Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female. I first transitioned at 14 — I was a depressed, troubled, immature child, and I have a lot of guilt that doctors coerced my parents into agreeing to medical steps under the threat of my imminent suicide if they didn't. I socially and medically transitioned, lived for years passing as male, and took testosterone for a long time; I've now been off T for close to a decade. I had a full beard at one point — my neighbors who've known me a couple of years met me while I still had a beard. I also had a mastectomy (top surgery) and I used Depo-Provera shots (progesterone-only) at some point; when I once missed a Depo shot due to an office error I bled for a month straight until the shot turned it off like a faucet.
What led me toward transition, and what I now understand about it: I've come to believe my 'dysphoria' was really dissatisfaction with life in general, depression, and existential-crisis type stuff. I still feel existential dread but I no longer think it's related to gender — I misinterpreted it when I was younger. I also think I was raised with female socialization (non-confrontational, gentle, non-violent), and when I passed well as a male I worried I'd have to react to threats or cockiness the way a socialized male would — puffing my chest, acting like I could kick someone's ass — and that strength competition I never wanted any part of. I think that mismatch made me stand out even while passing. I also felt too different and couldn't relate to women until I spent years trying to relate to men as a 'man,' which made it clearer than ever that I am a woman.
Moving toward detransition felt like waking up — a relatable, sudden clarity for me. I've swung back into 'neutral' rather than overcorrecting: just accepting my body as it is naturally and doesn't need adjusting. I don't think detransition could be a phase for me because it's just about existing as I am.
Medical aftermath and ongoing needs: I have a flat chest, a deeper voice, and I have to shave. I'd like reconstruction but probably won't get it — in the US insurance mandates coverage for breast reconstruction after mastectomy for breast cancer, not for my situation, and it would be very hard to get covered. I don't foresee a future with money for surgeries; implants need replacing every 10 years, any surgery takes a toll, and I'd rather save surgery for emergencies. I know a woman in constant pain years after cancer reconstruction, and I just want to treat my body with respect from now on. What insurance did cover were prosthetic breast forms and bras — I went to a prosthetic medical place and got measured by a professional; they look and feel realistic, though of course not the same. I also dealt with facial hair removal: waxing requires growing hair out to an uncomfortable length, and trying it was emotionally upsetting and worsened my depression because I had to walk around with a visible beard in public. At a laser consultation I was told coming in 30–60 minutes twice a week would take two years just to 'get it under control' — I cried and gave up. Voice-wise, I note that T produces what's often called a 'froggy' voice in natal females, an anatomical outcome rather than a lack of effort, and I worry people are given false hope they'll be the lucky exception. I've also advised that testosterone combined with pre-existing heart problems would likely be a higher risk, not a lesser one.
Mental health: I've struggled with depression ('Depression is a Biotch') and difficulty wanting to be present and awake. I used to suffer PTSD nightmares and recommend prazosin (a blood-pressure medication at low dose) to others, saying it pretty reliably blocks them — 'I used to be like you with the nightmares.' I believe our brains aren't built to stare at screens and socialize primarily online, and that isolation, inactivity, and indoor living drive rising mental illness; exercise releases dopamine and serotonin.
Passing and being read as female again: it used to hurt to be called 'he,' but people now catch on — my neighbors naturally started calling me 'she' just from being around me. Just recently someone very naturally called me ma'am even though my hair is somewhat short, I was in sweats and a t-shirt with a flat chest, having rolled out of bed looking disheveled — still seen as female. I tell others it's possible to be perceived as female again if that's what you want; I once thought I was backed into a corner, but 'nature prevails,' even with a flat chest, deeper voice, and having to shave.
I don't use makeup or wear dresses and barely perform femininity at all, yet I've accepted I'm a female — you don't need to be hyperfeminine to be a woman, and I still wear the same type of clothing my male friend wears at least 80% of the time. I believe butch and GNC women are not trans, feminine men are not trans, and that conflating GNC people with trans is 'the exact kind of thinking that got many of us here in the detransition boat.' I've told others they can embrace their feminine side — softness, caregiving — without being literally a woman, and not to shut those parts down.
On community and relationships: I find it frustrating that we're made to feel we betrayed the trans community just by figuring out our own lives; if others take my personal life as an attack, that's on them. I've said you don't owe anyone anything and that friends who abandon you through life's twists and turns aren't real friends. I'm critical of people whose identity is based on which group is kind to them, of trolls who post to make us look, and of the double standard where detrans people are 'free game to rip apart' while questioning whether a trans person is really trans is forbidden. I believe detrans isn't 'supposed to be against all Trans people' — we're just people who decided to detransition, with different views. I've defended the community against people laughing at detrans suffering, including a woman crying over having cut her boobs off. I'm skeptical of claims that toddlers have a coherent gender identity, and I've pushed back on people coming to the sub to bait pushback and then complain about 'transphobia.' I also think it's important to imagine yourself as a man at every life stage — 20, 30, 40, 50, elderly, in a nursing home — before transitioning.