Alle verhalen

Een bovenoperatie zonder testosteron — en de dysforie bleef

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd258
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/twijfelende vrouw die een bovenoperatie onderging maar nooit testosteron nam, en ik ervaar nog lichamelijke dysforie terwijl ik probeer het masculien zijn als vrouw te omarmen. In oktober 2020 zat ik in een ernstige mentale crisis nadat een trainingsblessure me dwong te stoppen met sporten; ik schreef dat ik eerder bijna een zelfmoordpoging had gedaan en op geleende tijd leefde, al zei ik dat ik te laf was om door te zetten. Ik was in therapie en zocht antidepressiva, en ik had ongeveer een jaar meegelezen in detransruimtes. Mijn transitie werd gedreven door langdurige genderdysforie, masculiniteit in mijn kindertijd, fysiek pesten en een misogyne conservatieve opvoeding, met als belangrijk waarschuwingssignaal dat mijn innerlijke schaamte zich naar buiten tegen vrouwen keerde toen ik me losmaakte van ‘vrouw’ zijn. Ik heb sindsdien copingstrategieën ontwikkeld rond het verminderen van gegenderde content en het loskomen van gegenderde taal, wat mijn functioneren verbeterde, en ik blijf kritisch over zowel de ontkenning van de biologische werkelijkheid door de transgemeenschap als extreme anti-transitieretoriek.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and I have always been a masculine person — very masculine as a kid, and I always put myself in the closer-to-male-than-female box. I started binding at puberty, unsafely, all day every day, and despite that I still developed DD breasts, which is common in my family; my top surgeon later remarked that my chest had very little space between the two and that this was most likely from years upon years of binding plus them being on the bigger size. I have had top surgery, so they are gone now. I was bullied a lot in middle school and toward the end of elementary school, and it was physical. Most of the time, though, I was just that quiet kid who refused to interact with anyone aside from my core group of friends — either I was being ignored, or if I wasn't being ignored I was being put in the spotlight in a bad way, by teachers/adults or other kids. Neither of my parents will admit it, but they are both pretty misogynistic. When I was young, up until I was 15, women were really demonized in my mind and in the worldview I was taught because of the circles I ran in and what I was exposed to. I grew up in a conservative upbringing. That combination — being already gnc plus a very rigid set of gendered roles as a kid — really came together for the perfect emotional fuck storm for me. I experienced gender dysphoria and physical dysphoria that is not connected to social connotations. I also had a lot of shame and hatred directed inward. When I was transitioning and cut myself free from being 'female,' all that shame and hatred I had directed inward was suddenly pointed at other women in a very negative way, and that was a big indication to me I was heading the wrong direction. I still experience physical dysphoria, and I am still a masculine person regardless of whether I had or have negative experiences with my gender. I have had top surgery. I have not been on testosterone — as of October 2020 I wrote 'Im not on testosterone.' I am 5'1", shorter than most men and typically shorter than women as well, since most women in my area are around 5'4". My height has become a major insecurity: I see short guys at work but they are still taller than me, and I feel there is no escape because testosterone won't change my height. I feel I cannot compete with cis men — 'biology be damned' — and that even if I looked male no one would take me seriously. I described it as 'trading leprosy for being paralyzed.' In October 2020 I was in a very bad mental state. I injured myself working out and was forced to rest for about six weeks, losing strength, which triggered a lot of this. I wrote that I am 'on borrowed time' and that I had nearly attempted suicide in the past — I chickened out at the last minute and my parents had to go through a lot of infertility treatment to have me. I said I am not going to end up dead any time soon because I am too chicken, but maybe one day 20 years down the line I will be tired enough to fall into it 'with some dignity.' I was in therapy and planning to talk to my therapist about seeing a psychiatrist for antidepressants to help me through the really rough patches where normal coping fails. I had lurked in the detrans community for about a year as of October 2020. I described myself as 'questioning ftm/butch.' I was and am transmed, which was enough to drive me from main trans communities — basically being insta-banned — and I am not a fan of the denial of biological reality in trans communities. I wrote that it is ridiculous to say my tits (when I had them) were male tits or that I have a 'boy pussy' or that 'men can have babies too.' I was unsure of the direction I would take and was just trying to survive. By mid-October 2020 I wrote that I was trying to learn to love myself as I am and embrace being masculine as a female, making peace with being outside the norm. I also noted I had been absorbing unhelpful ideas on the internet and in my personal life. I later developed a detailed framework for coping that helped me: stop consuming content that discusses gender/gender roles/gendered ideology; stop viewing yourself solely through the lens of your sex; understand the variables of society and how you grew up; learn about the things that are great about your biological sex as a detached observer; consider whether those functions are things you value; and extract from your life, your parents, and society the messages that are not yours. I found not consuming gendered content helpful, though I still slip up and it messes me up for a while. Detaching myself from gendered language as far as thinking of myself helped — the words 'woman' and 'female' are still really negative in my mind, but I don't associate myself with those labels in an emotional sense so much anymore. I also use art, gaming, and working out as hobbies that shut off my brain. I said this is not a sure-fire cure and I still deal with issues around my gender, but it has helped me function better and have far more positive days than negative days. I posted a poll in the detrans community asking how many people were disgusted by their biology prior to transitioning and whether that was a driving motivator or in their top two reasons to transition. I have been critical of comparisons of transitioning to lobotomies while also defending free speech. I have engaged extensively in debates about differences between men and women, arguing that women's biggest restriction is their physical body while men's restrictions are other men, and that in a biological sense women needed men to survive in immediacy. I said I would rather be killed than raped any day, and that I would rather burn in hell for a thousand years than be raped. I am fine looking masculine and if a dude said I looked manly I'd see it as a compliment, and I bulk the hell up at the gym because it does wonders for self-esteem. I also noted that as a masculine woman I still get attention from other women. I have expressed sympathy for people who feel their biological sex is associated with inherently bad or 'sinful' things, telling one person they are NOT shouldered with an original sin for being born male.