Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die rond 2019 in deze gemeenschap kwam en in 2020 anderen openlijk afraadde vroege medische transitie te doen, terwijl ik wie detransitioneert steunde. Ik geloof dat transgenderisme fundamenteel een copingmechanisme voor psychische ziekte is en dat dysforie psychologisch in plaats van medisch behandeld moet worden, al respecteer ik wie als laatste redmiddel transitioneerde. Ik deelde dat ik van ongeveer mijn 16e tot 18e mijn vrouwelijkheid, borst en heupen haatte en door vrouwen werd gepest, en dat ik mijn borst en heupen soms nog niet mooi vind. Ik raad jongeren die testosteron overwegen actief af het te nemen, waarschuwde dat niemand onder de 20 medisch zou moeten transitioneren, en feliciteerde anderen met hun detransitie terwijl ik hen aanmoedigde met artsen en therapeuten te praten. Ik heb in dit transcript geen eigen psychische crisis of suïcidale gedachten vastgelegd.
Volledig verhaal
I first came to this community in September 2019, when I defended it against someone who seemed to be trying to start an argument. I explained that detransitioning isn't for everyone — especially when it's forced or when someone is comfortable where they are — and that the sub had never implied everyone would be better off detransitioning. I described it as a support group for those who do detransition and a community to educate people around the subject.
By October 2019 I was still working out my own identity, reacting with confusion ('Cis.. woman???') to being described that way. In February 2020 I laid out my views in detail. I said that in my personal opinion, 'true transgenderism is a result of trying to cope with a mental illness,' and that I didn't think altering oneself to fit an image in one's head was the right approach — instead I believed in targeting the dysphoria at its heart, the way we would with other mental illnesses. I noted that political warfare over the topic meant no real medical research was being done on psychologically or pharmaceutically healing dysphoria. At the same time, I said trans people who pursue transition only as a last resort to alleviate their symptoms 'absolutely have my respect,' though I don't see them as unequivocally the sex they desire to be. I made clear I don't hold prejudice or negative feelings toward all trans people or those who don't detransition.
I also spoke directly to a young person considering testosterone, telling them they were still very young, that their body and hormones were all over the place, and that the dysphoria they felt likely reflected both that and the 'crippling insecurity that comes with growing up and going through puberty as a woman,' plus social expectations. I promised that testosterone would not make them happy and would only throw their mental health off further. I shared that when I was around 16 to 18 I felt the same way — I hated typical femininity, was bullied and brought down by all the women around me, and hated my chest and hips (I noted I still do sometimes), but that my bodily insecurities and masculine interests did not make me male. Given the person's suicidal thoughts and depression, I recommended seeing a therapist.
In February 2020 I also encouraged someone who had already made changes to their body: 'You are still beautiful. No amount of changing your body will ever lower your value,' and told them they had a good 5-7 years for their body to grow, change, and return to normal, because the human body is very resilient. I urged them to talk to their doctor and see a therapist, and said their story would be an inspiration to many. I took a firm line on age: 'there is never going to be a good enough reason to support the fact that anyone under 20 should be allowed to medically transition.' I also advised anyone even debating hormones to hold off, because it's a serious commitment with risks, and to not take them if they had any doubts at all.
In April 2020 I congratulated someone on deciding to detransition, calling it a great first step and hoping their journey with self-image would get smoother. I told them that just because they're male doesn't mean they can't partake in traditionally feminine things, and to dress how they want. Later that month I responded to someone whose year hadn't been great, hoping things would improve, and I advised someone coming off hormones that their body would re-regulate itself over time but that they should speak with their doctor, noting everyone handles medications — especially hormones — differently. I mentioned I'd heard of replacement therapy to counteract the effects of estrogen on males or testosterone on females but wasn't sure if it was legitimate, and wished them good luck with their detransition.
Throughout these comments I never explicitly described my own transition or detransition timeline in detail, though I referenced hating my chest and hips from ages 16-18 and being bullied by women, and I spoke with familiarity about the detransition process.