Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and identified as trans for a period, going on testosterone for more than half a year. Coming off T, I tapered it off over roughly one to one-and-a-half months, and by early January 2023 I had been off it for about a month when I got my first full period back, with lots of cramps. I had a blood test scheduled and wanted to understand the relationship between my returning periods and my estrogen levels.
The physical residues of testosterone have been a persistent source of frustration. My skin, which had been smooth before, broke out badly around the beard area while I was on T, and afterwards I was left with faded, mole-like spottiness over where my five o'clock shadow sits. I asked whether this would revert on its own and started a skincare routine with vitamin C and acids. I also eventually had laser hair removal, which helped. My voice dropped on T and did not come back; six months off T I was still trying to work out whether my lower register could let me blend into female spaces, and I posted audio clips asking people to compare a "small dog" versus "big dog" voice. Some people told me my voice still sounded female, but in real life it reads as male to most people.
The social fallout has been the hardest part. In February 2023 I noticed I can't win: when I dress femininely with makeup and long hair I get "sir"d," and when I present non-conforming in short hair and men's clothing people ask whether I'm a boy or a girl. I described that as the main annoyance of my "transition residues." In June 2023 I joined an all-women's soccer club for the first time and, while I know I would have felt at home before, I spent the match basically not using my voice because I was frightened people would assume weird things. Afterwards I cried, realizing I had lost my comfort in female spaces and the natural connection that came with it. I carry my male-passing voice "like such a heavy load," and I'm insecure about the fact that even doctors assume I'm male when they hear it.
I've been stuck on voice training. I present androgynously most days and use my "male" voice because forcing a female or androgynous register feels unnatural and like I'm being disloyal to myself — I didn't do it before T, so being told to do it now feels unfair, even though I experience both reverse dysphoria and ongoing dysphoria. I've been looking for casual, non-defensive phrases to explain myself to new people without over-explaining, because I hate being read as a trans woman, gay man, or straight man when I'm actually a woman, especially when it affects dating opportunities and friendships. Before transitioning I thought it would be ideal to be non-binary with people using he/him for me, but I now realize that fantasy translates very differently into real life, and when people tell me they have "gender envy" for me I want to warn them they'd probably be overwhelmed by it too.
On ideology I've become critical. I posted that something being a social construct doesn't mean you can keep the same structure and just demand it perceive you differently, comparing it to age being a social construct without meaning a 30-year-old can identify as five, and arguing that some branches of trans ideology function like a replacement for religious identity. I also reflected on how many of us preface things with "never look down on a woman" while still absorbing the idea that womanhood, emotion, sensitivity and femininity equal weakness. I've pushed back when I think people overgeneralize, though I'll concede a fair point when I see one. I don't consider myself an activist, but I engage in these arguments online and try to be honest about the material reality of what testosterone did to my body. Right now I'm a detransitioned woman navigating an androgynous presentation, a permanently lowered voice, and the ongoing work of reconciling with my body.