Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerde vrouw uit Rusland die nooit medisch transitioneerde maar sinds mijn tienerjaren wenste man te zijn, deels omdat ik een masculiene tomboy was en een beperkte kijk had op wat een vrouw kan zijn. Mijn moeder adviseerde me te wachten tot ik ouder was voordat ik onomkeerbare lichaamsbeslissingen nam, wat een reden is dat ik een desister ben en geen detrans. Ik werkte eraan masculiniteit los te koppelen van manzijn, leerde mijn gevoelens te behandelen als signalen van onderliggende overtuigingen en niet als waarheden, en vond diepe voldoening in kunst en animatie. Ik voel af en toe nog de wens man te zijn maar lijd er niet meer onder, en op mijn 23e voel ik me veel tevredener met mezelf. Ik presenteer me zeer masculien, ga naar de sportschool en identificeer me als vrouw, ongeacht hoe anderen me zien.
Volledig verhaal
I am a desisted woman — I never medically transitioned, but I experienced wishing to be male starting in my teens. I was a huge tomboy and never looked 'woman-like' enough, and I felt weird about wanting to become a man because of my masculinity. I grew up in Russia. My mom told me that being a teen is hard and confusing in every aspect of life, so I should wait until I was older to make heavy and irreversible decisions about my body — I am grateful for that advice, and it is one of the reasons I am a desister rather than detrans.
What helped me become content with myself was purposefully deciding to detach the concept of masculinity from being a man. I realized my discomfort about being a woman was actually due to my narrow view of what 'a woman' is and can be — the discomfort is real, but its cause is not. I feel it because of what society expects from women, the associations it brings up, and how often an image of 'a woman' is shown everywhere; I don't feel connected to those images and roles. I came to understand that society, and by extension me, are wrong — there is no single 'woman image', vibe, role, or feeling.
I was presented with a choice: continue making myself comfortable with the idea of 'me being a man, actually', or lean into the discomfort of the long process of unlearning the idea that women have a certain vibe I don't feel connected to. I chose the second option because I don't see comfort as the greatest value in my life — I would rather live the truth while feeling discomfort. The worst decisions I've ever made were feelings-based and driven by my seek for comfort, so now I treat feelings as a lead to dig up what internal belief is producing them and whether that belief is actually substantial. I believe final decisions should be informed by as much logic and reality as possible.
I also found my true passion in art and animation, which I got really invested in during my teen years. When I focused on improving my skills or developing a story, I kept forgetting the bitter feelings because my brain was focused on something unrelated to stereotypes, my body, or expectations. My art and work is now what truly makes me feel fulfilled and what I can say is 'me'.
I go to the gym and try to be athletic — it's harder for me to reach the level of strength I want, but I can do quite a lot, and there's some dignity in that. I present very masculine, dress however I like, behave and say what I want without pretending. Sometimes people confuse me for a boy, but I know what I am. I still sometimes get feelings of wishing to be male, but I'm not suffering because of it anymore — it's a bitter feeling that I expect will never fully go away, and I accept that. I have depression and am prone to negative thinking; accepting that these feelings will occasionally show up is a pathway to not letting them control me. I now feel much more content with myself at 23 than I did as a teen.