Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/kritisch ingestelde man in de vijftig die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd, en mijn betrokkenheid komt grotendeels voort uit het ouderschap van een kind dat tegen mijn betere oordeel in is getransitioneerd. Ik heb mijn eigen lichamelijk ongemak in mijn jeugd verwerkt door uit huis te gaan, fulltime te werken en bezig te zijn, in plaats van te transitioneren. Ik steun mijn kind, maar ben privé kritisch over zorg die alleen bevestigt, die ik vergelijk met de behandeling van anorexia en uiteindelijk met de lobotomie. Ik vind dat sekse binair is, dat volwassenen medisch mogen doen wat ze willen, maar dat kinderen nooit gemedicaliseerd mogen worden en dat niemand gedwongen mag worden beweringen over sekse of gender te bevestigen. Ik heb autisme en zie een groot deel van de huidige transbeweging als sekteachtig, tegendraadse rebellie, versterkt door de gemakkelijke toegang tot online hormoonrecepten.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and I have never medically transitioned myself; my involvement in this community comes from being a parent of a child who transitioned, plus my own long-standing discomfort with my body that I worked through without medical intervention.
Growing up, I thought about my body and gender a lot as a kid and a young adult while I still lived at home. I had chain-smoking aunts and a grandmother I was close to whose voices were gravelly and deeper from smoking, and I noticed they were different but it never bothered me as a child. What eventually moved me past my own preoccupation was practical: once I moved out on my own and had to support myself full time, working, paying bills, shopping, cooking, laundry, going out with coworkers, I simply thought about myself far less. It wasn't that the feelings vanished, but they dropped far down my list of worries until they stopped bothering me. I've told others that getting busy was what made it better for me.
On the transition question for my own child: my child came out and wanted to transition. I tried to raise the topic of detransition and got the usual talking points back — that it's a super small percentage of trans people and not worth mentioning. I also suggested that their OCD and neurodivergent nature could be making them think they were trans when they actually weren't, and got called a transphobe for that. At some point I concluded I was past the point of trying to dissuade them and decided I would just try to be supportive regardless of the outcome. They did some kind of online line counseling and received a prescription; I thought it was unethical that a doctor remotely met with and prescribed hormones for someone they'd never physically met, though nothing about it was illegal. We did guide them toward in-person options, but we live in a state that isn't friendly to trans people so there weren't many options and the backlog was long; they got fed up waiting. They don't tell us much and get angry if we ask questions that could be perceived as an attack on their transness or choice. I know how important blood work is and I hope they are getting tests done. I've also said that reading so many FTM stories here, I see my child in so many of them. I've acknowledged that sometimes pain and regret just need to happen, though I hope it works for him. I also recognize the parental bind: often it's a choice between saying nothing or your child going no-contact because you aren't supportive.
My own view is that I have no real problem with trans people, but I think the community has become almost cult-like. I believe anyone who wants to modify themselves because they can't stand their own body has the right to do so, but it doesn't change biology — you're still male or female, just looking more like your preferred gender. I'll use someone's preferred name and pronouns as common courtesy, but I refuse to accept claims that a transitioned person is no different from someone born that sex, or that non-binary, two-spirit, or therian identities are real. For me personally, what stopped any trajectory toward transition was knowing that no matter what I did I would never really be what I wanted to be or look the way I wanted to look; the reality of what was possible versus what I wanted was enough.
I've been critical of how gender dysphoria is treated, comparing it to anorexia — if someone with anorexia were treated the way dysphoria is treated, we'd hand them diet pills and schedule liposuction, which would be malpractice. I've said I honestly believe at some point this healthcare will be seen in the same light as the lobotomy, and that it will take at least another 10 years plus a chorus of detrans people and lawsuits before public opinion shifts. I think affirmation-only care is as effective as abstinence-only sex education, that gender dysphoria should not have been declassified as a mental illness, and that trans is more akin to body image illnesses like anorexia. I'm against children getting cross-sex hormones, puberty blockers, or surgeries; against denial of biological sex; against forcing pronouns; and against sex-segregated spaces based on self-identification. I think adults should be free to medicalize themselves if they want, though I view it as ultimately cosmetic and not something insurance should cover. I also think autism's binary thinking leads some people to conclude they must not be a man or woman because they don't fit their preconceived idea of one.
I have autism — I've referenced 'perhaps it's my autism' when explaining why I think presentation and misgendering should be consistent. I've never been diagnosed with gender dysphoria myself and have never taken hormones or had surgery.