Alle verhalen

Testosteron op haar 24e, hysterectomie op haar 32e, en de spijt die volgde

Vrouw · GedetransitioneerdTransitie 21 → Detransitie 323,5K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die vanaf mijn vroege twintig als non-binair en daarna als transman identificeerde, in 2010 met testosteron begon en in 2012 een dubbele mastectomie kreeg. In 2018 had ik een hysterectomie waar ik diepe spijt van heb, vooral omdat ik daardoor geen kinderen kan dragen en me niet bewust was van de gezondheidsrisico's. Ik detransitioneerde in 2020 na het starten van traumagerichte therapie en een diagnose autisme en ADHD op mijn 29e, wat me alternatieve verklaringen voor mijn dysforie gaf. Ik had suïcidale gedachten gerelateerd aan mijn onvruchtbaarheid, al zit ik sinds mijn detransitie over het algemeen mentaal in een veel betere plek. Ik identificeer nu als vrouw, ben kritisch over het concept genderidentiteit en pleit publiekelijk voor detransitiezorg en strengere normen in de gendergeneeskunde.

Volledig verhaal

I'm a detransitioned woman in my mid-30s living in Ontario, Canada. I first identified as nonbinary in my early 20s, and about a year later I realized I wanted to move forward with social and medical transition and started identifying as a trans man. I was prescribed testosterone in October 2010, less than a year after I started identifying as male, and I had a double mastectomy in January 2012, about 14 months later. I was on and off hormones for about five to six years, going off permanently around 2016. Before I was given access to testosterone, I was given a long list of questions to ask myself, and I answered all of them as a way to prove to myself I knew what I was getting into. Spoiler: I didn't. Looking back at my answers from March and April of 2010, I can see that I was hoping transition would fix things it never could — my inability to make friends, my sexuality, my confidence, my happiness. I wrote that I just wanted to be comfortable in the body I had to inhabit for the rest of my life. I was cavalier about fertility back then, writing that if I became sterile, that was the way it was going to be. I ended up having a partial hysterectomy in May 2018, keeping my ovaries, about eight years after starting testosterone. I regret the hysterectomy more than anything else about my transition. No one told me that the uterus has a structural purpose, holding other organs in place and supporting the top of the vagina. Without it, I'm at risk of pelvic prolapse, and studies suggest an increased risk of early-onset dementia even with ovarian conservation. More than anything, I'm devastated that I can't carry my own children. I've looked into IVF and surrogacy and been frustrated by the red tape and the debt involved. I've sought out support groups specifically about limited fertility options because of surgery. I've even pursued legal options, consulting lawyers about whether I have a medical malpractice case, counting from the date I detransitioned under a discovery clause. Several things led me to where I am today. I was diagnosed as autistic at 29, about three years before I made my introductory post here in December 2020. I was also diagnosed with ADHD around the same time, and at one point I was diagnosed with BPD, though I don't believe I meet the criteria anymore. Connecting with other autistic people was a turning point. I'd always used the fact that my 'girlhood' didn't match up with other girls' as a reason I must be trans, but my childhood experiences actually did match up with other autistic girls'. I also realized that the power dynamics I'd seen in social justice groups felt heightened among autistic people, and that I'd seen the same dynamics playing out in trans spaces. My roommate, a detransitioned man, detransitioned while we were living together. He's in this subreddit too. Even so, it took me a very long time to overcome the cognitive dissonance when we talked about being trans. I refused to even look at this subreddit. I was very specifically avoiding the hard conversations. I was in trauma-informed therapy — Internal Family Systems — and I only detransitioned after starting to do trauma work. In IFS terms, I came to understand my transition as a part with more masculine energy taking on a protector role that I identified with strongly for a while. After being in therapy for a couple of weeks, I started re-identifying with my birth sex, though I'd been thinking about it for a long time. When I started experimenting with looking more feminine, I felt a personality switch within minutes — it felt like me in high school. I stopped taking testosterone in 2016 after a dissociative episode while smoking weed, during which I had a vivid daydream of detransitioning and going back to my old name. It took another four years before I was ready to actually detransition. I identified as nonbinary for most of that time, and I didn't consider myself to have detransitioned until I had the internal shift where I realized I was never transgender to begin with. I reject any definition of detransition that doesn't involve reidentifying with your birth sex. I reidentified as a woman about five years after stopping testosterone. What really spurred that was realizing I was denying how many things I had in common with women. Deep within me, I wanted that sense of solidarity and safety back. I didn't want other women to see me as a threat anymore when I knew we were the same. I'd been bullied by other girls as a child, and that was part of wanting to transition. Even though I started connecting with girls in high school, the damage was already done. It took years to recognize and repair. I also think repressed sexuality played a role. It was easier for me to identify as a man than a lesbian. I knew I liked women since I was a teenager, but I had difficulty comprehending sexual attraction, so I identified as asexual, assumed I was attracted to both sexes about the same, and dated men even into my transition. I really only came out in the past couple of years, and I'm 35 now. My experience with women is still limited, but I'm more comfortable with myself. I wrote about my first experience with another woman — the hardest part was being next to her, beautiful and unmarred, and feeling repulsive and broken by comparison. She didn't see it that way. Physically, I passed. I still get called 'sir' by cashiers after detransitioning, and I probably will forever. Detransitioning had nothing to do with the results — it was about realizing the whole thing was a lie. I have sparse facial hair, mostly on my chin and jawline, and I did about ten sessions of laser hair removal that didn't do much. I'm considering electrolysis if I can afford it. My voice is still low. I've dealt with the pain of knowing I could have done something differently, but it helps to know that voice variation across genders is completely natural. I stopped being able to cry on testosterone, and I regained some ability after stopping, but I didn't feel exactly like my pre-T self until I stopped antidepressants this year. I had no libido before or during T, and still none after. I don't hate my bottom growth, though — I don't think I would have learned to enjoy masturbating without it. Mentally, I was in a much better place after detransitioning, but I've had suicidal ideation, especially when dealing with my infertility. When I announced my detransition, I got support from non-trans people, but the half-dozen people I knew who identified as trans didn't say anything at all. The silence is deafening. One of my close friends told me I 'made an ugly girl' when they saw old pictures of me, and I think that factored into my hesitance to detransition. That hurt. The people in my life who know very little about LGBT things have actually been the most supportive. They know who I am now, and they like me for that. I've become critical of the concept of gender identity. I don't think there's empirical evidence that it exists as an innate property, and I consider identifying outside of one's birth sex an ideological choice, akin to religious belief. I was a disillusioned leftist — I would have called myself anarcho-communist. My views are still anti-authoritarian and pro-socialist, but I've become more open to considering criticisms of my views. I'm also gender critical now, which has people accusing me of being right-wing. I've written extensively about my experience on a blog and shared my story publicly, including through the Gender Dysphoria Alliance. I've written briefs to the government advocating for detransition services to be added to gender-affirming health care bills, including insurance coverage for reversal procedures. I've attended detrans events and been in the audience for talks by other detransitioners. I moderate a detrans support community and have been involved in vetting professionals and lawyers who offer services to detransitioners. I've also written about loss to follow-up in transition regret studies and the flawed evidence base for transition. I'm currently in trauma-informed therapy and have taken up hiking and line dancing. I'm trying to figure out a feminine style that still feels like me. I'm still in a sort of crisis-of-faith mode in some ways, but I'm more comfortable with myself than I've been in a long time.