Alle verhalen

Sinds 2019 een supporter in de reacties

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd132
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gendercritische vrouw die niet is gedetransitioneerd en nooit is getransitioneerd; ik kwam in 2019 bij r/detrans als ondersteunende meelezer en reageerder. Ik bewonderde de moed van de gemeenschap, gaf detransitioners aanmoediging over hun lichaam, stem en therapie, en waarschuwde hen te rekenen op brigading van wat ik 'de maffia' noemde. Ik verdedigde ook r/GenderCritical en gendercritische ruimtes tegen kritiek en beloofde vijandig gedrag aan alle kanten te melden. Ik omarm labels als radfem niet meer, al blijf ik de detrans-gemeenschap steunen.

Volledig verhaal

I came to the detrans community in 2019 as an outsider and supporter rather than as someone who had transitioned myself. I was gender critical at the time, though I later said I was 'not radfem (used to be but at this point i dislike all labels)' and described myself as 'usually a lurker (I am GC and trying to understand what is going on with this phenomenon).' I told the community directly: 'I'm not detrans nor am I radfem' and 'I have no other agenda than to be a kind and encouraging commenter,' adding that I respected thread flair and would keep scrolling on posts marked 'detrans only.' I was drawn to the community because I admired its members' courage. I wrote that r/detrans is 'one of the most honest, raw, and human subs I've ever been in' and that 'it takes twice the bravery to detrans than it does to trans in the first place,' saying I had 'never witnessed any hate here.' I expressed full support: 'I fully support the detrans community in whatever way that means to you as a detrans person. I cannot imagine the pain you've walked through but I can be someone who helps create a safe and nurturing environment for you.' I was also politically engaged in gender-critical spaces online. I recommended r/GenderCritical to people who shared those ideals, noting 'the experiences you've attested to are very normal for any person who expresses even minuscule gender critical ideas' and assuring them 'you're absolutely not alone.' I defended the sub against criticism from another regular poster, arguing 'The whole point of the sub is ideological opposition to trans theory,' and pointed out that they had posted there 11 times in the past month and also posted to r/TrollGC, which I described as 'much more overtly toxic than GC and extremely radfem,' concluding 'Methinks the lady doth protest too much.' I also noted that while 'the majority of the sub is very feminist leaning, men are welcome too,' referencing r/gendercriticalguys. I was alert to what I saw as coordinated hostility toward both detrans and gender-critical people. I warned the community to 'Prepare to be brigaded and prepare for false posts to be created and flagged. These are their tactics,' referring to opponents as 'the mafia (you know who you are)' and saying 'anyone going through detrans presents a threat to their worldview.' I committed to constructive behavior: 'for my part I'll do my best to call it out on all sides and report when I see the behavior,' and I suggested rallying the mods to remove horrendous comments more proactively. In giving advice to detransitioners, I was consistently reassuring and encouraging. I told one person worried about being a woman again: 'You can absolutely be a woman again because you're already a woman - you never stopped. Breasts do not make the woman and its nobody's business what's going on under your shirt,' and 'Give yourself time - its OK to forgive yourself. You haven't done anything wrong.' To someone distressed about their voice after stopping hormones, I said 'your body is still adjusting to its own hormone levels... your voice will return to normal,' suggested talk therapy, warm tea and honey, and warned them to stop smoking, sharing that I was a smoker who 'got very sick once, caused permanent damage to my voice.' I encouraged therapy-shopping: 'I usually interview more than one to find one whose services and personality fit me best,' and shared my own experience of a therapist who 'eventually he retired at like 80' and who gave me 'the ability to think on my own two feet and how to recognize when my mind was playing tricks on me.' I also counseled someone struggling with misgendering to practice mindfulness and replace negative thoughts with 'I'm doing my best and so are they.' I disclosed that I have a first name that is 'difficult to spell and difficult to pronounce' and gets 'chopped up all the time,' which I used as an analogy for handling misgendering. Beyond that, I revealed little about my own personal history, family, relationships, or health beyond being a smoker.