Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde homoseksuele man, geboren midden jaren tachtig, die tot mijn 30e als verwijfd werd gelezen en me nu als homoseksuele man identificeert. Ik geloof dat als ik tien jaar later was geboren, ik waarschijnlijk had gedacht dat ik trans was, deels om te ontsnappen aan de religieuze schaamte die ik voelde over homo zijn en om acceptatie te krijgen van de hetero jongens op wie ik verliefd was. Ik werd jarenlang gepest als het homoseksuele, verwijfde kind, en ik dank het inzicht dat mijn sekse me ongeacht mijn gedrag een man maakte voor het loslaten van innerlijke stress. Ik ben nu sterk kritisch op medische transitie van jongeren, door social media gedreven transidentificatie en gendergeconformeerd denken, en ik heb online gepleit voor detransitioners en twijfelende jongeren. In dit transcript worden geen suïcidale gedachten, zelfbeschadiging of suïcidepogingen beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I was born in the mid-eighties. Growing up, other kids marked me as the gay effeminate kid and bullied me for it for years, both in childhood and in my teenage years. I experienced religious shame at being gay, and I fancied straight boys. I have said that if I had been born a decade later, I would probably have thought I was trans too, to avoid the religious shame I felt at being gay and to gain acceptance as a potential partner from the straight boys I fancied.
I was read as feminine until I hit 30, and I describe that as just an adjective for other people's perception of me rather than something about who I am. I graduated from school at a time when many of my friends had been beaten up in brawls for being gay guys; twelve years later my country and many others had legalised gay marriage. I dated a gay guy in college who had been gender-dysphoric as a child and who grew out of it by the end of puberty and is now a happy gay man.
I identify as a gay man. I have said that what released me from inner stress was recognising that my sex meant I was a man and that my behaviours had no influence or power over that fact. I now think that gender identity as a label is unnecessary — that if you take the label out, what remains is the old spectrum of personality traits, and I am happy being myself.
I hold strongly critical views about the current model of youth transition. I have recommended that people look at figures like Buck Angel and read the book 'Irreversible Damage', arguing that puberty blockers and hormones change the story entirely for the vast majority, and that the effects of testosterone on the body are not reversible. I have pointed to doctors in the UK resigning from the Tavistock clinic over the shift from watchful waiting to an affirmative model, and I have recommended that females in particular wait until they are older, maybe even 25, before making such a choice. I believe the trans identity social contagion would not have been possible without social media, which I see as designed to mine dopamine, hook people into validation, and make them vulnerable to ideological echo chambers and groupthink. I have described what young people caught up in this go through as a form of cult think designed to love-bomb them, promise answers, and silence dissent. I am also critical of the modern obsession with measuring how much of a boy or girl someone is by conformity to gender stereotypes, and of what I see as logically flawed transactivist arguments relying on emotional blackmail, appeal to authority and no true Scotsman fallacies. I do not accept non-binary as a coherent category, though I will accept someone as a man or woman who believes they are neither.
I have been active in advising others online: I have told a young woman who desisted that she is still a woman and asked her what advice she would give to others, I have told a young person asking questions that they are not bad or stupid for asking, and I have congratulated someone for detransitioning, saying they will have saved themselves a lot of pain.