Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die in 2020 op r/detrans kwam terwijl ik me nog als trans identificeerde en 'wanhopig medisch wilde transitioneren', meelezend als 'twijfelaar in mijn eigen transitie' en de gemeenschap peilend naar het vertrouwen en de kennis van anderen vóór medische transitie. In 2020 en 2021 werd ik kritisch over hoe transitie werd gepromoot — ik had bezwaar tegen 'ben ik trans'-tests met één kenmerk, de focus op sociaal gender boven blijvende lichamelijke effecten en het infantiliseren van transmannen — terwijl ik nog steeds het vermogen van kinderen verdedigde om dysforie te herkennen en scheldwoorden in anti-trans berichten afwees. In april 2021 was ik tot de conclusie gekomen dat ik verward was geweest en niet trans, en ik zei tegen een ander 'Je bent nooit een jongen geweest... Je bent een vrouw, en dat is nooit veranderd, je bent gewoon een beetje verdwaald onderweg', wat weergeeft hoe ik nu naar mijn eigen jaren als trans kijk. Ik beschrijf in deze berichten niet dat ik zelf hormonen of operaties heb ondergaan, en ik noem geen medische ingrepen, complicaties of vruchtbaarheidszorgen. Ik beschrijf in dit transcript geen psychische diagnoses, trauma of suïcidale gedachten.
Volledig verhaal
I first came to the r/detrans community in April 2020, but I was not detransitioned at that point — I told people plainly that I was 'not detrans' and that the subreddit's rules were anti-transition and therefore likely biased. At that time I was still identifying as trans and was, by my own later description, 'already desperate to medically transition.' I recommended that someone asking for advice try gender therapy, or, if they didn't want that, try living as female again to see how they felt, and I noted that transition doesn't necessarily mean you can't have biological children because you can freeze your eggs.
I stayed on as a lurker and questioner. In September 2020 I told the community I was 'here as a questioner in my own transition,' that I generally lurked to read others' stories, and that I didn't want to leave comments under a flair that would make people think I was detrans. I said I had trouble feeling sorry for people who did not do their own research, while clarifying I did feel sorry for them and did not intend to shame anyone, and I expressed concern that a fair number of people there had pursued transition without sufficient knowledge about it. I asked whether a 'would be detrans' flair would fit me, then corrected myself after noticing a 'questioning own transition' flair. I also asked what the flairs meant, including 'the lizard one,' explaining I'd given myself a random flair because I didn't know what they meant.
I posted several polls in 2020 asking the detrans community about their birth sex, how confident they were in being trans before beginning medical transition, and how much they knew about the effects of hormones before starting them — questions that suggest I was researching transition carefully before committing to it.
My views during this period were mixed. I called myself 'a trans lurker' and argued with people who, having decided their gender was no longer male, still called themselves trans guys, saying I didn't understand 'this branch of trans people who want to ignore the gender =/= sex that is so heavily repeated in so many places.' I was critical of what I saw as trivialising or pressuring culture around transition: I said I hated trans-supportive posts that claimed a single trait could guarantee someone is trans, arguing that nothing can do that 'without the whole context of their life, let alone given by a stranger on the Internet,' and that such posts trivialise being trans. I also said I disliked how much focus was placed on 'social gender' rather than 'the realistic, permanent, effects on your body,' and I complained that people who infantilise trans men are often the same people eager to cancel others for transphobia while 'blatantly seeing trans men as lesser men than cis men.' On the question of children, I argued that plenty of children can recognise sex dysphoria, though not every child who thinks they do is correct and appropriate therapy should be pursued before any rash decisions, while also objecting to the use of slurs in a post's title.
In October 2020 I advised someone with doubts about upcoming top surgery to hold off, saying there was plenty of time to get it in the future since, unlike testosterone, its effectiveness doesn't decrease with age; I suggested the doubts might relate to an IUD or hormonal fluctuations, or might be worries about surgery, and recommended a therapist or journaling, adding that 'this might be temporary doubts, it might be the start of detransition, but the important thing is not to rush it.'
By April 2021 my position had shifted decisively. When someone described being confused and having thought they were a boy, I told them to get a new therapist because theirs didn't sound fit to deal with gender issues, and I said: 'You were never a boy. Like you said, you were confused... You're a woman, and that never changed, you just got a little lost along the way.' I framed putting the years of thinking you were trans behind you as understandable and possible, comparing it to how trans people aim to put their AGAB life behind them. This is the clearest statement in my posts that I had come to see my own time identifying as trans as a period of confusion to be moved past, and to identify as a woman again.