25 in 2019 and 26 in 2020, so born around 1993–1994). I don't identify as gender critical or a radical feminist, though I agree with some radfem points and disagree with others; I'm critical of many aspects of the trans movement and queer theory. I believe some people genuinely benefit from medical transition and support adults' right to transition if it improves their wellbeing, but I'm strongly against minors medically transitioning, believe in robust gatekeeping (therapy and full-time social transition for 18–23 year olds, informed consent at 25+), and think the "you don't need dysphoria to be trans" and "gender euphoria" rhetoric is harmful. I've been an active voice in detrans/desisted communities, sharing resources (gnc-centric, Pique Resilience Project, Benjamin Boyce, Sasha Ayad), writing posts about topics like nonbinary lesbians, gatekeeping, and gender identity as a way to avoid being seen as a d*ke, and advocating for nuanced discussion rather than black-and-white thinking on either side. I don't believe in an intrinsic, immutable gender identity. I currently don't identify with any gender label — I just am female and a lesbian.