Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die in mijn vroege tienerjaren als transman identificeerde maar nooit medisch is getransitioneerd omdat mijn familie er niet voor openstond. Mijn dysforie, waaronder inzinkingen omdat ik ‘zij’ werd genoemd, vervaagde geleidelijk nadat ik detrans- en gender-kritische gemeenschappen vond en de wortels ervan doorwerkte in gebeurtenissen uit mijn kindertijd, geïnternaliseerde homofobie en pesten om mijn mannelijke uiterlijk. Ik ervaar op bijna 19 geen dysforie meer en heb vrede met het ‘zij’ genoemd worden. Ik heb nu kritische opvattingen over transitie, vooral voor minderjarigen, en neem deel aan radfem-georiënteerde online ruimtes.
Volledig verhaal
I struggled heavily with dysphoria during about half of my teen years. I was one of those people who would have a full-on breakdown over being called "she." I only identified as a trans man during my early teens, and I never medically transitioned because my family was not open to it. I was fully convinced I would never be happy unless I transitioned.
Several factors fed into my dysphoria. A few really-not-good childhood events and internalized homophobia were the main things I identified as likely causes. I also had low self-esteem and was bullied for "looking masculine as a girl." Even though people made me feel ugly as a girl, I had high hopes of transitioning into a perfect, handsome guy. I think some people transition because being a "different person" makes them separated from their trauma, though I don't think that's a healthy coping mechanism.
Finding communities like r/GenderCritical and detrans-oriented subreddits mattered a lot to me. Had I not looked into subreddits like this, I probably would've still been miserable and intensely dysphoric. It wasn't immediate — it was a gradual process of caring less and less about all the bullshit that was fed to me. I didn't immediately be okay with being called she; for a while I went by they, then they with only close friends being able to call me she, then eventually I had no problem anymore being called she. Today, at almost 19, I no longer struggle with dysphoria.
Sexuality and social dynamics were tangled up in this for me. One of the biggest factors in making me realize I wasn't a man was that I didn't want to be around men (except other trans men). I felt being a "straight guy" didn't suit me, despite wanting to be a guy so badly and only liking women. I related more to being gay in the sense of liking women, but I felt discomfort with being called female and discomfort being called a lesbian while I identified as a trans man. I even started calling myself "gynesexual" since I had no way else to describe it. I didn't act at all like most straight men, and I dated a few girls my age when I identified as trans, and they always expected me to act super intensely macho "dom" and whatnot, which was a huge turn-off.
I never had hormones or surgery, so I have no medical complications or irreversible changes to deal with. I don't describe myself as having a formal diagnosis of anything, though I do think of dysphoria in mental-health terms — I've told others that "it is a mental illness" and that they should try coping through therapy and hobbies instead of hormones or surgery.
I now hold critical views of transition, especially for young people. It especially hurts when I hear stories about 12- or 13-year-olds identifying as trans, even worse when their parents decide to start transitioning them at such a young age. I've had and still talk to friends who are trans, and a lot of the time they like to discount my story as me "just not being a real trans person." I believe there's nothing wrong with being a feminine man and that people need to come to terms with accepting themselves as their birth sex. I've been active on radfem-leaning platforms like Spinster.xyz and Mastodon.