Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw begin veertig, woonachtig in Berlijn, die zichzelf beschouwt als „mentale detransitioner”: ik geloof niet dat ik trans ben en twijfel vaak of trans bestaat, maar ik kies er toch voor een transleven te leiden op een lage dosis testosterongel omdat het me gelukkiger maakt. Ik heb nooit een operatie gehad of mijn ID veranderd, en ik wissel tussen mannelijke en vrouwelijke presentatie afhankelijk van de situatie, en beschrijf mezelf als „een vrouw met een baard”. Ik begon rond mijn 39e met T op een bewust zeer lage dosis, kreeg te maken met atrofie en urineweginfecties die verdwenen met een lagere dosis plus vaginale estradiolcrème, en heb verder geen medische problemen gehad. Ik val uitsluitend op mannen, heb altijd gevoeld dat een butch lesbisch leven bij me zou hebben gepast, en zeg dat ik „gevangen zit in de verkeerde seksuele oriëntatie” en niet in het verkeerde lichaam. Ik heb geen spijt van mijn keuzes, maak me op mijn leeftijd geen zorgen over onvruchtbaarheid en steun de beslissingen van anderen over het algemeen zonder oordeel.
Volledig verhaal
I am a woman who was born female and who has lived much of my adult life presenting in a masculine or 'in between' way. I identify as detrans in my thinking, but I have not stopped living a trans life — I still take a low dose of testosterone and still enjoy being perceived as a guy. I often describe myself as 'a woman with a beard' or 'a woman on testosterone who likes to be perceived as a guy for unknown reasons.'
I am 42 years old (as of April 2023) and started transitioning (female-to-male) three years earlier, so around age 39. I live in Berlin, in an extremely liberal city, and I grew up in the countryside elsewhere in Germany. I have never felt I missed out on anything by not being able to transition earlier in life; in fact it boggles my mind that teenagers and people in their twenties take such life-changing decisions with such absolute confidence. I have barely anything in common anymore with the person I once was — my worldview and perception of myself have changed dramatically over the decades.
I have been on a low dose of testosterone gel for about three years. I deliberately started on a much lower dose than my doctors suggested — basically a fifth — so I could take it very slowly. I chose gel over injections because I was scared of not having control over the changes for weeks or months at a time. I increased the dose for a while but the side effects hit hard pretty soon, so I went back to a low dose and now also use estradiol cream vaginally occasionally. I get my blood work done every six months and everything is in order.
The advantages of the low dose for me: much less PMS and menstrual problems, muscle growth, a deeper voice, increased libido, decreased gender dysphoria, less depression, hair everywhere (which I like), no hair loss, I still get my cycle, no acne, increased self-esteem, and I can pass as male — and also pass as female once I shave and don't bind. The disadvantages: atrophy symptoms, I still menstruate, and clitoral growth, which I don't like. When I briefly increased the dose I got bad atrophy and UTI problems — my body moved into something like menopause, and I got caught in a vicious circle of UTI, yeast infection and bacterial infection that antibiotics often didn't break. Estradiol cream topically plus lactic acid supplements helped a lot. With the lower dose and the estrogen cream I now have no atrophy problems. I also found that T has a strong antidepressant effect on me — I felt so great on it that it initially served as 'reverse proof' to me that I was trans.
I have never had surgery and have never changed my ID documents. Because of that, when in doubt — at passport controls or in a public bathroom — I can easily give 'proof,' which gives me confidence not to care. I switch between male and female presentation as much as I feel like: gym or yoga class, female; barber, male; everyday life in Berlin, male; visiting my parents in the countryside, female; traveling inside the EU, male; traveling outside the EU, female; dentist, male; gynecologist, 'trans male.' I am either read as a cis man or as an extremely gender-nonconforming cis woman (probably a lesbian). All my friends, family and colleagues know, and I mostly go by he/him — not because it matters, but because it feels more natural to them. I am not comfortable being stealth in close relationships; that causes me distress, so I usually let people know as soon as we get closer. If pressured for a label I say I am trans because it is the easiest explanation and probably somewhat true, but I don't announce identity, pronouns or sexuality — I let people draw their own conclusions. I went by a new name only because the old one was so gendered it confused people.
I do not think I am male, and I do not think I am a trans man. I am just a woman who likes to be and present male. More than wanting to be a guy, I have always felt that being a butch lesbian would have been perfect for me — I am not trapped in the wrong body or sex, I am 'trapped in the wrong sexual orientation.' I wish I could use the term butch, but it doesn't quite fit. I have never been into women; I am exclusively attracted to men. I have wondered whether what drives me is androphilia. I have also looked into autoandrophilia since I noticed the discussion is all about autogynephilia and never about autoandro — I can relate to the concept somewhat, but I do not think my 'love' for males and the male body has ever been driven sexually; cross-dressing was never about being turned on in the mirror. I have not made up my mind about these theories and want to read more. I have been with many bisexual AMAB partners in my life and very much enjoyed 'playing gay couple' with a partner before coming out.
I consider myself a mental detransitioner: I don't believe I am trans, I often doubt trans exists or at least think it is a mental disorder, and the gender talk becomes more and more nonsense to me the further I dive into trans logic. I detransitioned in my head at some point but could not be bothered to actually do it, since I still enjoy living as a guy. I don't need to 'believe' in transness to be allowed to live my life in a way that makes me more confident. I feel like an agnostic in a world of atheists and believers in God. I don't think I am harmed by what I am doing, nor am I harming anyone else.
I generally let everyone do whatever they want and don't judge other people's lifestyle choices; unless someone struggles and asks for my opinion I consider people capable of weighing costs and benefits themselves. I am not concerned about my own testosterone intake. I don't care about infertility anymore at 42. I have some health problems but not the ones people raise about T. I am not sure I could keep up this 'in between' life anywhere less liberal than where I live now.
I have advised others considering T to start on a very low dose, use gel rather than injections so nothing happens overnight, and remember that liking T does not mean you have to go further — you don't have to take more, change your name, come out, or have surgery. I have also told people that only while we are afraid of something can we not determine whether we truly dislike it. I have been critical of the absolute confidence young trans people express about irreversible decisions, while disliking older people's 'you'll regret it' talk — I think at least some self-doubt would serve them well. I think 'born this way' is over and that cis heteronormative society has created the very thing young people are escaping. I appreciate the detransition subreddit for its 'compassionate level-headedness.'