Alle verhalen

Zeven jaar op testosteron, en te horen krijgen dat het niet gaat leveren

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd279
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die in 2025 stopte met testosteron na 7 jaar, eind twintig, toen een arts zei dat sommige mensen de resultaten die transitie belooft gewoon nooit krijgen. Ik heb nog steeds lichamelijk dysfoor leed, maar ik ben tot de conclusie gekomen dat medische transitie voor mij een doodlopende weg is, en ik zie een gespecialiseerde therapeut om andere opties te onderzoeken. Mijn stem blijft diep en ik heb 'bottom growth' en wat gezichtsbeharing, maar de rest van de lichamelijke veranderingen draaide binnen ongeveer zes maanden terug. Ik heb mezelf niet vrouwelijk gepresenteerd en neem detransitie in mijn eigen tempo. Ik ben nog dysfoor en gefrustreerd, maar ik meld geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging.

Volledig verhaal

I grew up dysphoric and started medically transitioning in my early-mid 20's. For the first while I could pass for a teen boy, but I was never able to pass as an adult man. By my late 20's, once I could no longer be mistaken for a teenager, I stopped passing altogether. I was on testosterone for 7 years. Throughout, my blood levels were in range and I worked out constantly, but strangers perpetually assumed I was only about 6-8 months or a year into transition. Everyone kept telling me to be patient, that 'HRT works eventually' and that trans men always pass, and they made me feel dramatic for worrying. About half a year ago, one of my doctors finally told me bluntly that 'results happen on a bell curve, and unfortunately, some of you get stuck at the very front' — that for some people it just doesn't happen. After that conversation I went home and really looked at myself and came to terms with the fact that I looked weird: not like a man, but like a woman with something wrong with her. Even though I'm muscular, my shoulder/hip proportions are clearly female, I have tiny hands and feet, plus male-patterned fat distribution and a puffy face. I stopped taking testosterone then. In only six months, visually, it's almost like I never took it — things that took years to build up were gone. The exceptions are my voice, which was the only real noticeable change I ever saw, occasional tweezing of my upper lip, and bottom growth. I'm still massively dysphoric, but now that I know for sure that passing as a man is completely unobtainable for me, I'm trying to cope. I have to accept that I am and will always be a woman, and on top of that a 'weird' one with a deep voice and bottom growth — neither of which ever brought me closer to being male, which is a thought that makes the pit in my chest hurt. I don't know why being seen as a weird woman bothers me when I already wish I weren't one, but it does. My first step was stopping HRT about 6 months ago. My second step has been recently purchasing a bra just to see how it feels, though I haven't worn it yet. My hair has grown out a bit because I haven't cut it in a while, though I'll probably cut it again because I prefer it short. I still wear the same clothes I always have — detransitioning doesn't have to mean being feminine again. I'm not doing anything that makes me uncomfortable, like wearing women's clothes or makeup. I'm seeing a specialized therapist to explore other options for dysphoria now that I know transition is a dead end. On my voice: I tried at first to force myself to sound like I did pre-testosterone and kept being told I sounded like a man poorly imitating a woman. I stopped focusing on pitch and started focusing on how I physically speak through my throat and mouth, copying how deep-voiced women speak — I used a clip of Jessica Rabbit as my initial model. It started to sound natural after a couple of days of talking to myself and narrating what I was doing around my apartment, and I consciously added light vocal fry, which is now automatic. The Voice Tools app registers my speaking voice as male at an average of 147 Hz (120 Hz when relaxed), but the only comments I get are people telling me I should do voice acting or audiobook reading; it reads as female over the phone and in person. The exception is loud environments where I have to project — there I still feel I sound like a man. I don't think it's possible to ever really get a pre-T voice back, but I think it can pass as female again, and others I know who stopped testosterone seemed to experience some voice lightening over time. About 10 years ago, in my teens and early 20's, I was extremely active in my college and community's trans spaces — about 30 people regularly went to the meetups. I recently looked up roughly 20-something of them on social media, and only 7 or 8 haven't 180-degree'd back into presenting entirely within societal norms for their birth sex. At least half of everyone I knew on HRT eventually reached a period where they tried to reverse the effects, even if they don't call it detransitioning. I feel the widespread 'only 2% detransition' claim is disingenuous. I experienced what people call the honeymoon period of transition — that excitement when you start, because transition feels like the first positive thing after an extended period feeling like shit, giving you an explanation for why you feel bad, an actionable goal with observable milestones, identity, community, direction, purpose, and a sense of control replacing helplessness. Mine faded for reasons in line with the detransition survey findings I read: transition did not improve my mental health and I was dissatisfied with the physical results. I'm still physically dysphoric, but I came to the conclusion that medical transition fundamentally cannot fulfill me — I will never be biologically male in the sense I desire, and 'passing and living as a male' isn't enough for me. I'm seeking other options because this one is a logistical dead end. I'm politically left but I do believe the honeymoon effect exists, and I think far fewer people are adequately helped by medical transition than is currently narratively accepted, though I do believe such people exist. I also no longer fundamentally believe in the trans/cis dichotomy — I don't accept a strict trans/cis binary as a description of reality, and I've met people who take HRT and alter their sexual characteristics without their internal identity differing from their birth sex and are satisfied. I've also read Andrea Dworkin and agree with her on most takes, including that 'every transsexual is entitled to a sex-change operation, and it should be provided by the community.'