Alle verhalen

Zes jaar op r/detrans, geen eigen operaties

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd163
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die sinds 2019 actief is in de r/detrans-gemeenschap. Ik heb sterk kritische opvattingen over medische transitie, omschrijf transcultuur als een 'dolle sekte' en waarschuw anderen tegen operaties en hormonen. Ik heb mijn eigen medische geschiedenis in deze berichten niet beschreven, maar ik spreek vanuit de ervaring van het leven als vrouw en het gebruiken van vrouwenruimtes op een universiteitscampus. Ik adviseer anderen regelmatig hun geest te genezen voordat ze hun lichaam veranderen en bied steun aan mensen die zijn gedetransitioneerd. Ik heb geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging gemeld.

Volledig verhaal

I have been posting in the detransition community since at least August 2019, and my comments paint a picture of a woman who has come through transition and now holds strongly critical views of it. I was born female and I identify as a woman; I have never described any medical steps of my own in these posts, so I will not claim any. What I do talk about is how I see transition culture now. I wrote early on that each generation gets socially engineered differently — in the 90s everyone wanted to be stick thin with a flat butt, whereas today girls want to be curvy — and I said that teens unhappy in their bodies today aren't starving themselves, "instead they're getting castrated and sterilized in yet another idealized pursuit." I have described the trans community as a "rabid cult" that inevitably turns on its members, and I said of one writer that my heart goes out to her if she ever sees her "daughter's" internet history and realizes what is truly motivating that transition. I have also given advice directly to people considering or recovering from transition. I told one person to focus on healing their mind "before permanently cutting off important pieces of your body," framing it as a "software problem" while the "hardware is perfectly fine," and I urged them to read stories on the subreddit about people who regretted surgery. I told them that surgery won't turn them into a woman because "a woman is not something you can become, it's something you just are." To someone who had been on testosterone I said they look unmistakably female and that "butch woman is probably the best way to describe how you look," and to another I said they have a naturally pretty feminine face and never really looked like a man, adding that this is what most of the girls on T at my college look like — "just women with facial hair." I sent them strength and prayed for their continued healing. I have been open about my own experiences on a college campus. I mentioned that trans individuals at my college continue using the women's bathrooms, and I described quietly turning around and finding another bathroom when it happens, saying it's not a fight worth having because a college campus is about the last place where a trans individual would be attacked, whereas I would be putting myself in danger by speaking out. I have also written about women who transition into men, saying they don't truly see themselves as men and are "girls playing pretend" with no idea of the burden a man carries. On women's position in society, I wrote that I'm a woman and I've realized I have more power over most men than they have over me, and that many of them can't even look me in the eye. In a heated exchange I told someone that being the victim of a crime has nothing to do with the fact that women in the west have every social advantage over males, and that if you're not in a western country you're likely powerless against males as a woman. I also agreed with a comment about the Titanic and women-and-children-first, and I called a scenario "by definition conversion therapy" and said we have come full circle. I have defended others in the community too — I noted that someone posted a genuine detransition story and was later banned for that very post with no explanation, and I have commented on people's appearances supportively, telling one person their hair is amazing. I also suggested to someone that they can always publish a digital copy of their book on Amazon. I have not described specific therapy, medications, surgeries, or diagnoses of my own in these posts, and I have not described my sexuality, family situation, or current relationship status. What comes through is a woman who has been through transition-related experience, is now firmly critical of transition as offered to young people, and is active in supporting and advising others in the detransition community.